Mafia TBT Nomination Mafia: 7 Player Micro-DAY 1- ends Monday 10 PM EST

[PunchyTheCat]

antonio's post sounds forced

I want to look back into cala, with Antonio's post, I could see a cala/Antonio team.

I want to rule out toads because I don't think he'd let either of them make those posts.

 

[Biancasbotique]

I will extend the day to Tuesday 10 EST to give a chance for everyone first day

 

[Hyrule_Crossing]

im here/

also i forgot to describe my self

Im a male who lkes games, and dogs.. im also a newbie to mafia

- - - Post Merge - - -

That RQS is literal trash that gives us nothing helpful to go off of except anxiety that there are a bunch of 12 year olds, I suggest this one instead

- username/nicknames you like to go by

- experience with mafia

- strategy for the game/ or perceived strategy of what you think should be done/ what you think a game of mafia works like

- who you think is scum

- - - Post Merge - - -

- toadsworthy, but you can call me Toad/toads

- pretty experienced I've played in a dozen + games here

- analyze people's posts and votes and intentions with tone to see who is scum

- calamity bot is being very over top trying to look townie. That may be fresh enthusiasm, but could be trying to appear townie. I will look at their other game at some point

-Hyrule, Noah, anything lol

-almost none, i have only played one game. but i wouldnt say im terrible

-idk yet

-i also dont know yet

 

[Antonio]

antonio's post sounds forced

I want to look back into cala, with Antonio's post, I could see a cala/Antonio team.

I want to rule out toads because I don't think he'd let either of them make those posts.

Define force? Rush, maybe. It is the midterms after all. I'm sort of multitasking at this point. Maybe it seems rushed because It feels like I'm the only one really posting and no one really seems to be engaging into the thread (besides maybe toad and calamity).

Anyways you have been avoiding my question, along with Toad. You guys have obviously been online since my posts (You on Discord and Toad gave me 2 bells like an hour after I made that post) so why have you been avoiding my question? Plus, it feels like you are just throwing together accusations without a clear explantion.

This game isn't as fun if no one is really talking or contributing to the game.

- - - Post Merge - - -

im here/

also i forgot to describe my self

Im a male who lkes games, and dogs.. im also a newbie to mafia

- - - Post Merge - - -



-Hyrule, Noah, anything lol

-almost none, i have only played one game. but i wouldnt say im terrible

-idk yet

-i also dont know yet

What are your opinions right now?

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I don't scumread calamity unless he's with you.

I meant not naturally sounding town by forced

 

[Antonio]

I don't scumread calamity unless he's with you.

I meant not naturally sounding town by forced

Oh shoot. I misread that post. I should stop multitasking and such. Anyways, why is your opinion on him and others.

Could you possibly explain what comes off as force?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm asking because I'm not sure how my messages are coming off force.

 

[Antonio]

Also, you claim that calamity is sus if he was paired with me but is not sus if he isn't. What is your reasoning behind that?

Why is no one else talking? Where are the other users? I maybe will ask for a replacement if this game doesn't pick up.

 

[Biancasbotique]

Also, you claim that calamity is sus if he was paired with me but is not sus if he isn't. What is your reasoning behind that?

Why is no one else talking? Where are the other users? I maybe will ask for a replacement if this game doesn't pick up.

don't. do. that. again.

 

[Antonio]

don't. do. that. again.

Fine.

 

[calamitybot]

- username/nicknames you like to go by
my user or bits of it
- experience with mafia
little compared to veterans, but much more than the new players in this game
- strategy for the game/ or perceived strategy of what you think should be done/ what you think a game of mafia works like
All of the veterans have been the most active this game, while the new players have basically only answered questions so far. Yes, this is typical, as new players usually don't know how to contribute, but it could indicate that two veteran players, like antonio, punchy, or toads are working together, because if a veteran was paired with a noob, I'd guess that the veteran would try to get the new player to talk a bit more than the new players currently are. Or, they're encouraging to lay low, since they're more prone to make mistakes. I really cannot say for sure what speculation I currently hold to be the strongest, all I can do is come up with possibilities and wait for other's input on them.
- who you think is scum
No answer as of yet, but I would say voting off one of the newer players who hasn't said much is the most logical step, since the newer players have hardly contributed, and if it's a town voteoff, it wouldn't affect the town's strategizing too much, just the numbers. If I could, I'd encourage everybody to go novote, but that's against the rules of this game.
Also, I'm really sorry for my inactivity all day. I forgot I had class, and then my boyfriend came over and I completely forgot about this game. I'm glad Bianca extended the vote cutoff so I wasn't modkilled.

 

[rhinoo]

-James, Rhino or whatever,

-1 game

-dont got one

-idk we have been playing for a day.

 

[Biancasbotique]

Mechanics if I ever have to modkill tonight:

In case of a lot of people getting modkilled, we will not lynch tonight (but you must still vote nonetheless). We have a replacement and everyone will vote at end of day 1 on who they want replaced (for fairness). If things keep up as it is, there will be possible multiple modkills tonight. Thank you!

 

[Hyrule_Crossing]

What are your opinions right now?

Opinions on what? The game?

 

[toadsworthy]

Bad answers are better than false answers. Why do you get to determine what is a bad answer?

I don't usually come up with a stragey this early because I need something to work with. Same with question 4, I ain't gonna consider anyone Scum unless I got somehing to work with. Why are you forcing an answer this early in the game? I'm not gonna throw out any names unless I am certain there is something scummy about a person.

My opinions on Calamity is I'm not sure. I'm still obversing everything during midterms and it's still day 1.

However, I believe you are Scum as of now. Usually, I have never seen you so controlling over how the game should be run. Stating how things should go and such. We should be working together as a Town but it feels you are trying to take control of the game. That is just my opinion.

Why do you think calamity is scummy? You too @punchy

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh god the grammar....

I got an English class to attend too...

A bad answer is one that doesn't answer the question... so anyone can judge that not me.

And I don't care if its too early to have a strategy. If everyone played like that then mafia games would be sitting around doing nothing.

I do this all the time, tell people how to play this game because honestly everyone who plays right now is utter poop. I said I was gonna do this in the original post too... so don't know why this is a surprise. Someone has to say something or otherwise you noobs will just fade into oblivion, like every other game

 

[Antonio]

A bad answer is one that doesn't answer the question... so anyone can judge that not me.

And I don't care if its too early to have a strategy. If everyone played like that then mafia games would be sitting around doing nothing.

I do this all the time, tell people how to play this game because honestly everyone who plays right now is utter poop. I said I was gonna do this in the original post too... so don't know why this is a surprise. Someone has to say something or otherwise you noobs will just fade into oblivion, like every other game

But I did answer the question, just not to your liking. Forcing opinions out of people is unethical and could lead to rushed statements. Also, could you possibly quote the orignal post where you said this. Finally, you didn't answer my question.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

But I did answer the question, just not to your liking. Forcing opinions out of people is unethical and could lead to rushed statements. Also, could you possibly quote the orignal post where you said this. Finally, you didn't answer my question.

If you'd actually been reading the thread you'd have had at least an opinion on someone, mainly calamity.

Okay you don't actually know what you're talking about?

- - - Post Merge - - -

@Toads opinion on me?

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Voting Antonio

 

[Antonio]

If you'd actually been reading the thread you'd have had at least an opinion on someone, mainly calamity.

Okay you don't actually know what you're talking about?

- - - Post Merge - - -

@Toads opinion on me?

Punchy, if you actually been reading the thread you will realize I have stated my opinion on you and Toad. I even said my statement about Calamity. The fact that you don't provide detailed reasoning for your statements and how you been avoiding my questions (Just like Toad) is scummy enough. You also haven't stated much (not stated nothing but much) on other people like Toad or Hyrule, you have been just coming for me. And claiming what I dont know what i'm talking about is quite disrespectful imo.

So, let me go into details about you.

Punchy | Scumish | You have been sussing me without properly going into details into why you are saying this. Let's go into this post first:

antonio's post sounds forced

- You stated my statement sounded force - So, how does my statement sound force? You haven't actually explained in detail what about my statement seemed force. I even asked you if you could explain:

Could you possibly explain what comes off as force?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm asking because I'm not sure how my messages are coming off force.

Still haven't answered that question, even after you have posted something after I made this post.

- Next, you stated that calamity is sus if we were a team but otherwise, he will be town.

I want to look back into cala, with Antonio's post, I could see a cala/Antonio team.

I don't scumread calamity unless he's with you.

Could you explain to me why you believe that? What makes our posts seem like we are a team?

I believe you are just throwing accusations around, without proper explantions to back up your accusations

- Finally, you come back from this 20hr gap and clearly stated that I have no idea what I'm talking about, which is rude and another accusation. Stating I have not stated my opinions on users, especially Calamity. I have stated my reasons for Calamity, and Toad (not including this post).

Cal:

My opinions on Calamity is I'm not sure. I'm still obversing everything during midterms and it's still day 1.

Tbh, I believe he is Town now as of this post.

Toad:

However, I believe you are Scum as of now. Usually, I have never seen you so controlling over how the game should be run. Stating how things should go and such. We should be working together as a Town but it feels you are trying to take control of the game. That is just my opinion.

Plus there is quite hyprocrisy in that statement because you haven't talked about others aswell.

Now, I wouldn't think you were scum if you went into detail about your accusations towards me. Can you go into detail into why?

I'll be working on my post about everyone else in a few minutes, I need to shower.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

mk so I wasn't very clear on my context in some of my posts

first off, the opinion about calamity is about the first post you made, your response to the rq's. you did not provide very much at all with the rq's. I put blame on you for lack of pulling people out to create content for rq's in my first post.

Okay asking for the post that toads is talking about gives a bad vibe, I might have been overzealous in saying that, I'm sorry.

I just asked Toads to make some content, so I'm looking into him a little bit. Literally no one else has created content. They need to create content, but it is not needed yet, since I'm zeroed in on you atm. It is needed.

Everyone, please state your opinion on Antonio now.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Bad answers are better than false answers. Why do you get to determine what is a bad answer?

I don't usually come up with a stragey this early because I need something to work with. Same with question 4, I ain't gonna consider anyone Scum unless I got somehing to work with. Why are you forcing an answer this early in the game? I'm not gonna throw out any names unless I am certain there is something scummy about a person.

My opinions on Calamity is I'm not sure. I'm still obversing everything during midterms and it's still day 1.

However, I believe you are Scum as of now. Usually, I have never seen you so controlling over how the game should be run. Stating how things should go and such. We should be working together as a Town but it feels you are trying to take control of the game. That is just my opinion.

Why do you think calamity is scummy? You too @punchy

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh god the grammar....

I got an English class to attend too...

What I meant here is that the tone sounded not like something a member of town would say. Also, there is an amount of WIFOM in many of his posts. I have to go to sleep now, so I can't pull specifics.

 

[Antonio]

mk so I wasn't very clear on my context in some of my posts

first off, the opinion about calamity is about the first post you made, your response to the rq's. you did not provide very much at all with the rq's. I put blame on you for lack of pulling people out to create content for rq's in my first post.

Okay asking for the post that toads is talking about gives a bad vibe, I might have been overzealous in saying that, I'm sorry.

I just asked Toads to make some content, so I'm looking into him a little bit. Literally no one else has created content. They need to create content, but it is not needed yet, since I'm zeroed in on you atm. It is needed.

Everyone, please state your opinion on Antonio now.

It was early on into the game, I didn't have much to say. I think my reqs still stand. It is early

When did you tell Toad to make some content? Quote pls.

Thanks for the explanation though, I still got a few more question.

------

1) How does my lack of explanation on rqs link me up to calamity?

2) You never explained how my statement was force. Could you possibly explain?

3) Do you have any questions for me?

--------------------