Purpl's attempt to get conversation started
It's a big risk to lynch a strong player on Day 1, especially one that posts a lot and actually contributes to the thread.
If we lynch Superpenguin today, could you fully guarantee he flips mafia or third party? If so please tell me why you think so and I'll gladly vote for him. I don't see the reasoning behind the semi-bandwagon on SP. Why would mafia put attention on themselves? I don't see the evidence you have on him, as far as I understand it's he 1) rubbed people the wrong way, 2) attacked a new player, 3) talked to people in the IRC.
The only reasons why I (and I'm sure many other people too) pushed off voting for him is 1) I don't see his current behavior lined up with scum behavior, 2) There are other better lynch candidates today, 3) If we wait a day we can analyze his posts to come to a definite conclusion.
Bolded parts - so you're saying little evidence is enough to get him lynched with hardly any questioning? If it's a player like say, Cory, then sure I agree he would get lynched without any questioning. This isn't the case though.
Karen. Think about this. If you were mafia, you would want to look pro-town, yes? So you would employ tactics to make you look like Town, such as drawing attention to yourself.
Maybe now we know to watch for the quick bandwagons as that should give us clear warning signs we are lynching wrong.
As much as I hate to agree with Superpenguin, this is right.
That was pretty obvious, you idiots should be happy it wasn't a blue role.
I just wanted to point out I just received notification I was saved from Starvation. Thanks to whichever of you Bakers did that, and hopefully I'll be in contact with you sometime soon (aka pls pm me but you don't have to). This means I'm doing good enough to for at least some town to trust me.
I'd appreciate getting in contact with some Detectives, but I know that isn't really possible right now. Here's a list of people who I personally would like to get inspected. Please remember that there are roles that can frame in this game - choose wisely.
-Superpenguin
-BlueLeaf
-Oath2order
-Ashtot
-BellBringerGreen
I agree with this list, and I think Superpenguin needs to be inspected the most urgently, due to the evidence Trundle, a few others and I posted previously.
Every 5 mini mafia games, a mafia is lynched day one.
Prin has been posting one-liners all game, and it is kind of making me suspicious. She has been bringing up points that don't have anything to do with mafia, and is overall giving me scummy vibes.
I can understand why I was on the list, of course. Superpenguin, yes. BlueLeaf, maybe. BBG and Ashtot? I don't get why they need to be inspected, tbh.
Yeah, I don't understand why BBG needs to be inspected. I understand you never get vibes from him, Trundle, but I feel it would be beneficial to have him rolechecked as a last resort, if the detectives don't have suspicions.
There wasn't a point. It was just a answer to a question.
Anyway, who does everybody thing is a prime target for the Starvation/Pestilence? The horsemen may seek to kill off town using that way. I'm going to try and make a list with a couple of players who may have higher chances of being targeted.
Once again, another pointless post. Prin, if you had been reading the thread, we said the stronger players are more likely to be targeted.
Mainly this post:
Where you were all against lynching Superpenguin for the presented evidence but were all for Dolby, even though he is known to be a terrible town player and exhibited terrible playing once again. You think for yourself when it comes to Superpenguin's lynch but follow blindly when it comes to Dolby? That's what raises suspicion in my eyes.
I agree with this, personally.
- - - Post Merge - - -
You realize War is in this game, right, a player who can frame a player every night?
You realize there is more than one detective, right?
