Mafia TBT Mafia V: There and Back Again [Game Over/Town Win]

[toastia]

If you really are town, you seem to be more interested in saving your own neck.

 

[Beary]

If you really are town, you seem to be more interested in saving your own neck.

Aren't we all?

 

[toastia]

I would rather die if it would benefit town, but since I am town, it wouldn't help town at all.
You, on the other hand, would rather live whether it would benefit town or not.
You haven't actually asked me any questions originally, your just directing questions that I ask you back at me.
Got any evidence that I should be lynched?

 

[iLoveYou]

Here are people that the Town can't forget are playing the game:

Minties
Jeremy
Justin
LaurinaMN
SirGanatar

FireNinja1
TheCreeperHugz

From that list I am most worried about:

Minties
Jeremy
Justin

If we look at this entire situation from another angle, we could equally be dealing with 3 Townies here. If the Mafia think this will be our final lynch then they are wrong.

I am most likely going to switch my vote off of Blu Rose. There are other ways to deal with them.

 

[Beary]

I would rather die if it would benefit town, but since I am town, it wouldn't help town at all.
You, on the other hand, would rather live whether it would benefit town or not.
You haven't actually asked me any questions originally, your just directing questions that I ask you back at me.
Got any evidence that I should be lynched?

You are aggressive.
And dead set on getting me and/or Blu Rose lynched.
Basically, the same reasons as you.

 

[toastia]

You are aggressive.
And dead set on getting me and/or Blu Rose lynched.
Basically, the same reasons as you.

I learned this earlier: it doesn't matter if you are aggressive or not.
Take SP, he's aggressive, yet he isn't being targeted ATM.

Whats wrong with being set on getting people lynched? You seem set on getting me lynched, don't you?
Obviously there's other reasons than the ones I'm coming up with for you. Care to tell me what they are?

 

[Superpenguin]

To be honest, I'd like to lynch one of either Blu Rose, Beary509, or Prin just because we can't go through every future lynch with these three bickering like this. They need to be broken up for Town's sake. Which ever one gets a majority, I'll happily add my vote to.

 

[Beary]

To be honest, I'd like to lynch one of either Blu Rose, Beary509, or Prin just because we can't go through every future lynch with these three bickering like this. They need to be broken up for Town's sake. Which ever one gets a majority, I'll happily add my vote to.

*raises hand*
I advise lynching Prin.

 

[toastia]

If I get a strong vibe about a different person, I might change my vote. But for now, I'm sticking with beary and blu.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Primarily beary.

 

[Blu Rose]

If Prin is lynched, then she would stop accusing us both.
Beary and I are currently at peace, here...

 

[BellGreen]

Beary is near majority so most likely her, but anyone else is fine. It's really clogged up with these accusations.

 

[toastia]

If you or beary is lynched, I can stop trying to lynch you both.
To tell the truth, I'm just going after who I think is acting scummy.

 

[Beary]

My gameplay is usually altered by how I feel. When I was town, I was very open and active. When I was mafia, I hardly ever posted.

^^^

 

[BellGreen]

^^^

You're only active due to how you're being accused in my opinion.

 

[Beary]

You're only active due to how you're being accused in my opinion.

Sure.
I'm going to laugh at you guys when I come out town/miller.

 

[iLoveYou]

Essentially I think we should take the risk on players like Minties ( I love you girl <3 pls no mad :c ) or Justin.

Blu Rose, Beary509, Prin: Please be careful with who you are PM'ing. For some odd reason, your PMs seriously coincide with how the Mafia made their moves on Night One. If this is a coincidence, then wow. If it's not, it'll be caught on really quickly. If anyone new tries to PM you, you need to bring their name forward immediately.


We should also pay attention to those who didn't vote Day One:

- TheCreeperHugz
- LaurinaMN
- FireNinja1
- Mary

Hikari seems to be more Town aligned which is why I left him out. These people on the list are seriously flying under everyone's radars. Disinterested Townies? Maybe. If I forgot anyone else, lemme know.

 

[BellGreen]

And I will be laughing along with him if I get lynched.

I'm laughing so hard at you guys.

I'll be laughing so hard when you guys lynch me and I turn out to be town.

Sure.
I'm going to laugh at you guys when I come out town/miller.

Oh my gosh, we get it already. I feel like you're running out of things to say and are waiting for more accusations.

 

[FanousOnTheLoose]

To be honest, I'd like to lynch one of either Blu Rose, Beary509, or Prin just because we can't go through every future lynch with these three bickering like this. They need to be broken up for Town's sake. Which ever one gets a majority, I'll happily add my vote to.

I'm getting to that point now. They need to shut up all of them or find a way to agree or something. There back and forth one/two liners are getting annoying to read. Now to think about which piece of the triangle to get rid of and make this game easier for all of us.

 

[Justin]

I still think we should lynch River and my vote remains on her. I'm re-quoting my post from earlier as I strongly believe she is the Serial Killer and the post seems to have gotten looked over. I saw no arguments against it either.

I would like to bring back the topic of the supposed River fake claim of Serial Killer. Let me lay out this first: I believe that River is lying about it being a fake claim test, and that she actually did legitimately claim Serial Killer to Kayla, among possibly other players such as Tom. I believe that she is actually the Serial Killer and we should lynch her today, unless we can find scum first today.

Why?

River claims that her claim to Kayla was fake and supposed to test Kayla's ability to be quiet with sensitive information that should not shared with everyone. To be honest, this wouldn't be a terrible idea... except the choice of role to claim as!!! As previously discussed, the Serial Killer's interests directly conflict ours. Therefore the Serial Killer should be killed eventually if possible. This cannot happen if the Serial Killer is not known. (well it can, but you know what I mean, obviously it is easier we know!) In my opinion, any player should out a Serial Killer. In fact, I would be more suspicious of Kayla if she did not out River's claim.

Point is: The Serial Killer is a terrible role to fake claim as for this supposed test. If River truly intended this as a fake claim, she would have picked a different role to use. The fake claim setup is a clever lie to cover her ass after Kayla outed her as she should have. (which seems to have worked to some degree as the discussion has completely turned away from her)

I'm voting to lynch River today. If some other information comes to light on a potential Mafia instead, I'll consider changing to that. But otherwise, I'd like to rid us of the Gollum (Serial Killer) distraction River.

 

[toastia]

Sure.
I'm going to laugh at you guys when I come out town/miller.

Well, if you are the miller, how would that help us?