Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
Because from our experience, 4 mafia is too much for a 15 player pool....3 maybe but 4 no...
Mafia The Murder of Woodpines Oregon - Game Thread - Endgame
- Thread starter N e s s
- Start date
- Status
Because from our experience, 4 mafia is too much for a 15 player pool....3 maybe but 4 no...
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
That has nothing to do with the current quote and I already got the message.
- - - Post Merge - - -
by current quote, I mean the one you provided for me
- - - Post Merge - - -
of me**
amanda1983
Senior Member
(I've been trying to post this off-and-on for the past two hours now due to technical difficulties so if anything happened in the past few hours, I'll see after I finally get this done.)
I spent awhile looking up roles and rereading some old games to refresh myself on some stuff. Agreed that we shouldn't spend more time on KP stuff until we have solid info (so, night kills) to go on.
I haven't yet read any games in-depth from like June last year and the last game played, so theres a bunch of players here I don't know much about yet. I'll make sure to look them up before I make a full reads post.
For now, I'll only comment on players I'm familiar with.
Initial thoughts :
glow - active and engaged, asking questions (Farobi RE 3rd party comment), contributing info (roles), and opinions (KP discussion). I'm comfortable putting her as my top Town Lean rn.
Toads - active and engaged, contributing to discussions openly and in a generally calm and relaxed manner. He seems very much like the Town!Toads I'm used to, and nothing like the Mafia!Toads so far. Town Lean.
Seroja - I'll wait til there's more from her before I comment
Panda - as with Seroja
---
I was going to hold off on commenting on other players until I've read up on them, but I realised it's better if I just put my first impressions done now, so here they are real quick :
1. Amazonevan19 - seems to know what they're doing and offered opinions, albeit only all in the one post so far
2. Vampnessa - Town Lean. Paying attention and thinking about the dynamics (player count vs Mafia) in a natural way
3. PunchyDaHufflepuff - similar to Vampnessa, they seem to be trying to figure the game out in a natural way. Town Lean
4. Toadsworthy
5. Farobi - was a part of KP/3rd party discussions, seems to be candid with their posts, though I'm a bit hazy on who was posting exactly what (need to read back through all that carefully later) ; null for now
6. Amanda1983 - a sleep-deprived moron who should have learnt by now to not have 5839 tabs open on her damned phone and then be surprised when Chrome won't ****ing work long enough to send a Mafia post through before bedtime..
7. Locket - null
8. Antonio - new player, active and asking questions and taking things in. Town Lean
9. Biancasbotque - null
10. Seroja
11. glow
12. Runeraider - discussion with Farobi and others was a bit confusing, need to read back through that carefully later ; null for now
13. Dedenne2 - null
14. PandaDarling
15. ITookYourWaffles - null
---
I'm really hoping this made sense enough. Please ask any questions if not, or I left anything out, or you want other info. And, hi! to people I don't know yet
- - - Post Merge - - -
Amazonevan19 - null for now
- - - Post Merge - - -
Antonio, I believe they were saying that the reason your initial post (to the RQS) seemed so Town-like (or even, the most Town of any post here, therefore the Towniest, as glow called it) is because of your Mafia player count comment. They were explaining specifically *why* that comment screams Town!Antonio to us. It's not a problem or anything, just a context thing that you'll pick up as you go.
I spent awhile looking up roles and rereading some old games to refresh myself on some stuff. Agreed that we shouldn't spend more time on KP stuff until we have solid info (so, night kills) to go on.
I haven't yet read any games in-depth from like June last year and the last game played, so theres a bunch of players here I don't know much about yet. I'll make sure to look them up before I make a full reads post.
For now, I'll only comment on players I'm familiar with.
Initial thoughts :
glow - active and engaged, asking questions (Farobi RE 3rd party comment), contributing info (roles), and opinions (KP discussion). I'm comfortable putting her as my top Town Lean rn.
Toads - active and engaged, contributing to discussions openly and in a generally calm and relaxed manner. He seems very much like the Town!Toads I'm used to, and nothing like the Mafia!Toads so far. Town Lean.
Seroja - I'll wait til there's more from her before I comment
Panda - as with Seroja
---
I was going to hold off on commenting on other players until I've read up on them, but I realised it's better if I just put my first impressions done now, so here they are real quick :
1. Amazonevan19 - seems to know what they're doing and offered opinions, albeit only all in the one post so far
2. Vampnessa - Town Lean. Paying attention and thinking about the dynamics (player count vs Mafia) in a natural way
3. PunchyDaHufflepuff - similar to Vampnessa, they seem to be trying to figure the game out in a natural way. Town Lean
4. Toadsworthy
5. Farobi - was a part of KP/3rd party discussions, seems to be candid with their posts, though I'm a bit hazy on who was posting exactly what (need to read back through all that carefully later) ; null for now
6. Amanda1983 - a sleep-deprived moron who should have learnt by now to not have 5839 tabs open on her damned phone and then be surprised when Chrome won't ****ing work long enough to send a Mafia post through before bedtime..
7. Locket - null
8. Antonio - new player, active and asking questions and taking things in. Town Lean
9. Biancasbotque - null
10. Seroja
11. glow
12. Runeraider - discussion with Farobi and others was a bit confusing, need to read back through that carefully later ; null for now
13. Dedenne2 - null
14. PandaDarling
15. ITookYourWaffles - null
---
I'm really hoping this made sense enough. Please ask any questions if not, or I left anything out, or you want other info. And, hi! to people I don't know yet
- - - Post Merge - - -
Amazonevan19 - null for now
- - - Post Merge - - -
Antonio, I believe they were saying that the reason your initial post (to the RQS) seemed so Town-like (or even, the most Town of any post here, therefore the Towniest, as glow called it) is because of your Mafia player count comment. They were explaining specifically *why* that comment screams Town!Antonio to us. It's not a problem or anything, just a context thing that you'll pick up as you go.
ok I spent the whole day playing my newest otome game so forgive me. thank you for not spam posting, it's great to come back and not have too many pages to catch up on.
it would be great if we can get clickies soon.
I see your point. it's just that from the few games I played with him I felt like his tone was genuine. I'm not townleaning him yet tho since all he talked about were just technical stuff.
after rereading the thread rune kind of give me town vibes simply based on the carefree way he types. didn't seem forced, as in it didn't sound like he was trying to be helpful when he discussed about mafia kp and role possibilities.
dedenne, antony, panda, waffles and locket - I have no idea :shrugs:
punchy seems more quiet that usual, i miss the silly punchy tbh
amanda asked questions but hmm they seemed a bit like asking just for the sake of asking. would need more before I can read her either way however.
toads
I like the tone in vanessa's posts. I agree that the kp discussion was a bit distracting even though it got the thread moving.
null on glow cos she's good at emulating her town play as scum but she's raised some good points. I agree Dolby's absence is felt but I'm sort of relieved he isn't in this game cos at least I wont get scumread just solely based on teammate speculations.
evan made one post with a neat lil reads list. he's the hardest to read tho so null.
bianca hun thanks for the TL but I'm not townleaning u yet even though i love u. are you mafia? you can tell me.
did I miss anyone? sorry for the ****ty reads.
it would be great if we can get clickies soon.
I see your point. it's just that from the few games I played with him I felt like his tone was genuine. I'm not townleaning him yet tho since all he talked about were just technical stuff.
after rereading the thread rune kind of give me town vibes simply based on the carefree way he types. didn't seem forced, as in it didn't sound like he was trying to be helpful when he discussed about mafia kp and role possibilities.
dedenne, antony, panda, waffles and locket - I have no idea :shrugs:
punchy seems more quiet that usual, i miss the silly punchy tbh
amanda asked questions but hmm they seemed a bit like asking just for the sake of asking. would need more before I can read her either way however.
toads
i believe this. jk
I like the tone in vanessa's posts. I agree that the kp discussion was a bit distracting even though it got the thread moving.
null on glow cos she's good at emulating her town play as scum but she's raised some good points. I agree Dolby's absence is felt but I'm sort of relieved he isn't in this game cos at least I wont get scumread just solely based on teammate speculations.
evan made one post with a neat lil reads list. he's the hardest to read tho so null.
bianca hun thanks for the TL but I'm not townleaning u yet even though i love u. are you mafia? you can tell me.
did I miss anyone? sorry for the ****ty reads.
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
@Amanda do you think you could tell me a game you were scum in and a game you were town in? You're the only returning player I haven't played with before so I'd like to get a better idea of your normal playstyles
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
@Amanda do you think you could tell me a game you were scum in and a game you were town in? You're the only returning player I haven't played with before so I'd like to get a better idea of your normal playstyles
I echo this. There's a lot of new players and having something to go off of with Amanda (a returnee) would be great
Antonio seems fairly genuine to me so far, and his paranoia smacks of townie to me, but we'll see. Too soon to say if being coached or not
amanda1983
Senior Member
@Amanda do you think you could tell me a game you were scum in and a game you were town in? You're the only returning player I haven't played with before so I'd like to get a better idea of your normal playstyles
My first game was Miraculous Cultists, where I was Town up until almost the end of the game when I became Cult - http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?386403
The wiki only has one other game I was in - http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?387783
So I'll look back through Ness' history thread and find the others + my roles here
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
never hurt to be careful and always keep newbie bianca in mind
that is def true but at least Antonio isn't going out of his way to act stupid, like Bianca did
I agree with most (which translates into approximately 2) people that Antonio sounds genuine. I don't think a newb scum would ask about the amount of members in the maf team unless he got a prompt from quick topic which is highly unlikely
Reads coming later stay tuned.
- - - Post Merge - - -
And I just missed a load of posts. GREAT
Reads coming later stay tuned.
- - - Post Merge - - -
And I just missed a load of posts. GREAT
amanda1983
Senior Member
These are the other games I was in that I could find :
Town but I died N1 http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?410382-Overwatch-Mafia-End-Game-Town-wins!
Traitor (so appears to be on Mafia team but really 3rd Party) http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?419030-Paper-Mario-Thousand-Year-Door-Mafia-Mafia-Win!!
Town, as a replacement player http://www.belltreeforums.com/showt...a-Steven-Universe-2-Mafia!!!-Town-and-Kat-win!!!!
- - - Post Merge - - -
EBWOP : I was also a replacement as Traitor in Paper Mario
Could you say why you think so?
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
Thank you!
Biancasbotique
Sweet Feather
I am not mafia hun...yay!
Ok i didn't word it correctly but I'm pretty sure most people got my point...
I think...
But I don't think a newb scum would ask this (unless getting coached via qt)
Antonio
✦ Any Pronouns ✦
It really wasn't a question though. It was more like throwing an idea out there. Also:
- Status
