Mafia The Murder of Woodpines Oregon - Game Thread - Endgame
- Thread starter N e s s
- Start date
- Status
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
actually Locket don't even mind me..I am actually just chuckling at this point. I don't even mean to make a big deal of it ..just really bored with all these ..
it devolved from nothing to a clusterfrick
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
everyone is so polite lol
PunchyTheCat
Senior Member
Amanda, could you post some more?
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
im used to day 1 bickering between people....nothing seems to be happening
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
nothing substantial is happening. I think scum is lurking and/or are could be the ones trying to stir **** up out of nothing.
does that mean anything to u?
monkaS
toadsworthy
Tangsworthy
Leaving reads here so I can follow my own train of thought
Bianca: Town because she was drawing attention to people with "experienced player theory", which I don't think she would do as scum.
Rune: openly talked about mafia set-up very early. Suggested No lynch when I know he is smart enough to try to get someone lynched day 1.
Seroja: town seroja is town, look at her meta its super similar. I hate going up against town seroja when I'm scum, so I'm well aware of what it looks and feels like (and am happy because I'm not going up against it).
Antonio: meme-y, too casual, noob town. I do suggest you stop making bad assumptions and tieing them to scum or town reads. Being invisible or inactive isn't indicative of anything.
Evan: the way you skirted around the topic of mafia set-up really seemed scummy. Like I said earlier, I don't think mafia would be brazen enough to speculate about their own set-up falsely, and the way you seemed to try to add to the conversation without saying anything really rubbed me the wrong way. Your last post just seemed crappy too... "I bet mafia is in quiet ones... but I also bet mafia is in the talkative ones." It just seems like you are trying to divert attention anywhere.
Punchy: Tone is completely different. I understand improvement, I understand real-life stuff, but such a drastic change in tone and demeanor is typically indicative of scum. Your change in demeanor and tone so far is by far the most notable in some time. Just because three people pick up on it, doesn't mean its all scum too.
Panda: Reads feel like a defense from getting scum read, yet here we are. Not as strong of scum lean as the other two, but something has stuck out to me.
Farobi: did speculate on mafia set up but it was very strange. I don't get what angle you are trying to make with your posts too. Town should be trying to help figure out mafia, but yours are just a big (?)
- - - Post Merge - - -
Well you seem content to lynch yourself, so I figure I would let you have that sweet release
Voting yourself is by far the most stupid and worst play ever. And the only way to train a dog to stop crapping on the floor is to stick their own nose in it.
Bianca: Town because she was drawing attention to people with "experienced player theory", which I don't think she would do as scum.
Rune: openly talked about mafia set-up very early. Suggested No lynch when I know he is smart enough to try to get someone lynched day 1.
Seroja: town seroja is town, look at her meta its super similar. I hate going up against town seroja when I'm scum, so I'm well aware of what it looks and feels like (and am happy because I'm not going up against it).
Antonio: meme-y, too casual, noob town. I do suggest you stop making bad assumptions and tieing them to scum or town reads. Being invisible or inactive isn't indicative of anything.
Evan: the way you skirted around the topic of mafia set-up really seemed scummy. Like I said earlier, I don't think mafia would be brazen enough to speculate about their own set-up falsely, and the way you seemed to try to add to the conversation without saying anything really rubbed me the wrong way. Your last post just seemed crappy too... "I bet mafia is in quiet ones... but I also bet mafia is in the talkative ones." It just seems like you are trying to divert attention anywhere.
Punchy: Tone is completely different. I understand improvement, I understand real-life stuff, but such a drastic change in tone and demeanor is typically indicative of scum. Your change in demeanor and tone so far is by far the most notable in some time. Just because three people pick up on it, doesn't mean its all scum too.
Panda: Reads feel like a defense from getting scum read, yet here we are. Not as strong of scum lean as the other two, but something has stuck out to me.
Farobi: did speculate on mafia set up but it was very strange. I don't get what angle you are trying to make with your posts too. Town should be trying to help figure out mafia, but yours are just a big (?)
- - - Post Merge - - -
Well you seem content to lynch yourself, so I figure I would let you have that sweet release
Voting yourself is by far the most stupid and worst play ever. And the only way to train a dog to stop crapping on the floor is to stick their own nose in it.
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
I didn't talk about setup because I felt it was already discussed a lot and wasn't worth much more analysis/speculation. We'll learn much more after d1 and n1. If I don't have anything substantive to add to a discussion, I'm not going to say it just to look like I'm in the thread. The things I've been bringing up are the issues I want to focus on.
I can have two thoughts in my head at the same time. Mafia could be doing one or the other, OR maybe BOTH. They could be ****stirring, they could be quiet, or some could be doing ****stirring and some could be quiet. Why is that hard to contemplate?
- - - Post Merge - - -
Toads, you do have a fair point with voting ITYW, but perhaps she only intended for it to be a placeholder? She was dodgy about voting herself earlier though.
she would if none of the people on that list were her scummates. its probably not the case buts its a possibility, and probably not something to use to read her as town
not sure about that one tbh
very strange reasoning, and yet feels too aggresive to be scum. although i wouldve said campaigning for pres and then saying its cos ur a miller is the same way so idk. gonna keep that one in my brain for later
oof
i'm looking at punchy's behavior as something possible from both angles. i could relate to it as town wanting to improve but i dont recall punchy playing as mafia before so i cant really compare that aspect to anything. i also feel that a punchy train could be easily started by scum, but at the same time i'm still somewhat conflicted on his alignment cause basing a player's mindset using my own is fatal. at the moment i think his lynch may be the most beneficial bc of how much info we can gain from the exchanges earlier.
bianca vs locket actually provided some funky fresh content. so far slight sl towards bianca considering how she just threw off the argument after locket engaged properly in it. and bianca in general is so inconsistent with how she plays that i wouldn't be surprised if scum bianca would take that risk.
scum is definitely somewhere in bianca, toads, and punchy. though i also feel that ness would add a newbie in the mix too. so far the new guys seem genuine enough and the only outlier is really punchy. these are just quick reads i may put a whole colored list later when im not procrastinating, but im ok with either a punchy info lynch or bianca likely scum lynch.
bianca vs locket actually provided some funky fresh content. so far slight sl towards bianca considering how she just threw off the argument after locket engaged properly in it. and bianca in general is so inconsistent with how she plays that i wouldn't be surprised if scum bianca would take that risk.
scum is definitely somewhere in bianca, toads, and punchy. though i also feel that ness would add a newbie in the mix too. so far the new guys seem genuine enough and the only outlier is really punchy. these are just quick reads i may put a whole colored list later when im not procrastinating, but im ok with either a punchy info lynch or bianca likely scum lynch.
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
toads, don't you think this is just a bit too much?
- Status
