Mafia TBT Mafia V: There and Back Again [Game Over/Town Win]

[Beary]

Oh my gosh, we get it already. I feel like you're running out of things to say and are waiting for more accusations.

I'm repetitive. Sorry.

I'm getting to that point now. They need to shut up all of them or find a way to agree or something. There back and forth one/two liners are getting annoying to read. Now to think about which piece of the triangle to get rid of and make this game easier for all of us.

Yes, please. I don't care who you lynch. I'm just tired.

 

[iLoveYou]

To be honest, I'd like to lynch one of either Blu Rose, Beary509, or Prin just because we can't go through every future lynch with these three bickering like this. They need to be broken up for Town's sake. Which ever one gets a majority, I'll happily add my vote to.

I do agree that these three need to be broken up for Town's sake as well. We heard earlier in the thread that there is a Vigilante with multiple shots. This Vigilante needs to consider breaking up these three for us. If you have a different game plan to follow, then by all means go for your own game plan. These three can be left for later, I guess. Generally I think these 3 do need to be broken up though.


I think it's wise to take the risk on Minties or Justin.

 

[Blu Rose]

Yes, good call.

It can be any of us though, and, rightnow, it looks like I'm on the highway.

 

[toastia]

Alright, Il take anymore acusatsiobs I have to PM. I agree I am getting tired of this. I might change my vote ti River. I trust justin.

 

[Superpenguin]

I still think we should lynch River and my vote remains on her. I'm re-quoting my post from earlier as I strongly believe she is the Serial Killer and the post seems to have gotten looked over. I saw no arguments against it either.

River is responsible for the death of Karla, at least that is what I saw it as.
We all know she is a Serial Killer, so she obviously isn't going to win. I don't think she'd turn on any of us, at least not tonight, so we can let her pass for now. We can even ask her to refrain from shooting anyone if we are scared about extra shots.

 

[Justin]

River is responsible for the death of Karla, at least that is what I saw it as.
We all know she is a Serial Killer, so she obviously isn't going to win. I don't think she'd turn on any of us, at least not tonight, so we can let her pass for now. We can even ask her to refrain from shooting anyone if we are scared about extra shots.

There are far more town and than scum, so statistically she is more likely to hurt us than them. She will turn on us eventually, she has to to win (and if she's not, then I question whether she should be allowed to play, going directly against Play to Win in the rules), so why not get it out of the way now and not worry about extra possible town deaths from her in the future. You guys don't seem to have much of solid case on any Mafia today anyway. As far as I can tell, Beary/Prin/Blu Rose, none of them have any particularly damning to them, so honestly chances are it's just gonna be another random town death by the looks of it.

Although it doesn't look at this point I'm going to be able to change your minds anyway, you all seem pretty set on allowing the SK to roam free and hit a random town lynch while we're at it. I'll just be sitting over here watching then.

 

[Blu Rose]

I'm just going to say two things...

(1) I just realized that we still have 23 hours until Day ends. Teaches me to play Tina's Mini Mafia.

(2) I say we keep telling River who to kill, but then, if she does not kill the person we instruct, then we lynch River.
To me, it's blackmail, but, we're playing Mafia, non?

 

[FanousOnTheLoose]

I'm just going to say two things...

(1) I just realized that we still have 23 hours until Day ends. Teaches me to play Tina's Mini Mafia.

(2) I say we keep telling River who to kill, but then, if she does not kill the person we instruct, then we lynch River.
To me, it's blackmail, but, we're playing Mafia, non?

These should be done by PM's rather than publicly on here. Assuming River is SK then mafia will just avoid killing that person because River is supposed to take care of it.

 

[Blu Rose]

These should be done by PM's rather than publicly on here. Assuming River is SK then mafia will just avoid killing that person because River is supposed to take care of it.

Well, what I mean is, we tell River to kill suspects, of course through PM, but then, if she kills the wrong person, then we lynch her, so that the Mafia can get killed, and then we eventually lynch River...

I feel so bad for using River, though...

Assuming, of course, that River is the SK.

 

[FanousOnTheLoose]

I like this plan that Blu has come up with. And I think we should give it a chance before we lynch River.

 

[Ashtot]

I agree, definitely worth a shot.

 

[Superpenguin]

There are far more town and than scum, so statistically she is more likely to hurt us than them. She will turn on us eventually, she has to to win (and if she's not, then I question whether she should be allowed to play, going directly against Play to Win in the rules), so why not get it out of the way now and not worry about extra possible town deaths from her in the future. You guys don't seem to have much of solid case on any Mafia today anyway. As far as I can tell, Beary/Prin/Blu Rose, none of them have any particularly damning to them, so honestly chances are it's just gonna be another random town death by the looks of it.

Although it doesn't look at this point I'm going to be able to change your minds anyway, you all seem pretty set on allowing the SK to roam free and hit a random town lynch while we're at it. I'll just be sitting over here watching then.

You do make a good point here. We found a Serial Killer, so why don't we just lynch her, especially since we are at a complete loss when it comes to mafia suspicions. The longer we keep River alive, the more kills we'll have to endure each night, and who's to say something else will stop us from lynching her at every future lynch?

Considering we have found a Serial Killer, I think Justin is right in that it is in the Town's best interest to lynch River today to drop Night Kills by one.

 

[Trent the Paladin]

You do make a good point here. We found a Serial Killer, so why don't we just lynch her, especially since we are at a complete loss when it comes to mafia suspicions. The longer we keep River alive, the more kills we'll have to endure each night, and who's to say something else will stop us from lynching her at every future lynch?

Considering we have found a Serial Killer, I think Justin is right in that it is in the Town's best interest to lynch River today to drop Night Kills by one.

I disagree, we can have the serial killer kill off distractions and potential mafia. If our distractions don't shape up, they only benefit mafia and are no good to us.

 

[Superpenguin]

I disagree, we can have the serial killer kill off distractions and potential mafia. If our distractions don't shape up, they only benefit mafia and are no good to us.

That is only dropping Town's numbers each night. We can't afford to intentionally drop our own numbers. We don't have strong enough suspicions to think any of these suspects are mafia, and we know a Serial Killer. We should just get rid of the Serial Killer now, because they are an enemy of Town.

Serial Killers and the Town have opposite win conditions, and working together is essentially cheating. If Town is going to win, we will win the right way.

Apparently there are two vig shots out there still. These can easily be directed at the distractions.

 

[FanousOnTheLoose]

You do make a good point here. We found a Serial Killer, so why don't we just lynch her, especially since we are at a complete loss when it comes to mafia suspicions. The longer we keep River alive, the more kills we'll have to endure each night, and who's to say something else will stop us from lynching her at every future lynch?

Considering we have found a Serial Killer, I think Justin is right in that it is in the Town's best interest to lynch River today to drop Night Kills by one.

Or we could blackmail our SK to kill for us. That way we can lynch someone while the SK kills someone else the town wants dead. If the SK slips up then we lynch no questions asked. But assuming we have found SK the town essentially gets 2 kills -- 1 from the lynch and 1 from the SK. If SK fails to cooperate then we just lynch.

 

[Jeremy]

We are throwing a lot of names around, so whoever we don't lynch now will surely be taken out by the Eagles.

 

[Superpenguin]

Or we could blackmail our SK to kill for us. That way we can lynch someone while the SK kills someone else the town wants dead. If the SK slips up then we lynch no questions asked. But assuming we have found SK the town essentially gets 2 kills -- 1 from the lynch and 1 from the SK. If SK fails to cooperate then we just lynch.

Then tell me when you plan on getting rid of River.

 

[EpicGamer12]

For the time being, beary509 and Blu Rose can be left alone. I will go along with Justin with his attempt to lynch the serial killer.

 

[Blu Rose]

Then tell me when you plan on getting rid of River.

When she does not kill a distraction or potential Mafioso.

 

[Mary]

Essentially I think we should take the risk on players like Minties ( I love you girl <3 pls no mad :c ) or Justin.

Blu Rose, Beary509, Prin: Please be careful with who you are PM'ing. For some odd reason, your PMs seriously coincide with how the Mafia made their moves on Night One. If this is a coincidence, then wow. If it's not, it'll be caught on really quickly. If anyone new tries to PM you, you need to bring their name forward immediately.


We should also pay attention to those who didn't vote Day One:

- TheCreeperHugz
- LaurinaMN
- FireNinja1
- Mary

Hikari seems to be more Town aligned which is why I left him out. These people on the list are seriously flying under everyone's radars. Disinterested Townies? Maybe. If I forgot anyone else, lemme know.

In my defense, I was at my friend's house playing minecraft. Anyone who has seen me play knows that I am anything BUT quiet.
If you feel like it, flip back several pages and see where I was like "Oh crap. Did I get modkilled?"
I assure you that it was because of events in real life, not because I'm a criminal mastermind.