Mafia TBT Mafia IX: The Apocalypse [Game Over/Town Win]

[Superpenguin]

You realize there is more than one detective, right?

It's not known for sure if there is or not, but I figured there would be since the Psychic is not a specifically named role like it could've been. However, the Framer doesn't frame a Detective, they frame a person, and that person returns Demon to ALL rolechecks even if both Detectives roelcheck that same person. Which, by the way, having both Detectives check the same person is stupid.

Everyone has been urging me to get inspected. At least acknowledge the fact that I now have a good chance of getting framed. Read my posts and determine my alignment that way; it shouldn't be that hard to see. Have the watcher watch me at first and then inspect me when War is out of the picture or at a night where you aren't all posting publicly to inspect me guiding War into framing the right person.

 

[PurplPanda]

It's not known for sure if there is or not, but I figured there would be since the Psychic is not a specifically named role like it could've been. However, the Framer doesn't frame a Detective, they frame a person, and that person returns Demon to ALL rolechecks even if both Detectives roelcheck that same person. Which, by the way, having both Detectives check the same person is stupid.

Everyone has been urging me to get inspected. At least acknowledge the fact that I now have a good chance of getting framed. Read my posts and determine my alignment that way; it shouldn't be that hard to see. Have the watcher watch me at first and then inspect me when War is out of the picture or at a night where you aren't all posting publicly to inspect me guiding War into framing the right person.

Yes. Ok. Let's think about this. Let's assume there is one Framer, and 2+ detectives. They frame you Night 1, and the first detective's rolecheck comes back as Town/Mafia/Third Party. The next day, detective 2 inspects you, and your inspection comes back opposite. Which do we follow? The second.

 

[Superpenguin]

Yes. Ok. Let's think about this. Let's assume there is one Framer, and 2+ detectives. They frame you Night 1, and the first detective's rolecheck comes back as Town/Mafia/Third Party. The next day, detective 2 inspects you, and your inspection comes back opposite. Which do we follow? The second.

Yeah, that is a good plan. Except the same Detective can actually inspect a player twice in a row. There is no limit to how many times in a row Detectives can inspect players this game. War can't frame the same person twice in a row, however.

 

[PurplPanda]

Yeah, that is a good plan. Except the same Detective can actually inspect a player twice in a row. There is no limit to how many times in a row Detectives can inspect players this game. War can't frame the same person twice in a row, however.

So you aren't objecting to inspection? Detectives, I ask that one of you inspect Superpenguin twice in a row. You of course have no idea who each other are, so I suggest strong players and weak players (who are detectives) inspect him, so that way we can have a sort of way of choosing our detectives.

 

[BlueLeaf]

Yes. Ok. Let's think about this. Let's assume there is one Framer, and 2+ detectives. They frame you Night 1, and the first detective's rolecheck comes back as Town/Mafia/Third Party. The next day, detective 2 inspects you, and your inspection comes back opposite. Which do we follow? The second.

Couldn't Framer/War frame the second inspection instead? In one scenario, SP could flip Town Night One, then flip Mafia (framed) Night Two. If we do what you're saying, SP could be lynched when he's actually Town.

Mafia/Horsemen are definitely going to try and confuse us, so there's no telling which inspection they will frame. It still is an effective plan, but can blow up in our face.

 

[Superpenguin]

Couldn't Framer/War frame the second inspection instead? In one scenario, SP could flip Town Night One, then flip Mafia (framed) Night Two. If we do what you're saying, SP could be lynched when he's actually Town.

Mafia/Horsemen are definitely going to try and confuse us, so there's no telling which inspection they will frame. It still is an effective plan, but can blow up in our face.

If I return town the first check, I am essentially cleared of being a Horsemen, though still could potentially be the godfather. But at the moment, I think the majority of the suspicion on me has been in regards to people thinking I am, in specific, Famine.

 

[PurplPanda]

Couldn't Framer/War frame the second inspection instead? In one scenario, SP could flip Town Night One, then flip Mafia (framed) Night Two. If we do what you're saying, SP could be lynched when he's actually Town.

Mafia/Horsemen are definitely going to try and confuse us, so there's no telling which inspection they will frame. It still is an effective plan, but can blow up in our face.

Then we do it three times. Whatever will prove SP's innocence or scumminess. Unless he can provide sufficient evidence, I will still be keeping my suspicions.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If I return town the first check, I am essentially cleared of being a Horsemen, though still could potentially be the godfather. But at the moment, I think the majority of the suspicion on me has been in regards to people thinking I am, in specific, Famine.

I support these suspicions, actually. You could have given Trundle hunger to kill him off, knowing that I would probably be lynched later on during the game.

 

[Superpenguin]

Then we do it three times. Whatever will prove SP's innocence or scumminess. Unless he can provide sufficient evidence, I will still be keeping my suspicions.

Three inspections is not necessary and is just going to hold town back. I'm sure I'll be proven on the first check tonight.

 

[PurplPanda]

I am now in contact with a blue role, one which will help us figure out whether or not SP is mafia, third party, or town. We now do not have to worry about the framers.

 

[oath2order]

Why would they role claim to you?

 

[PurplPanda]

Why would they role claim to you?

They said they trusted me, and supported my suspicions of SP.

 

[Sataric]

We must wait and see what new evidence we will have once morning comes - And if we're lucky, the Servants of Hell and the Horsemen will be taking each other out tonight. I feel that it is unwise to discuss details regarding which targets we have in mind to investigate, seeing as there is a Framing role amongst our opponents, and with so many killing roles stacked against us we really do not have the time to keep re-investigating the same targets too much. I still find SuperPenguins behavior very suspicious, but the fact that he did not decide to lynch Dolby does makes me a tad uncertain.

 

[toastia]

I am now in contact with a blue role, one which will help us figure out whether or not SP is mafia, third party, or town. We now do not have to worry about the framers.

Where did this blue role magically come from? Why would they message you simply because of SP's prominent suspection when many others have already said the same thing before you? I'm just eager to find out they why they would roleclaim to you.

- - - Post Merge - - -

They said they trusted me, and supported my suspicions of SP.

I'm going through to look for these now.
I still don't see why they would roleclaim to you, even.

 

[PurplPanda]

[Prin;2870011]Where did this blue role magically come from? Why would they message you simply because of SP's prominent suspection when many others have already said the same thing before you? I'm just eager to find out they why they would roleclaim to you.[/QUOTE]
Magic? Roleclaiming is part of the game.

I'm going through to look for these now.
I still don't see why they would roleclaim to you, even.

Ok, so I post one one liner, and all except about 2 of your posts are one-liners. Ok, Prin.

 

[toastia]

Where did this blue role magically come from? Why would they message you simply because of SP's prominent suspection when many others have already said the same thing before you? I'm just eager to find out they why they would roleclaim to you.

Magic? Roleclaiming is part of the game.

Ok, so I post one one liner, and all except about 2 of your posts are one-liners. Ok, Prin.[/QUOTE]
You've posted more then one, Purpl. Why is that relevant here?
I looked through your posts, and it appears you've made a mafia/horsemen plan. While I personally think it's a great plan, they is the idea that there is not more than one detective. In this case, I would find it kind of a loss to use two rolechecks on the same person. However, if it will help us find scum that way rather than hold us back, then I'm all for it!

Appearently, I just can't see why anyone would roleclaim to you.

 

[PurplPanda]

It is relevant because literally half of your posts are one-liners. Literally. 14 of your 28 posts. Lets go check my posts, shall we?

 

[EpicGamer12]

Yo can you two shut up about one-liners. It doesn't matter.

 

[toastia]

You just said Rest in peace in peace. Sorry, it was bothering me.

It was a joke. Don't take anything I say about Minties seriously.

There are game links on the OP, if you are interested. I have read through a lot of them myself.

What was his roleclaim?

Guys omg reply I'm so scared
like I'm trembling
Did I do something wrong

Yeah, still less than me, but you haven't posted just one. Just proving my point here.
Also, I'm asking you legitamate questions, and you flat out ignore me and bring up my posts. So what? I doubt that someone actually roleclaimed to you. I think you just want to make everyone think that.

 

[PurplPanda]

Ok. Arguments aside, we probably need to get conversation started.

- - - Post Merge - - -

[Prin;2870011]Where did this blue role magically come from? Why would they message you simply because of SP's prominent suspection when many others have already said the same thing before you? I'm just eager to find out they why they would roleclaim to you.

Magic? Roleclaiming is part of the game.

Ok, so I post one one liner, and all except about 2 of your posts are one-liners. Ok, Prin.[/QUOTE]

Ok, so I post one one liner, and all except about 2 of your posts are one-liners. Ok, Prin.

You've posted more then one, Purpl. Why is that relevant here?
I looked through your posts, and it appears you've made a mafia/horsemen plan. While I personally think it's a great plan, they is the idea that there is not more than one detective. In this case, I would find it kind of a loss to use two rolechecks on the same person. However, if it will help us find scum that way rather than hold us back, then I'm all for it!

Appearently, I just can't see why anyone would roleclaim to you.[/QUOTE]

Yeah, still less than me, but you haven't posted just one. Just proving my point here.
Also, I'm asking you legitamate questions, and you flat out ignore me and bring up my posts. So what? I doubt that someone actually roleclaimed to you. I think you just want to make everyone think that.

O rly bc it looks 2 me like I have answered ur questions

 

[Ashtot]