Mafia The Battle of the Nobles- Endgame

[amazonevan19]

That does not look sus in any way, in fact I think that looks kinda good. If you think that one scum is going to die, does Rune's first thought be "I'm gonna vote the other, sinking the vote between my two buddies and NOT get towncred"

I'm not sure the timeline of Rune logging off but the logic, as presented here is flawed

- - - Post Merge - - -

Rune wasn't on at EoD because they were afk

I think that it's truly that simple

That's kind of my point though? Rune's vote doesn't make them look scummy to me at all

 

[unravel]

That punchy/jacob vote reminds me of my last game with Kat hmm... I'm going to reread the N1 convo again on why yall think punchy is possible GF

 

[Dolby]

That's kind of my point though? Rune's vote doesn't make them look scummy to me at all

Sorry bad reading comprehension and the stress of the last hour is getting to me

Ironically, one of the biggest things that would make Evan and Toads (toads def moreso than Evan) look good to me is Punchy flipping town

- - - Post Merge - - -

That punchy/jacob vote reminds me of my last game with Kat hmm... I'm going to reread the N1 convo again on why yall think punchy is possible GF

Which game?

 

[Chele]

I see you Rune.
Also yeah, she did vote over here

 

[unravel]

Punchy and Bianca since you both are hard to read can uou give us possible scum team with Jacob and why thanks

- - - Post Merge - - -

Sorry bad reading comprehension and the stress of the last hour is getting to me

Ironically, one of the biggest things that would make Evan and Toads (toads def moreso than Evan) look good to me is Punchy flipping town

- - - Post Merge - - -



Which game?

Kat, me and jacob as I recall as scum team im on mobile and will look back to that game. Kat had to save me cuz my role is useful and im really on my edge that time. I think heyden was there in that game too if anyone remembered what game it was just lmk ty

 

[Biancasbotique]

Punchy and Bianca since you both are hard to read can uou give us possible scum team with Jacob and why thanks

1. Punchy- that whole Punchy/Jacob debacle reminds me of mafia strategically making something out of two mafia being potential lynch.

2. Vanessa- your post actually gave me the idea that Vanessa might be using reverse psychology when she proclaimed " I'm gonna lynch Jacob but I'm gonna be angry!" and then proceeded to again introduce the idea of me being scum. And remember she started the whole Bianca meta sus.

That's all I have for now.

 

[Heyden]

Punchy and Bianca since you both are hard to read can uou give us possible scum team with Jacob and why thanks

- - - Post Merge - - -



Kat, me and jacob as I recall as scum team im on mobile and will look back to that game. Kat had to save me cuz my role is useful and im really on my edge that time. I think heyden was there in that game too if anyone remembered what game it was just lmk ty

oh the ancient egypt game

 

[Dolby]

Bianca's later content looks way better than her former content (sans Tae vote but I don't really see Punchy/Bianca(ftr that's because it's the only world that I see Bianca DELIBRATELY voting Tae, and has nothing to do with my opinion on Punchy) and if Punchy is scum she becomes a townlock

- - - Post Merge - - -

Punchy and Bianca since you both are hard to read can uou give us possible scum team with Jacob and why thanks

- - - Post Merge - - -



Kat, me and jacob as I recall as scum team im on mobile and will look back to that game. Kat had to save me cuz my role is useful and im really on my edge that time. I think heyden was there in that game too if anyone remembered what game it was just lmk ty

Oh yeah I remember, I said that I thought Kat was protecting you to but I thought that even if she was goon her death was more valuable

- - - Post Merge - - -

Jacob-Lvl 1. Goon
???-Lvl 100 Godfather

Someone make this post game

- - - Post Merge - - -

That's how mafia works

 

[unravel]

https://www.belltreeforums.com/show...Egyptian-Gods-Kingmaker-(Game-Thread)-Endgame

https://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?437011-Wrath-of-the-Egyptian-Gods-Voting-Thread

Yall torn who to vote so you guys decided Kat then Me

 

[cornimer]

I'm not calm but one more thing @toads and @Bianca

Why would I, as scum, say: "Oh look, my teammate is going to be lynched, I'll have to go through with maj but I'd better make it clear that I don't want to vote for him first", thus putting sus on myself unnecessarily while not saving my teammate.

It would accomplish nothing. If I was scum at that point I would've just pretended I was happy to lynch hom for more towncred

 

[Biancasbotique]

Bianca's later content looks way better than her former content (sans Tae vote but I don't really see Punchy/Bianca(ftr that's because it's the only world that I see Bianca DELIBRATELY voting Tae, and has nothing to do with my opinion on Punchy) and if Punchy is scum she becomes a townlock

- - - Post Merge - - -




Oh yeah I remember, I said that I thought Kat was protecting you to but I thought that even if she was goon her death was more valuable

- - - Post Merge - - -

Jacob-Lvl 1. Goon
???-Lvl 100 Godfather

Someone make this post game

- - - Post Merge - - -

That's how mafia works

why would Punchy being scum make me a town lock?

 

[EpicGamer12]

I'm not calm but one more thing @toads and @Bianca

Why would I, as scum, say: "Oh look, my teammate is going to be lynched, I'll have to go through with maj but I'd better make it clear that I don't want to vote for him first", thus putting sus on myself unnecessarily while not saving my teammate.

It would accomplish nothing. If I was scum at that point I would've just pretended I was happy to lynch hom for more towncred

it's just wifom at this point, hopefully you can get some rest and chill vanessa, you deserve it!

 

[toadsworthy]

My eyes hurt from looking at my phone I’ll look at Jacobs posts and post tomorrow before night ends

 

[Dolby]

why would Punchy being scum make me a town lock?

he was the one who made your wagon happen and has been irrationally attacking you this whole time?

 

[Biancasbotique]

I'm not calm but one more thing @toads and @Bianca

Why would I, as scum, say: "Oh look, my teammate is going to be lynched, I'll have to go through with maj but I'd better make it clear that I don't want to vote for him first", thus putting sus on myself unnecessarily while not saving my teammate.

It would accomplish nothing. If I was scum at that point I would've just pretended I was happy to lynch hom for more towncred

Vanessa, you go rest girl!! You need that after a crazy lynch day. We will continue sussing each other as soon as you do. (ok i will stop making case against you for now-- it was Waffles who gave me the idea!)...

 

[amazonevan19]

ok I checked the lead up to 5:26 in the thread, what's key here is that rune posted 3 minutes before he switched to jacob, and then 1 minute before he switched and left

theres like 20 pages i have to scroll through heck off

punchy looks scummy when hes town and towny when hes scum lol, this outburst rly looks to me like a town punchy outburst and im v sure that scum trundle wouldnt have been able to pull off that emotional outburst esp if he was apparently trying to be conscious of how he was percieved in the thread, so im voting jacob ty pls stop bullying me

So after catching up in the space of 2 minutes, (granted she said she was scrolling so probably wasn't reading terribly in-depth, no way you read 10 pages a minute) they essentially snapvote Jacob because...it ain't punchy?

All rune/Jacob interactions or rune mentioning jacob:

ye scum is for sure lurking at this point if trundle is town, which makes me kinda worried about the ppl who havent rly contributed to the ate thing when it was happening (jacob, evan, chele, vanessa kinda and me i guess but ik im not scum so i cant rly scumread myself lol)
thats by no means a comprehensive list and im sure im missing some ppl but id def say that at the top of my list of ppl who have been a little in the background and not saying much of substance is jacob, would def wanted him lynched if i had to choose rn but then again i havent put much effort into looking through ppl yet so its subject to change. would def lock him in as at least a scumread atm

also i tr trundle if u want a hot take

id make a reads list if i could but most of today has just been a mess of ate back and forth, woodpines had a lot more actual content from what i remember. my read on jacob is v subject to change like im p sure i said before so its not rly worth me making a full iso or smth but i guess if u rly want smth he feels like hes said basically no new reads and is just jumping on ppl that everyone else is jumping on, and the one time where he listed 3 ppl and said he thought there was maybe one mafia between all three of them was super fishy and just looked like he was hedging his bets and not committing to a read (trundle said this stuff before i think which is y i didnt think it was super important to explain myself). ofc u could prob say some of that stuff about me as well which is y its a weak read but there u go i guess, this game has just kinda sucked so far lol

(my emphasis added)

y r u doing what he tells u to do lol, shouldnt u be focused on reading ppl ur interested in and not just what ppl demand of u

This ^ is rune's only direct interaction with Jacob, at least as far as I can tell.

big yikes right here, jacob evan sounds p legit

Keep in mind Jacob bundled mog, unravel, and trundle together while townreading Bianca, Chele, and one other I forget atm.

I think our plan should be: shoot Punchy (or me if you really want to) and lynch Bianca D2. Rune def looks way better to me after that lynch. It'd take a lot of impressive consternation for scum!rune to predict the results/strategically go AFK without potentially sacrificing a teammate in the process. The thing that gives me pause is that rune and Jacob hardly interacted and rune sounds pretty damn sure Jacob is scum - could have been rune keeping her finger on the pulse of town and realizing Jacob was a liability to her

 

[toadsworthy]

I'm not calm but one more thing @toads and @Bianca

Why would I, as scum,
say: "Oh look, my teammate is going to be lynched, I'll have to go through with maj but I'd better make it clear that I don't want to vote for him first", thus putting sus on myself unnecessarily while not saving my teammate.

It would accomplish nothing. If I was scum at that point I would've just pretended I was happy to lynch hom for more towncred

But when I asked you should we vote im punchy or Jacob, you shifted everything to bianca.... you didn’t just put out support for jacob, you tried to divert. There is a difference and I don’t see you necessarily clear from scum with him

 

[Dolby]

I'm not calm but one more thing @toads and @Bianca

Why would I, as scum, say: "Oh look, my teammate is going to be lynched, I'll have to go through with maj but I'd better make it clear that I don't want to vote for him first", thus putting sus on myself unnecessarily while not saving my teammate.

It would accomplish nothing. If I was scum at that point I would've just pretended I was happy to lynch hom for more towncred

Vanessa is nothing more than a puppet of bourgeois mafia acting against the interests of the proletariat town! Townies of kingdom unite for a Peoples Republic and overthrow our feudal overlords!

Real talk, Vanessa is a townlean

 

[cornimer]

Vanessa, you go rest girl!! You need that after a crazy lynch day. We will continue sussing each other as soon as you do. (ok i will stop making case against you for now-- it was Waffles who gave me the idea!)...

You can make a case against me it's fine lol I'm just saying I think my actions would be dumb if I was scum

 

[Dolby]

I think our plan should be: shoot Punchy (or me if you really want to) and lynch Bianca D2.

I do think that you're distinctly sus, regardless of the Punchy flip, but there's no world where you deserve to be shot tonight (I also don't like that you keep bringing it up and tbh I don't know why)