Mafia The Murder of Woodpines Oregon - Game Thread - Endgame

[Farobi]

I'm a little wary of Farobi actually, the last time I remember him really taking charge (which was in wild west mafia, as meme-y as that game was) he was scum. And I had completely townleaned him that time. Not that I'm legit scumleaning him yet but I'll be keeping an eye on him :eyes:

I mean looking at the player list the only notably skilled player is glow and if she is scum then town could be easy sheep. There are a couple of high-mid tier players scattered but the newbies more or less dominate the list which could suck for the later days if they're the remaining town. The kp speculation also got blown a bit too much which tho useful (?) still kinda sucks because little else has been mentioned aside from the "i contributed guys" rq responses

And that playstyle makes sense if we only get like 6 pages of content 12 hours in to Day 1 lol. to be fair i'd rather be the backseat player that shouts my thoughts but there haven't been much discussion during that time anyways.

ness can you add player links in? thankies

 

[toadsworthy]

Are you experienced: Yes, but I'm also pretty stupid sometimes
Are you two-sided: Yes, its good to be back in the light
Preferred Alignment: Being mafia and making people believe theres an oracle is pretty dope ngl
Mafia team: Dad, Dolby, Jacob

 

[dedenne]

What if there is 4 mafias?

-------
How experienced are you?
First game
Are you town-sided?
No, I'm lopsided
What's your preferred alignment?
huh
Who's in the mafia team?
wha

Yee welcome Antonio
Yeah, what Vanessa said. 4 would be a bit unbalanced, so the best bet is 2/3 +maybe a third party. Ness is a very experienced host so he knows how to balance a game

If there is 4 scum, there would be no tp but I'm ruling out the 4 scum possibility.

Also if this post seems a bit off it's because I'm literally in Morrisons atm shopping with my dad and I'm impatient lol

 

[toadsworthy]

town-sided*

 

[cornimer]

I mean looking at the player list the only notably skilled player is glow and if she is scum then town could be easy sheep. There are a couple of high-mid tier players scattered but the newbies more or less dominate the list which could suck for the later days if they're the remaining town. The kp speculation also got blown a bit too much which tho useful (?) still kinda sucks because little else has been mentioned aside from the "i contributed guys" rq responses

All of this is very true, I don't like how much kp speculation there has been in the first 12 hours when there is no way we can know anything yet, seems like a bit of a distraction even though there is not enough posts to do significant scumhunting.

 

[Antonio]

Thanks Vanessa!! 4 out of 15 is still a pretty good ratio and could be unexpected.

Yee welcome Antonio
Yeah, what Vanessa said. 4 would be a bit unbalanced, so the best bet is 2/3 +maybe a third party. Ness is a very experienced host so he knows how to balance a game

If there is 4 scum, there would be no tp but I'm ruling out the 4 scum possibility.

Also if this post seems a bit off it's because I'm literally in Morrisons atm shopping with my dad and I'm impatient lol

hmm ok

 

[toadsworthy]

The KP thing means it doesn't follow traditional equation of # on team/two and rounded up = KP. To me this means that there is some interesting role on the mafia team or a strange amount of mafia members. I did this in Paper Mario Mafia because I had 4 mafia members where 1 was a traitor. 2 seems less likely, because it would mean their KP is fixed at 2 or based something strange.

Honestly though, we shouldn't speculate this much on it. I do TL Rune for bringing this up, not as much on farobi.... idk I agree with Vanessa its uncharacteristic of him. But me and Vanessa always agree because were lovers, millers, scum

 

[Farobi]

i tried being town leader too guys but y'all just striked it off as dumb reads lol (caxnival). im not mafia this time, promise.

 

[toadsworthy]

i tried being town leader too guys but y'all just striked it off as dumb reads lol (caxnival). im not mafia this time, promise.

Then start reading people and stop reading into that one sentence

 

[Farobi]

Then start reading people and stop reading into that one sentence

Yeah, cause it'd be so easy 7 pages in first day with most people having 1-2 posts. I'll get to that when when things actually happen my dude.

 

[toadsworthy]

Yeah, cause it'd be so easy 7 pages in first day with most people having 1-2 posts. I'll get to that when when things actually happen my dude.

You make some small reads on what we do have, that leads to discussion, then more reads, then more discussion... tis the cycle of mafia....... my dude

 

[Antonio]

You make some small reads on what we do have, that leads to discussion, then more reads, then more discussion... tis the cycle of mafia....... my dude

what do we have?

 

[Farobi]

You make some small reads on what we do have, that leads to discussion, then more reads, then more discussion... tis the cycle of mafia....... my dude

well ok, here are my gut reads

tl - i think dedenne seemed genuine in answering antonio, tl.
rune's interaction with me seemed different from their old game, so slight tl.

slight sl - anyone who posted rqs and just left, that is
locket and panda always look scummy to me, and based on my ~v meticulous read~ on their rq answers im kinda iffy on them

 

[dedenne]

well ok, here are my gut reads

tl - i think dedenne seemed genuine in answering antonio, tl.

W-wait
Is this..
A townlean for Dedenne? Wooooaaaahhhh
(This is a joke **** post if you couldn't tell lol)

 

[Farobi]

W-wait
Is this..
A townlean for Dedenne? Wooooaaaahhhh
(This is a joke **** post if you couldn't tell lol)

Correct me for any mistakes please

 

[amazonevan19]

On page 4; I doubt there's hostile TP(s) alongside mafia; this game is only 15 people and having 3KP per night is a bit OP.

Also, let the record show that Punchy's RQs are trash and don't actually really help us with anything.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Slight sus of dedenne cuz she jumped onto Antonio's "four mafia" hypothesis very quickly. Don't like that

Amanda is null for me; she's asking good questions but role and KP speculation at this point is only good to a degree before we see the night kills.

Glow is a slight tr; I like how she tried to direct discussion away from KP

 

[glow]

i’m actually happy w/ the pace of this game rn

it does feel odd playing without dolby though, he’s one of the ones that really adds momentum to the game

- - - Post Merge - - -

You make some small reads on what we do have, that leads to discussion, then more reads, then more discussion... tis the cycle of mafia....... my dude

i think the point was that he doesn’t have [or] does not want to say any reads on the content available

which is relatable since i was thinking about how i felt like he was towny but his emphasis on thirds felt weird. the only people that should be theorizing on thirds d1 r maf

do you have any reads?

- - - Post Merge - - -

excuse me what happened to my invisible

- - - Post Merge - - -

back 2 the shadow realm

- - - Post Merge - - -

Hello everyone! just getting home from work.

1,How experienced are you?
Fairly...
2.Are you town-sided?
Yes...
3.What's your preferred alignment?
Town...
4.Who's in the mafia team?
Glow, Farobi, Runeraider...

most likely 3 member mafia team, and i agree a tp will show themselves in due time if they are present.

panda 4 gf 2k18

- - - Post Merge - - -

What if there is 4 mafias?

-------
How experienced are you?
First game
Are you town-sided?
No, I'm lopsided
What's your preferred alignment?
huh
Who's in the mafia team?
wha

this is honestly the towniest post in the game

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Also, let the record show that Punchy's RQs are trash and don't actually really help us with anything.

God damn it at least I tried

- - - Post Merge - - -

Nvm on Vanessa I was overthinking it.

 

[Biancasbotique]

I really think there's only 3 mafia, and one TP. pretty standard for a game this size plus 3 blue roles

- - - Post Merge - - -

and I am townleaning Seroja coz that's my girl right there ha ha! <3

- - - Post Merge - - -

Punchy are you scum this time?

- - - Post Merge - - -

I agree with glow..its weird without Dolby...but you scum always kill him night 1!!bohoo

 

[Antonio]

Why is my post the towniest post here? Why are you referring to it as "towniest" and not like "something a town member would say"? Towniest is quite specific.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm paranoid though so...