tldr just avoiding making opinions with a whole lot of fluff and shading players of the previous game
How does Antonio?s RQ?s involve fluff? There?s literally nothing that seems fillery or forced. It?s just him talking about his playstyle, pronouns and personal opinion on what happened in other games. Also, I don?t think that he?s even shading players. This is a bad case to make, especially on his RQ?s.
I'm also slightly scumreading Ness/Chele bc I noticed them kinda lowkey defending each other for separate points but I have nothing to base it off really and it's just a weird hunch, so I'll come back later with more formulated reads tomorrow given there are more posts hopefully :')
I can almost see where you?re coming from, the thing is that it?s not only Ness that I?ve defended. I?ve also been defending Evan, Toads and Antonio. Also I don?t know why you?re scumreading Ness, he never defended me. Look back at his posts and he only just said that he slightly TR?d me but with a bit of caution.
Antonio is kind of uncoordinated of what he is doing I couldn't tell if it's legit or not; he's kinda suspicious in my opinion
Yes, he is uncoordinated but look into his playstyle and look at his previous posts. He even mentioned Dad in one of his posts and didn?t think that Dolby was playing. This means that he is just inattentive. Just wait until he posts more
then you could make a judgement.
ik it's been picked up on but antonio wasn't sure dolby was even in the game and then wasn't sure if dad was in the game? you'd think you'd at least check after you had to check if dolby was in the ground, i find it weird he didn't check before he even said that initially. maybe it's nothing and he doesn't read carefully like heyden said but doing it twice is just clumsy and weird
Majority of people are going for Antonio just for his RQ?s. I feel like this is just a very easy bandwagon because so many other people have just been saying stuff about him and I?m pretty sure that I have proved him to be ignorant towards the game. Obviously he didn?t read the OP or just skimmed through the posts, but that?s not AI at all. You have no right to even sus him over one post (which is his first post). Also I?m not just aiming this at you, Mog.
no, not really after thinking about it, just thought it was weird he did it twice, like i said tho there's no reason for him to be clumsy, not like it benefits him, just find it strange people don't bother even looking at the player list before answering questions like that
It is sorta filler to just comment on something which feels ?weird? and not even feel sus about it? It?s just the damn RQ?s and an OP, there?s no point even making a case off of it.
By stating that refusing to answer specific questions in RQS is not usually alignment indicative, Heyden is showing he really has town's interests in mind. The way the whole paragraph is written reads very town to me.
(3) He called out Dolby's small mistake (or non-mistake, I don't really care) calling out 3 mafia instead of 4. His point might not be entirely relevant, but the fact that he is reading and paying attention to the details makes me think that Heyden has little bias towards any players at the moment.
First of all, can we just count how many players have already declared that the RQ?s and Evan?s refusal aren?t AI? I don?t see how Heyden only stands out to you for that reason. Second, he?s only made two posts so far (aside from the RQ?s), so how does meta and the way only one of the posts that you?ve quoted make it look ?good?? Third, reading into something carefully could also be a Mafia tactic so that they could sus many people based on little things. How does reading into
only one question from Dolby?s RQ?s form a reason to clear Heyden for you?
This is 100% town mog, scum mog would be uncomfortable and seem out of it. Check CTSTP
I?m letting you off for this one since you?re an early poster, but clearing somebody JUST for their meta and assuming that they?re town shouldn?t be a good tactic to use, Punchy. People take advice from previous games and change for the better, sometimes (take yourself as an example).
after rereading a bit mog is literally a townlock for me
mog is not AT ALL acting like scum mog that I remember from CTSTP
And now you?re townlocking her based off one game
Anyways Punchy aside from meta, is there anything else you could give us?
mog defending me is definitely towny, mog defo wouldn't do that as scum.
her tone and posting style aren't really alignment indictative, but her content is.
HOW? How is her content AI? Why
wouldn?t she defend you as scum? Elaborate please.
Yeah I could, this part is more linked towards Chele bc her posts seemed kinda overcautious when she tried to deconfirm Rune/Antonio as town bc they were questioning Evan (which is a valid point), but I didn't like how quick she was to shrug off 'sucking up to Vanessa' towards you and Toads. Ofc that's probably her own personal scumtells but it just felt inconsistent to me.
I sandwiched you in last night probs bc I townread toads more, plus her defence on you was almost a paragraph long.
How was I overcautious? Also, it is a valid point to shrug off Vanessa. Dolby came into the game saying ?yo toads and ness are sucking up to vanessa using the RQ?s? and obviously that?s a very wrong sus. You can?t just sus somebody for asking for RQ?s from Vanessa. As well as that, many other people asked for the RQ?s. And yeah, I always use paragraphs and reasoning to state my points? Again, I?m confused as to why you?re only targeting Ness and I in this. What happened to Toads, Antonio and Evan? I?m pretty sure I defended way more people as well. Ness never defended me.
It reminds me of a game where I think Bowie sussed someone because they are not eating lunch or something or something like that. It still chuckles me to this day
I still laugh to this day as well. I think it was in I?m a Cop You Idiot mafia where Bowie sussed Chick for eating lunch.
Punchy where?d you get that from? You could always improve your playstyle and tone, nobody is sussing you or hating on you right now. I just wanted a few questions answered from you. Just keep going Punchy.
Mafia's #1 priority on day one is to ensure that people aren't being confirmed so quickly, I noticed that trying to deconfirm town is kind of an unconscious thing scum does early bc they're paranoid of a narrowing scum pool.
Before you come at me for doing this Heyden, what I?m trying to say (and agree with Bianca on that point about Punchy) is that he just said ?Mog sounds towny. Look at one other game. Townlock?. I want Punchy to elaborate more, because his reasoning using meta just by itself is questionable. I?m not trying to deconfirm town.
