Mafia The Murder of Woodpines Oregon - Game Thread - Endgame

[cornimer]

im not sure if were allowed to ask questions like this, but if we are, did u ever play epicmafia ness?

- - - Post Merge - - -



i remember sniper being different tho, couldnt they only kill people during day time?

- - - Post Merge - - -


given the fact the mayor in the flavour text was only killed by one person and the small size of the game, its probably safe to assume there isnt an sk or whatever

I think the flavour story is totally irrelevant and Ness will descend and kill us all if we speculate on that

- - - Post Merge - - -

(That was @the third point)

 

[illunie]

I think the flavour story is totally irrelevant and Ness will descend and kill us all if we speculate on that

- - - Post Merge - - -

(That was @the third point)

true, but the second point still stands

- - - Post Merge - - -

the second point of the third point

 

[cornimer]

If for some reason there are only two mafia I think there is definitely a third party. If there are three mafia I would say probably not

 

[PunchyTheCat]

If for some reason there are only two mafia I think there is definitely a third party. If there are three mafia I would say probably not

Yes. Almost definitely true. Very random theory: (only for SK) If the mafia guess the lynch correctly, they get to kill. The killing TP would always be able to kill.

 

[illunie]

If for some reason there are only two mafia I think there is definitely a third party. If there are three mafia I would say probably not

maybe it could be argued that two mafia with ultra powerful abilities could be their own team? especially since kp is a non factor in terms of balance.

tbh i think the fact that the lack of kp was such a big point which needed to be adressed proves the absence of a lethal tp entirely, since the fact it needed to be adressed shows that there may be some discrepancy in the amount of kills per night, thus

- - - Post Merge - - -

wtf ipad what r u doing
disregard the second 'paragraph' it doesnt make sense

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yes. Almost definitely true. Very random theory: (only for SK) If the mafia guess the lynch correctly, they get to kill. The killing TP would always be able to kill.

most likely way too experimental to be included in this game

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I'm getting a gut feeling TR from Rune, I need to reread AMP

 

[Farobi]

wot

where do u expect it to mention hostile thirds

Considering that mafia already has an ~unconventional~ killing process, i think that any third parties present aren't night killers. Like for example mafia can kill twice per night through uncertain ways, and there's a serial killer too, that doesn't seem favorable to town at all lest theres blue roles. And any less (~1KP for mafia) is also pretty unbalanced.

My take on it is that there's a slim chance of there being a non-hostile TP, but I still stand on town v mafia esp considering the number of players being as small as it is. An addition of TP hostile would disrupt the balance I would imagine.

 

[Seroja]

damn all these talk about roles always gets my head spinning

How experienced are you?
Are you town-sided?
What's your preferred alignment?
Who's in the mafia team?

so-so, havent played in a long time
yes duh
town
too early to tell plus not everyone's checked in yet

feeling like farobi seemed genuine in trying to figure out the mafia team, but not sure what to make of rune yet.

 

[Locket]

Hello, I've arrived.

How experienced are you? This is my third game that I have played recently.
Are you town-sided? I'd hope so. (I am)
What's your preferred alignment? I've only been town before, so I have no idea.
Who's in the mafia team? How am I supposed to know?

 

[glow]

Considering that mafia already has an ~unconventional~ killing process, i think that any third parties present aren't night killers. Like for example mafia can kill twice per night through uncertain ways, and there's a serial killer too, that doesn't seem favorable to town at all lest theres blue roles. And any less (~1KP for mafia) is also pretty unbalanced.

My take on it is that there's a slim chance of there being a non-hostile TP, but I still stand on town v mafia esp considering the number of players being as small as it is. An addition of TP hostile would disrupt the balance I would imagine.

not sure i can agree with your assumptions? this is what we know:

on the op its quite clear on the fact that theres at least one mafia who grants the team X number of KP. e.g. strongman

&

2 mafia KP is the standard for this size game

from there i interpreted that:

the KP is calculated this way to grant an advantage to mafia should one of them be lynched. this makes two mafia unlikely and three mafia pretty likely. but a fourth mafia or a hostile tp aren't unlikely, though both those of those together is extremely unlikely.

to me it's kinda pointless to speculate on thirds when you haven't had a night phase yet anyway

 

[PandaDarling]

Hello everyone! just getting home from work.

1,How experienced are you?
Fairly...
2.Are you town-sided?
Yes...
3.What's your preferred alignment?
Town...
4.Who's in the mafia team?
Glow, Farobi, Runeraider...

most likely 3 member mafia team, and i agree a tp will show themselves in due time if they are present.

 

[dedenne]

How experienced are you?
I've played a few games but I'm still dumb

Are you town-sided
Yes

What's your preferred alignment?
I've never been mafia so town

Who's in the mafia team?
A bit too early to speculate but I never really have an idea anyway

 

[unravel]

Hi guys will be back

 

[PunchyTheCat]

What are some games that Amanda has played in? I'm getting town vibes but I want to check her meta.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Another Theory: scum are all 1 or 2 shot vigs and there's a Dormant SK.

 

[cornimer]

feeling like farobi seemed genuine in trying to figure out the mafia team, but not sure what to make of rune yet.

I'm a little wary of Farobi actually, the last time I remember him really taking charge (which was in wild west mafia, as meme-y as that game was) he was scum. And I had completely townleaned him that time. Not that I'm legit scumleaning him yet but I'll be keeping an eye on him :eyes:

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I also think that we should drift away from the KP thing until night. That's the only discussion we have.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm a little wary of Farobi actually, the last time I remember him really taking charge (which was in wild west mafia, as meme-y as that game was) he was scum. And I had completely townleaned him that time. Not that I'm legit scumleaning him yet but I'll be keeping an eye on him :eyes:

Yes, I just reread WW mafia. I think that you are kind of scummy, reminding me of RHOM, ugh I need to reread more.

 

[cornimer]

I also think that we should drift away from the KP thing until night. That's the only discussion we have.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Yes, I just reread WW mafia. I think that you are kind of scummy, reminding me of RHOM, ugh I need to reread more.

What in my like four posts made you think I'm mafia?

 

[Antonio]

What if there is 4 mafias?

-------
How experienced are you?
First game
Are you town-sided?
No, I'm lopsided
What's your preferred alignment?
huh
Who's in the mafia team?
wha

 

[cornimer]

What if there is 4 mafias?

I think four mafia for fifteen players would be pretty unbalanced, the ratio is usually one mafia for every five players which would perfectly equal three mafia in fifteen, but I'd buy 2 + third party because of what Ness said about the non-standard kp.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, welcome!

 

[Antonio]

Thanks Vanessa!! 4 out of 15 is still a pretty good ratio and could be unexpected.