Mafia TBT Mafia V: There and Back Again [Game Over/Town Win]

[Keen]

and since so many are looking at lynching the 'SK' while a few people present a good plan, why not look at those people against the said plan. Maybe their the ones scared that the 'SK' would take them out in a hit to reveal them as mafia?

 

[Superpenguin]

When she does not kill a distraction or potential Mafioso.

This is just the stupidest thing ever.

Town doesn't even know who to lynch, let alone who to let a Serial Killer go out and kill! Instead of losing one Town player each Day/Night Cycle, we'll be losing two + the mafia shots. Obviously River will follow through with whoever we tell her, because what does it matter to her if she hits Town or Mafia, she has to shoot them all anyway. Thus, our numbers will drop significantly and essentially River can get around this and win.

Without the Serial Killer, Town has had no problem winning games. Lynch River and get it over with.

 

[FanousOnTheLoose]

Then tell me when you plan on getting rid of River.

when River
a). slips up and doesnt follow us
b). or after 2 or 3 kills

How long do you think we are gonna keep her alive?

 

[Ashtot]

For those of you who didn't know, Trundle is a dwarf.

 

[Superpenguin]

when River
a). slips up and doesnt follow us
b). or after 2 or 3 kills

How long do you think we are gonna keep her alive?

Until Town loses.

 

[FanousOnTheLoose]

This is just the stupidest thing ever.

Town doesn't even know who to lynch, let alone who to let a Serial Killer go out and kill! Instead of losing one Town player each Day/Night Cycle, we'll be losing two + the mafia shots. Obviously River will follow through with whoever we tell her, because what does it matter to her if she hits Town or Mafia, she has to shoot them all anyway. Thus, our numbers will drop significantly and essentially River can get around this and win.

Without the Serial Killer, Town has had no problem winning games. Lynch River and get it over with.

I see what you're saying. Well is it doesnt matter who gets killed then how about we have some controlled kills? We were all indecisive on voting between prin, blue, beary and river. Why not lynch and have SK kill one of those 3 and then we lynch SK?

 

[Mary]

For those of you who didn't know, Trundle is a dwarf.

Yay, more suspects.

Seriously though, what are you thinking, making a post like that? This makes me feel as if you are both Mafia.

 

[Beary]

For those of you who didn't know, Trundle is a dwarf.

D8

Really?
****.

 

[Superpenguin]

I see what you're saying. Well is it doesnt matter who gets killed then how about we have some controlled kills? We were all indecisive on voting between prin, blue, beary and river. Why not lynch and have SK kill one of those 3 and then we lynch SK?

Why not let vigs deal with those distractions and lynch River tonight?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yay, more suspects.

Seriously though, what are you thinking, making a post like that? This makes me feel as if you are both Mafia.

D8

Really?
****.

Omg, how easily you guys forget things is unbelievable. Trundle was protected last night...from a mafia shot.

 

[FanousOnTheLoose]

Why not let vigs deal with those distractions and lynch River tonight?

- - - Post Merge - - -





Omg, how easily you guys forget things is unbelievable. Trundle was protected last night...from a mafia shot.

Why not utilize all 3? lynch someone, have SK kill someone, and then have vig kill RIver?

 

[Mary]

Why not let vigs deal with those distractions and lynch River tonight?

- - - Post Merge - - -





Omg, how easily you guys forget things is unbelievable. Trundle was protected last night...from a mafia shot.

Am I missing something?

 

[FanousOnTheLoose]

also why waste a vig shot when we have SK?

 

[Justin]

also why waste a vig shot when we have SK?

Because the SK is not town aligned and potentially volatile, it is not safe to keep them around if we have the ability to get rid of them. Vigs are town aligned, and will count towards a town victory, and for that reason can be trusted far more.

 

[Superpenguin]

Am I missing something?

You probably missed this:

I just got a PM. I was targeted last night. First off, thanks to whoever saved me. Second, if you're the one who protected me, it'd be nice if you came out to me. The town needs to know the doctors this game.
So there is one of the missing kills. Again, I could have died, so thanks!

 

[iLoveYou]

May I ask why no one is willing to take a risk on Minties or Justin?

Justin wants the Serial Killer out. This can either be Mafia motivated or Town motivated. On top of that, KarlaKGB has tried to clear him from his list of potential Mafia that helped remove Dolby from the game. On top of THAT Justin has never replied to that or made a comment. He has remained neutral and focused on River.

Essentially having River in the game will force the Mafia to waste 1 KP on her or 1 roleblock on her every night. This is what will benefit Town, as it will allow our Detectives + Doctors + Vigilantes to get to work. If they choose not to, then River's shot will go through. Tom has said that he has a long list of blue roles in his possession. This greatly reduces the numbers of "grey players" and gives us a lead to work with.

River has made it clear that she will be a roadblock for the Mafia. Why not let the Mafia deal with her? They will deal with her because she removed the Godfather from the game. They have to remove her from the game before we find their roleblockers. She is not obliged to shoot every night.

 

[FanousOnTheLoose]

Because the SK is not town aligned and potentially volatile, it is not safe to keep them around if we have the ability to get rid of them. Vigs are town aligned, and will count towards a town victory, and for that reason can be trusted far more.

I understand. And I just thought of this now but what if better evidence keeps coming up after each night and then we keep delaying on killing the SK. Alright agreed, vote off SK.

 

[iLoveYou]

She can help town by absorbing KP / roleblocks.

 

[Justin]

Justin wants the Serial Killer out. This can either be Mafia motivated or Town motivated. On top of that, KarlaKGB has tried to clear him from his list of potential Mafia that helped remove Dolby from the game. On top of THAT Justin has never replied to that or made a comment. He has remained neutral and focused on River.

Karla is not stupid. He would not give away his teammates that easily. If anything, I bet he would purposely throw that kind of thing into his posts Day 1 to throw you off, knowing that he would likely die earlier in the game rather than later.

 

[FanousOnTheLoose]

"the enemy of my enemy is my friend"
River can swing either way. Who's to say that mafia doesn't roleblock River and then River kills a townie? And with their being a lot more town then mafia this is a very likely case. Leaving River alive will mostly only aid mafia.

 

[Justin]

And no, I'm not currently willing to take a risk on Minities or myself because they are essentially random lynches.