Mafia TBT Mafia V: There and Back Again [Game Over/Town Win]

[Blu Rose]

At the moment there's a good deal of worthless blabbering going on. Blu Rose, you still haven't answered. Why do you have suspicion on Lunatic and TheCreeperHugz? Lunatic has been pro-town all game, with some suspicion on beary509 from Day One.

I answered your question, thank you very much.
Go back and check:

I took forever on you, so, stop undermining me. What you could say about your case applies to Waffles' case in Game IV that I made.

I suspect Lunatic and TheCreeperHugz because they both voted "No Lynch" on Day 1, and this just screamed Mafia to me, but apparently, me only.

 

[toastia]

I am not scum.

Right.... care to expand on that?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I don't have a reason not to believe your not scum. PM circles, messaging, lying, just screams mafia.

 

[Beary]

Whoops I might have lied in order to get some answers from you. Looks like it worked.

You can try saying why they have to explain themselves.

You tricked me.
Very well, I may say.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Whoops I might have lied in order to get some answers from you. Looks like it worked.

Right.... care to expand on that?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I don't have a reason not to believe your not scum. PM circles, messaging, lying, just screams mafia.

Care to explain how I have lied?

 

[FanousOnTheLoose]

So essentially we're going around in circles. No bueno.

Here are the five names involved:

Oath2Order
Justin (removed quickly from KarlaKGB's list - frame or not?)
Prin
Beary509
Blu Rose

Someone has to get lynched. None of these particular names HAVE to get lynched. We don't have anyone better to suggest yet. If other Town players can put in their opinion of these 5 names (doesn't have to be all 5, just what you know / can think of) then please do so. We need to work together to get someone lynched, and we still have a whole day. C:

Get Oath off the list. Me and him have had a couple IRC chats and I'm getting a town vibe from him instead of mafia one.

Nothing to say about Justin.

I've had mild suspicions on Prin for awhile. His playstyle is just weird and his defenses seem to simplified, nor really much depth to them.

Beary is just a weak mafia player (sorry) and I feel like we are just picking her apart, but things are getting fishy with her and Blu. I mean Beary added Prin to her contact list like 5 posts ago just because Prin accused her of mafia. She's getting desperate.

 

[toastia]

Um... me and beary chat about other things than mafia you know...
Also, I am a her.

 

[Beary]

Get Oath off the list. Me and him have had a couple IRC chats and I'm getting a town vibe from him instead of mafia one.

Nothing to say about Justin.

I've had mild suspicions on Prin for awhile. His playstyle is just weird and his defenses seem to simplified, nor really much depth to them.

Beary is just a weak mafia player (sorry) and I feel like we are just picking her apart, but things are getting fishy with her and Blu. I mean Beary added Prin to her contact list like 5 posts ago just because Prin accused her of mafia. She's getting desperate.

Desperate? Quite the contrary. I'm just getting started.

She PMed me, and is still doing so, therefore, she has contacted me.
You, Prin, and Trundle seem to be ganging up on me.
Explanations?

 

[Ashtot]

Get Oath off the list. Me and him have had a couple IRC chats and I'm getting a town vibe from him instead of mafia one.

Nothing to say about Justin.

I've had mild suspicions on Prin for awhile. His playstyle is just weird and his defenses seem to simplified, nor really much depth to them.

Beary is just a weak mafia player (sorry) and I feel like we are just picking her apart, but things are getting fishy with her and Blu. I mean Beary added Prin to her contact list like 5 posts ago just because Prin accused her of mafia. She's getting desperate.

In my opinion, Beary and Blu are both either mafia, or just terrible players. Even if they aren't mafia, they're helping the mafia by distracting us from a real problem if they really are town.

And Beary an explanation would be that we are ganging up on you.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

Get Oath off the list. Me and him have had a couple IRC chats and I'm getting a town vibe from him instead of mafia one.

Nothing to say about Justin.

I've had mild suspicions on Prin for awhile. His playstyle is just weird and his defenses seem to simplified, nor really much depth to them.

Beary is just a weak mafia player (sorry) and I feel like we are just picking her apart, but things are getting fishy with her and Blu. I mean Beary added Prin to her contact list like 5 posts ago just because Prin accused her of mafia. She's getting desperate.

Just because you've got a vibe from him doesn't mean he's in the clear. Mafia ought to be acting like town to avoid suspicion while killing off the strong and keeping us busy with distractions like Prin, Beary509, and Blu Rose. Sure one of those might be scum, but there's no convincing argument for any of them other than they're stumbling over their word vomit.

 

[Beary]

In my opinion, Beary and Blu are both either mafia, or just terrible players. Even if they aren't mafia, they're helping the mafia by distracting us from a real problem if they really are town.

You all made me a distraction.
Thank you for insulting me. I have a disorder that makes it hard for me to read other peoples intentions.
Problem?

 

[toastia]

Yes, I have contacted beary since we've posted. Talking about mafia... etc... why I think she is mafia...

Her only answers seems to be, "Prove it."
Why don't you prove yourself, beary?

 

[EpicGamer12]

Desperate? Quite the contrary. I'm just getting started.

She PMed me, and is still doing so, therefore, she has contacted me.
You, Prin, and Trundle seem to be ganging up on me.
Explanations?

I kinda think you're scum, I have my brother's (You) trust, and Prin seems the least scummy of everyone here.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Switching my vote to beary509 for the time being

 

[Ashtot]

You all made me a distraction.
Thank you for insulting me. I have a disorder that makes it hard for me to read other peoples intentions.
Problem?

It's mafia, the whole point is to make it hard for people to read your intentions. I don't mean to be so harsh but it just seems to be the only explanation.

 

[Beary]

I kinda think you're scum, I have my brother's (You) trust, and Prin seems the least scummy of everyone here.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Switching my vote to beary509 for the time being

Omfg, the entire town are downright idiots.
You, please explain what information you were trying to get out of me?

 

[BellGreen]

Omfg, the entire town are downright idiots.
You, please explain what information you were trying to get out of me?

If you're town as much as you say you are, you're including yourself.

 

[Blu Rose]

Ugh, I'll just shush for now...

Apparently, my "word vomit" is too much as of the moment.

 

[Beary]

If you're town as much as you say you are, you're including yourself.

Yep. Im pretty stupid, according to You.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'll be laughing so hard when you guys lynch me and I turn out to be town.

 

[toastia]

You tricked me.
Very well, I may say.

- - - Post Merge - - -





Care to explain how I have lied?

Beary, I have been in contact with the detective too. And your PM's show that your not telling the truth.

The detective has already checked me, and he said that I was green. If I was being framed, wouldn't I have returned red? If I was mafia, wouldn't I have returned red?
You said that you were in contact with the detective, and he sent me back red.
I think you are scum trying to see if I'll fall for your little trick.

There's my response to that last question.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'll probably vote to lynch you Day 3, beary.

 

[Beary]

There's my response to that last question.

Care to prove that you have been checked?
And who is this detective you claim checked you?

 

[Byngo]

So essentially we're going around in circles. No bueno.

Here are the five names involved:

Oath2Order
Justin (removed quickly from KarlaKGB's list - frame or not?)
Prin
Beary509
Blu Rose

Someone has to get lynched. None of these particular names HAVE to get lynched. We don't have anyone better to suggest yet. If other Town players can put in their opinion of these 5 names (doesn't have to be all 5, just what you know / can think of) then please do so. We need to work together to get someone lynched, and we still have a whole day. C:

So I've caught up on the past pages, here's my opinions:

Oath2Order: I haven't noticed anything that would indicate he's red.
Justin: Basically, I agree that it is odd Karla took him of his list rather quickly.
Prin: When I read Blu Roses accusation post, some of those things he pointed out made sense.
Blu Rose: I find him to be the most alarming, right now. I did say Blu Rose's accusation post made sense to me, but at the same time, Blu Rose is a smart player. (In my opinion, at least) So he is easily capable of making convincing post to throw off suspicion of himself.
Beary: I explained my thoughts of Beary here.
My own added player: River She still lingers in the back of my mind, but other people are looking more suspicious right now.

Overall, Blu Rose is seeming like the reddest person here. I'm confident enough with all the evidence brought forth to send in a vote for him.

 

[toastia]

Care to prove that you have been checked?
And who is this detective you claim checked you?

I'll answer your question if you answer mine. You've been avoiding this question for a while now.

Care to prove yourself, beary? How can you message me saying I have been checked, than ask me can I prove I've been checked?