Mafia TBT Mafia X: The Honnō-ji Incident [Game Over/Town Win]

The main post now contains links to each player's post filter. Sorry for the delay in getting it up. :)
 
First of all, I'd like to say that I'm not convinced that Tom is scum just yet because as Ash pointed out, he doesn't seem to be acting any differently to me. Although, his post asking to be checked did seem kind of scummy to a lot of people. It's possible that he just wants a change of playing style to make it less obvious for future games when they're mafia, however I kind of doubt that.


I'd just like to bring up alise for the moment. Firstly, here's a post from them earlier:
alise said:
I'd like to hear more from Jeremy before voting for him. {However what I've heard so far, he seems like an alright choice along with Trundle. I'm not exactly sure about Karla.}

Also, Andelsky does not seem as scummy to me, I'd also love to hear more from her.

Being hypocritical, I haven't been posting as much have I, sorry for not posting, being distracted a lot.
Click to expand...
They said they didn't see how Andel was acting scummy (and I'm not saying they seem scummy for not hopping on the bandwagon right away either, because I think it's good to share your opinions!). They didn't say much about leaning towards voting for Trundle either, however I guess that's understandable since they were going to be late.

alise said:
Last game in Mini Mini mafia, when Farobi was scum, he acted very pro-town.

I think hes a bored townie, IMO. But I haven't read as much past mafia games to analyze posts and whatnot.

The Andel case seems very persuading. Her defenses aren't the greatest and the evidence is good. Plus, with Karen's little tidbit we could most likely get scum from lynching Andel.
Click to expand...
Then they seem more open with the idea of lynching Andel now, and mention Farobi. On the subject of Farobi, I think that he could be scared mafia who wants to avoid posting in my opinion (considering they've been active on the rest of the forum).

To me, it could be possible that they could be defending their mafia team since, firstly they kind of back up Andel, and then when it seems that there's no way Andel can get out of the lynch, they decide to change their opinion to avoid looking scummy. Then, if Farobi did turn out to be scum, then it would make alise look suspicious in my eyes, because of a similar reason. Just a thought.

The rest of their posts are one liners or don't contribute to the game much.

If this makes me look like a hypocrite or is completely flawed, then I'm sorry. I thought it'd be better safe than sorry.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh, and how did I never see the option to search a thread until today? -.-
 
Relax Yui, you bring up some good points, be more confident of yourself. Apologising for yourself doesn't help you or town.
 
Yui Z, you're trying and you're doing pretty good at making points. Don't be sorry, you're making excellent points.
 
In relation to yui-z, we will have to wait and see what Farobi flips really. You're doing awesome! Great finds!
 
Tom mX (so far)- 11 posts
Tom mIX- 52 posts (survived whole game) blue
Tom mVIII- 57 posts (killed night 3) green
Tom mVII- 34 posts (killed NIGHT 1) green
Tom mVI- 73 posts (LYNCHED day 3) red
Tom mV- 44 posts (killed night 2) blue
Tom mIV- 76 posts (survived whole game) red
Tom mII- 62 posts (killed night 3) green

As I promised. This included sign up pre game and post game posts.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Note: He hosted game III and did not play in game I.
 
Sorry to bring this back up but... did we ever figure out how Karen knew Andelsky would die as Hooker?
 
Justin said:
Sorry to bring this back up but... did we ever figure out how Karen knew Andelsky would die as Hooker?
Click to expand...

I was about to post about that. The only way we'd know is if Andel leaked her role somehow to Karen, or Karen was scum as well.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I meant the only way Karen would know.
 
Yui Z said:
First of all, I'd like to say that I'm not convinced that Tom is scum just yet because as Ash pointed out, he doesn't seem to be acting any differently to me. Although, his post asking to be checked did seem kind of scummy to a lot of people. It's possible that he just wants a change of playing style to make it less obvious for future games when they're mafia, however I kind of doubt that.


I'd just like to bring up alise for the moment. Firstly, here's a post from them earlier:

They said they didn't see how Andel was acting scummy (and I'm not saying they seem scummy for not hopping on the bandwagon right away either, because I think it's good to share your opinions!). They didn't say much about leaning towards voting for Trundle either, however I guess that's understandable since they were going to be late.


Then they seem more open with the idea of lynching Andel now, and mention Farobi. On the subject of Farobi, I think that he could be scared mafia who wants to avoid posting in my opinion (considering they've been active on the rest of the forum).

To me, it could be possible that they could be defending their mafia team since, firstly they kind of back up Andel, and then when it seems that there's no way Andel can get out of the lynch, they decide to change their opinion to avoid looking scummy. Then, if Farobi did turn out to be scum, then it would make alise look suspicious in my eyes, because of a similar reason. Just a thought.

The rest of their posts are one liners or don't contribute to the game much.

If this makes me look like a hypocrite or is completely flawed, then I'm sorry. I thought it'd be better safe than sorry.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh, and how did I never see the option to search a thread until today? -.-
Click to expand...

My play style is weaker compared to other players, as I'm not as good as making big paragraphs of opinions because I don't have any suspicions. Plus, I have no idea what to post sometimes.

Farobi could be scared mafia, but I am a little confused on his style of being mafia if he is scum this game. He was very pro-town when he was scum, he must have been interested somehow in that mafia game?
I'm not exactly backing up Andel. That's my way of saying "I need more evidence." or "They haven't made a defense yet, I'll give them some time {maybe timezones.}." The reason why I agreed to lynching Andel is because Trundle had some good evidence and she was backing down. I always give people some chance to make a defense, and then see what happens next, THEN decide if I won't lynch or will lynch.

But, I am a little suspicous of Farobi. He's been very quiet so far.
 
alise said:
My play style is weaker compared to other players, as I'm not as good as making big paragraphs of opinions because I don't have any suspicions. Plus, I have no idea what to post sometimes.

Farobi could be scared mafia, but I am a little confused on his style of being mafia if he is scum this game. He was very pro-town when he was scum, he must have been interested somehow in that mafia game?
I'm not exactly backing up Andel. That's my way of saying "I need more evidence." or "They haven't made a defense yet, I'll give them some time {maybe timezones.}." The reason why I agreed to lynching Andel is because Trundle had some good evidence and she was backing down. I always give people some chance to make a defense, and then see what happens next, THEN decide if I won't lynch or will lynch.

But, I am a little suspicous of Farobi. He's been very quiet so far.
Click to expand...

Farobi is almost always quiet, usually because he's bored. When you get Townie over and over again, there is really nothing more for you to do, so the game gets boring to you (I've been Townie in every single game in Mafia so far, so I know what it feels like). He likely got active because he was Mafia for a change, which means he had a private chat and he had to be active, making it much more interesting than it was previously with a role change. If he continues to be quiet, it's likely he's, once again, a bored Townie. We can have a Vig take care of him if we consider him for the lynch at another time, because I personally don't feel he needs a lynch if he's a bored Townie like he usually is.
 
I know there's not enough evidence but can a vig consider shooting farobi! You don't have to but I and others have a burning feeling about him.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Kippla said:
Farobi is almost always quiet, usually because he's bored. When you get Townie over and over again, there is really nothing more for you to do, so the game gets boring to you (I've been Townie in every single game in Mafia so far, so I know what it feels like). He likely got active because he was Mafia for a change, which means he had a private chat and he had to be active, making it much more interesting than it was previously with a role change. If he continues to be quiet, it's likely he's, once again, a bored Townie. We can have a Vig take care of him if we consider him for the lynch at another time, because I personally don't feel he needs a lynch if he's a bored Townie like he usually is.
Click to expand...

He did this last game and he was mafia? He then quit so that's not the reason.
 
So, some interesting stuff has been posted, and I'd like to say a few things. I agree with the alise case, (good job Yui Z!) and I think the only way Karen would know if Andel were scum would be a. Karen is scum or b. Andel told Karen. One of these is more likely than the other. I am waiting until day, and depending on what happened, I may make a case on a player I am suspicious of.
 
PurplPanda said:
So, some interesting stuff has been posted, and I'd like to say a few things. I agree with the alise case, (good job Yui Z!) and I think the only way Karen would know if Andel were scum would be a. Karen is scum or b. Andel told Karen. One of these is more likely than the other. I am waiting until day, and depending on what happened, I may make a case on a player I am suspicious of.
Click to expand...

This post is absolutely bloody useless. You literally repeated everything that has been posted.
 
Lauren said:
I know there's not enough evidence but can a vig consider shooting farobi! You don't have to but I and others have a burning feeling about him.

- - - Post Merge - - -

He did this last game and he was mafia? He then quit so that's not the reason.
Click to expand...

I'm going to agree that shooting Farobi isn't too bad of an idea, as long as there aren't any other leads. Farobi has been posting in other parts of the forum but hasn't contributed anything to the game. Kuma however, hasn't been on the forum for three days or so, and will most likely be mod killed. Anybody else have thoughts on this?

Honestly Farobi should just be banned from Mafia in general.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

N e s s
Mafia TBT Mafia - Darkest Dungeon (Cancelled)
Replies
15
Views
823
N e s s
N e s s
Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)
139 140 141
Replies
3K
Views
96K
unravel
unravel
Damniel
Mafia Among Us Mafia - Sign Ups
2
Replies
24
Views
2K
Damniel
Damniel
E
  • Locked
Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Sign-Ups
2 3
Replies
47
Views
2K
EpicGamer12
E
TN4U
Mafia Redd's Revenge - Sign-Up Thread [CLOSED]
2
Replies
37
Views
2K
TN4U
TN4U
Back
Top