its still a victory..we eliminated one of the threats to town.
That's how I see it. Both Lyncher and Survivor roles are Anti-Town, so all things considered I'm glad we've gotten that threat out of the way D1. Especially given that if the lynch had moved back to Punchy for any reason (say, a claim from Waffles), we'd have had an even bigger mess to deal with than we'd have realised... as glow would still be here to confuse us further, in addition to the fallout from the ML and the EoD mayhem to work through *and still needing to actually find and lynch Mafia*. Yikes, that was a close call.
it wasnt even that convincing if u think for a second, why did everyone go along with it so easily in the last ten minutes of the day
gaaaaaaaah
- - - Post Merge - - -
oh come on, how is a survivor a threat to town
.... I'm not the most experienced of players but I am quite sure that Survivors are considered Anti-Town for a reason. And that's when they're not the calibre of player that glow is. Given the EoD mess, how on earth could glow still being the game actually be anything *but* a threat to Town???
she's not a survivor, she's a lyncher
She was actually Lyncher but would become a Survivor if she failed to lynch Waffles. Either way, she was at best Anti-Town.
Also I was certain punchy would be lynched and wanted to see what kind of information my vote on glow would generate.
Having gone back over those events and checked the timing, this makes sense to me. I'm sorry I didn't pick up on the discrepancy in pages glow mentioned needing to catch up on in posts #439 (14 pages) and then #441 (she speed-read last 5 pages), and that this happened in four minutes or less. Had I not been focused on Waffles, the copied reads, and how much I TR Punchy, I might have noticed this and paid more attention to her and her motivations. I mean, I'm glad things panned out the way did. But I'm sorry I missed such an obvious red flag. Thanks for catching it and not letting it go.
Dang glow would have still won if I was lynched.
If I understand it right then ya, she almost certainly would have won no matter what ; only way she'd have lost would be if she was NKd. And Waffles would probably have been lynched D2 - leaving us down two Town players instead of one, in addition to the extra cycle of time + effort lost on fulfilling glow's win/con instead of our own.
The more I think about it, the more happy I am with the outcome. We dodged a heck of a painful D2 because of how things played out.
Omg there was a double voter?!?
I'm not really familiar with roles that can double vote, I've only seen it in action once, in the last game (when Ness was President + had a double vote). I think I read in that game that it's *usually* handled as : player 'a' that has two votes, votes for player 'b' as usual (their one vote is visible in the thread), so then the vote tally will ultimately show player 'b' show one vote from player 'a' and also one secret vote.
gimme a sec to catch up, my mum made me serve pizza at school and i think im scarred for life
I was on a very crowded train when I read this and started laughing uncontrollably. I don't know why, but this was just the most hilarious thing I'd read all day. Thank you!
Dafuq?????????
Okay bye good luck and gratz Glow
I'm sorry. You got one heck of a bad RNG draw.
- - - Post Merge - - -
EBWOP :
I'm not really familiar with roles that can double vote, I've only seen it in action once, in the last game (when Ness was President + had a double vote). I think I read in that game that it's *usually* handled as : player 'a' that has two votes, votes for player 'b' as usual (their one vote is visible in the thread), so then the vote tally will ultimately show player 'b' show one vote from player 'a' and also one secret vote.
And the other - uncommon - way it can happen is where they can place their two votes seperately, so on two different players. One done visibly, the other in secret via PM.
Have I understood that correctly??
- - - Post Merge - - -
Vanessa just left without posting at all?
