Mafia The Murder of Woodpines Oregon - Game Thread - Endgame

[amazonevan19]

(a) dodging and continuing to offer no evidence for your read of me. Purely emotional and reactionary scumread because you're scared that you know we're on your track and hunting you down, so you're trying to cast shade on me. Except it's not gonna work because either you'll kill me tonight to shut me up, or will keep me around to keep scapegoating me, and are probably right now scrambling on QT with your scumbuddies to fabricate a case against me for tomorrow...cuz obviously you don't have any case, with any evidence, right now.

(b) extremely instrumental in getting the lynch away from punchy, who is 85% likely to be your teammate at this point. And you used glow as a (albeit valid) excuse to do so

(c) parading around your glow read in the aftermath like you're some superstar, when in fact you probably did it precisely to look more townie.

The vote has made it uber obvious who's who in my mind

 

[illunie]

gimme a sec to catch up, my mum made me serve pizza at school and i think im scarred for life

 

[Seroja]

(a) dodging and continuing to offer no evidence for your read of me. Purely emotional and reactionary scumread because you're scared that you know we're on your track and hunting you down, so you're trying to cast shade on me. Except it's not gonna work because either you'll kill me tonight to shut me up, or will keep me around to keep scapegoating me, and are probably right now scrambling on QT with your scumbuddies to fabricate a case against me for tomorrow...cuz obviously you don't have any case, with any evidence, right now.

(b) extremely instrumental in getting the lynch away from punchy, who is 85% likely to be your teammate at this point. And you used glow as a (albeit valid) excuse to do so

(c) parading around your glow read in the aftermath like you're some superstar, when in fact you probably did it precisely to look more townie.

The vote has made it uber obvious who's who in my mind

you could have at least quoted me before responding.

a) the thing is, I'm town you see, so you suddenly out of nowhere saying I'm guaranteed scum without first saying why obviously gonna make me feel suspect. have that ever occured to you Mr Opportunist? and all that mumbo jumbo about what I would do is just you explaining to me in detail what you would do or are doing if you're scum.

b) this doesn't make any sense. how was I extremely instrumental in getting the lynch away from punchy? tf this is laughably bad. you're exposing yourself Mr Opportunist, be careful.

c) I was simply replying to toads who was understandably confused. notice that I didn't at all try to make him scummy even though he was high time sussing me? that's because he actually had a reason to sus me which I understand, unlike you Mr Opportunist, who jumped on the first chance to make call scum.

 

[amazonevan19]

you could have at least quoted me before responding.

a) the thing is, I'm town you see, so you suddenly out of nowhere saying I'm guaranteed scum without first saying why obviously gonna make me feel suspect. have that ever occured to you Mr Opportunist? and all that mumbo jumbo about what I would do is just you explaining to me in detail what you would do or are doing if you're scum.

b) this doesn't make any sense. how was I extremely instrumental in getting the lynch away from punchy? tf this is laughably bad. you're exposing yourself Mr Opportunist, be careful.

c) I was simply replying to toads who was understandably confused. notice that I didn't at all try to make him scummy even though he was high time sussing me? that's because he actually had a reason to sus me which I understand, unlike you Mr Opportunist, who jumped on the first chance to make call scum.

(a) "I'm town, you see" lol nice try, forced af btw but I digress. It was very apparent that I was calling out the people who directed the lynch away from Punchy, and that was my main reason I've put you in the scumteam I've listed. Call it "mumbo jumbo" all you want to distract from the real issues at hand. You are trying to make me look bad when it's not MY fault a townie is dead...your posts are all smoke and mirrors and you want to discredit me as much as possible. I'm seeing through your false little townie act here sister. Go tell your scummates that their "case" on me is garbage.

(b) ...you didn't even respond to this point. At all. You just said it was "laughably bad" when you KNOW EXACTLY what you did. You were trying to get votes away from punchy, plain and simple. I don't care that it was on glow; you knew glow wasn't on your team and was a good scapegoat to divert from your teammate and try to look good. The fact glow is hostile TP thus perfectly explains your screeching about how great you are for reading glow - you did not know that glow was TP, but after the results, it gave you ammo to boost your ego to the nanosphere. The fact you are mostly concerned about that instead of the fact that you were directly responsible for an innocent person's death is telling.

(c) lolol why would you try and turn this on toads in the first place? You know he's being pretty widely townread and to try and cast sus would only make you look bad.

You keep trying to make this about ME and calling ME an opportunist, but really the onus is on YOU for being opportunistic as hell and labeling ME scum, when it's clear as day that Waffles' blood is on you and Punchy/Farobi/Amanda's hands. You knew glow couldn't be lynched, but you also didn't want to be in the Waffles train, so you went with glow and were lucky enough to get an even better outcome than you could have possibly envisioned.

Stop the lies. Stop the cover up. We're coming for you scummy girl.

 

[illunie]

alright what the frick is seroja talking about lmao that insta omgus

- - - Post Merge - - -

(c) lolol why would you try and turn this on toads in the first place? You know he's being pretty widely townread and to try and cast sus would only make you look bad.

i dont think that shes trying to turn this on toads, i think shes trying to turn this on you. what shes saying is that toad was justified in questioning her, but you werent because idk???

 

[amazonevan19]

alright what the frick is seroja talking about lmao that insta omgus

- - - Post Merge - - -



i dont think that shes trying to turn this on toads, i think shes trying to turn this on you. what shes saying is that toad was justified in questioning her, but you werent because idk???

we're on the same wavelength this game lmao

She asked me why would she try to turn this on toads. I was not saying she was, but saying "exactly...why WOULD you?" The fact she thought of this heavily implies she at least considered trying to twist it to make toads look bad...hmmm. And she is trying to make me look bad probably because I'm being much more vocal and hitting some scummy nerves way harder than toads did. Plus I've been a nonentity in most people's reads list, as opposed to toad, who's been a much more contentious character

 

[Seroja]

(a) "I'm town, you see" lol nice try, forced af btw but I digress. It was very apparent that I was calling out the people who directed the lynch away from Punchy, and that was my main reason I've put you in the scumteam I've listed. Call it "mumbo jumbo" all you want to distract from the real issues at hand. You are trying to make me look bad when it's not MY fault a townie is dead...your posts are all smoke and mirrors and you want to discredit me as much as possible. I'm seeing through your false little townie act here sister. Go tell your scummates that their "case" on me is garbage.

(b) ...you didn't even respond to this point. At all. You just said it was "laughably bad" when you KNOW EXACTLY what you did. You were trying to get votes away from punchy, plain and simple. I don't care that it was on glow; you knew glow wasn't on your team and was a good scapegoat to divert from your teammate and try to look good. The fact glow is hostile TP thus perfectly explains your screeching about how great you are for reading glow - you did not know that glow was TP, but after the results, it gave you ammo to boost your ego to the nanosphere. The fact you are mostly concerned about that instead of the fact that you were directly responsible for an innocent person's death is telling.

(c) lolol why would you try and turn this on toads in the first place? You know he's being pretty widely townread and to try and cast sus would only make you look bad.

You keep trying to make this about ME and calling ME an opportunist, but really the onus is on YOU for being opportunistic as hell and labeling ME scum, when it's clear as day that Waffles' blood is on you and Punchy/Farobi/Amanda's hands. You knew glow couldn't be lynched, but you also didn't want to be in the Waffles train, so you went with glow and were lucky enough to get an even better outcome than you could have possibly envisioned.

Stop the lies. Stop the cover up. We're coming for you scummy girl.

this is fun

a) evan, wtf is this even? I wasn't even trying to make you look bad, it was you who did that to me lol? so what does that make you? what when did I even blame you for a dead townie? you were away the whole time duh? if you were so called 'calling out' to people who directed the lynch away from punchy, then where's panda in all of this? this is the most opportunistic garbage I have ever read.

so you said "It was very apparent that I was calling out the people who directed the lynch away from Punchy, and that was my main reason I've put you in the scumteam I've listed."

I leave for dinner and this happens. Gdi, I knew waffles was town. Ugh

Well at least we know glow is TP now, and that there's probably three mafs. Catching up on what I've missed, but geez louise guys...

ok yeah, after a quick read I am helllllla suspicious of the people who flipped to waffles, and pretty sure they blitzed to save punchy last minute.

instalynch punchy or amanda next day. Amanda has skyrocketed in my sus list, maybe even my top scumread after that.

Punchy/Seroja/Amanda/Farobi

3/4 scum in this list

Guaranteed

kill them ALL. No mercy.

there we go. you said you were sus of people who FLIPPED their votes to waffles. was I one of those? did you mention anything about sussing people who voted other people? no. naturally I felt it suspicious that you suddenly include me without reason.

b) it was not worth refuting because it didn't make sense. you're making up a story that didn't happen. also this point is just you insulting me. I know I sounded arrogant and I'm sorry. but how am I the reason for a person's death. are you not aware of how ridiculous you sound right now?

c) no my point is, if I am an OMGUS person, I would have OMGUS toads too. the reason why I said I was sus of you is because you were opportunistic in calling me scum. if you had made valid points like toads did I wouldn't have felt iffy about you.

no no it didn't make me opportunistic when it was you who zeroed in on me after seeing how toads were questioning me, and not consider panda in your list as well. toads was suspect of both me and panda, but only I was around to answer him. your whole 'case' on me is so fake sounding I can't even tell if you're serious or what. it's just, idk laughably bad.

 

[illunie]

we're on the same wavelength this game lmao

She asked me why would she try to turn this on toads. I was not saying she was, but saying "exactly...why WOULD you?" The fact she thought of this heavily implies she at least considered trying to twist it to make toads look bad...hmmm. And she is trying to make me look bad probably because I'm being much more vocal and hitting some scummy nerves way harder than toads did. Plus I've been a nonentity in most people's reads list, as opposed to toad, who's been a much more contentious character

i dont want to agree with u so much but it keeps happening, if u turn out to be scum im shooting myself on camera i cant be that dumb

i think shes trying to say that the reason she didnt suss toad is because he was somehow justified, and u werent. at least thats what i got out of it. it would be nice if she were here so i didnt have to divine her words like the egyptians during the ten plagues diving gods message, but shes gone off somewhere

- - - Post Merge - - -

nvm shes here just invis

 

[Seroja]

i dont want to agree with u so much but it keeps happening, if u turn out to be scum im shooting myself on camera i cant be that dumb

i think shes trying to say that the reason she didnt suss toad is because he was somehow justified, and u werent. at least thats what i got out of it. it would be nice if she were here so i didnt have to divine her words like the egyptians during the ten plagues diving gods message, but shes gone off somewhere

- - - Post Merge - - -

nvm shes here just invis

ok good go read up.

- - - Post Merge - - -

evan is known to be manipulative as hell as scum, which was why I said he's hard to read.

 

[illunie]

evan is known to be manipulative as hell as scum, which was why I said he's hard to read.

if hes so hard to read, whats with the insta 'ur scum'?

 

[Seroja]

if hes so hard to read, whats with the insta 'ur scum'?

darling, I said he was hard to read in my first read list, and understandably so cos he could be manipulative. and if you have read my reply to him and still not see how sus it was for him to call me 'guaranteed' scum then I don't know what else to tell you.

 

[illunie]

darling, I said he was hard to read in my first read list, and understandably so cos he could be manipulative. and if you have read my reply to him and still not see how sus it was for him to call me 'guaranteed' scum then I don't know what else to tell you.

i mean if ur gonna call him out for saying ur guaranteed scum and then go and say u think hes scum and not see how someone would question u for it, im gonna be at least a little sus. this kind of double standards seems like it could only be benefical for scum, i feel like a townie would both not be so quick to omgus someone and also realise their mistake if they did and back down, this whole thing seems like a desparate stuggle to make up for being too quick to defend yourself

- - - Post Merge - - -

dont want to respond to the larger post because i dont want to put words in his mouth

- - - Post Merge - - -

his being evans

 

[Seroja]

i mean if ur gonna call him out for saying ur guaranteed scum and then go and say u think hes scum and not see how someone would question u for it, im gonna be at least a little sus. this kind of double standards seems like it could only be benefical for scum, i feel like a townie would both not be so quick to omgus someone and also realise their mistake if they did and back down, this whole thing seems like a desparate stuggle to make up for being too quick to defend yourself

- - - Post Merge - - -

dont want to respond to the larger post because i dont want to put words in his mouth

- - - Post Merge - - -

his being evans

You're missing the point. I am sus of him for putting me in a guaranteed scum list without explaining why. The act of him doing that makes me think of him as an opportunistic scum. You can question me yes, I never stopped you from doing so. My problem is with his so-called case and reason for adding me in that list. If you're gonna say double standard, then it's also on you because it was OK for him to suddenly sus me, but it's not ok for me to suddenly sus me? In my post refuting him I have quoted every single post of his after EOD and none of it explained why I was in that list in the first place.

What he posted after I said he could be scum too further made him look scummy in my eyes tbh. They're just so ridiculous smh.

- - - Post Merge - - -

ebwop: *for me to suddenly sus him dammit

 

[illunie]

You're missing the point. I am sus of him for putting me in a guaranteed scum list without explaining why. The act of him doing that makes me think of him as an opportunistic scum. You can question me yes, I never stopped you from doing so. My problem is with his so-called case and reason for adding me in that list. If you're gonna say double standard, then it's also on you because it was OK for him to suddenly sus me, but it's not ok for me to suddenly sus me? In my post refuting him I have quoted every single post of his after EOD and none of it explained why I was in that list in the first place.

What he posted after I said he could be scum too further made him look scummy in my eyes tbh. They're just so ridiculous smh.

- - - Post Merge - - -

ebwop: *for me to suddenly sus him dammit

i have a few possible arguments against this but again im gonna wait for him to come back bc i dont want to put words in his mouth / give him any outs. i still think his sus on u was more justified than ur sus on him tho

- - - Post Merge - - -

the more i think about it the more voicing my thoughts about what he could be up to sounds like a really bad idea rn, thats all ill say

 

[Seroja]

i have a few possible arguments against this but again im gonna wait for him to come back bc i dont want to put words in his mouth / give him any outs. i still think his sus on u was more justified than ur sus on him tho

- - - Post Merge - - -

the more i think about it the more voicing my thoughts about what he could be up to sounds like a really bad idea rn, thats all ill say

if you have reads against me that is your own you can definitely share it here though. but if you're gonna say things that you think he meant then ok.

but what do you mean "give him any outs"?

 

[illunie]

if you have reads against me that is your own you can definitely share it here though. but if you're gonna say things that you think he meant then ok.

but what do you mean "give him any outs"?

even if i strongly believe hes town that could change at any moment, if he is scum i dont want to give him an explanation he can use in an argument, so id rather keep any thoughts about his possible intentions to myself so he cant just point to it and say that (i dont think hes scum but better safe than sorry)

also my reads from this will come at the end, im more worried about the middle of the argument (the actual content) rather than the end result (who won). rn it looks to me like evans winning but idk that could change

- - - Post Merge - - -

i structured that really poorly, if u want me to address each point in order read the second one first

 

[dedenne]

What why did y'all vote waffles???

Anyway my biggest sus is still punchy, but not as strong as before. We'll see.

 

[illunie]

What why did y'all vote waffles???

Anyway my biggest sus is still punchy, but not as strong as before. We'll see.

idfk lmao

 

[Seroja]

even if i strongly believe hes town that could change at any moment, if he is scum i dont want to give him an explanation he can use in an argument, so id rather keep any thoughts about his possible intentions to myself so he cant just point to it and say that (i dont think hes scum but better safe than sorry)

also my reads from this will come at the end, im more worried about the middle of the argument (the actual content) rather than the end result (who won). rn it looks to me like evans winning but idk that could change

- - - Post Merge - - -

i structured that really poorly, if u want me to address each point in order read the second one first

it's ok I get you, and that's a good decision actually.

 

[illunie]

i have a sneaking suspicion im going to die tonight but i still think its too early to posts reads so im gonna wait till the morning to do that