Mafia The Murder of Woodpines Oregon - Game Thread - Endgame

[PunchyTheCat]

Agreed with Vanessa and toads, I think lynching punchy next is our best bet.
And no more 1 second before EoD chaos!

but but but thats my thing

 

[amazonevan19]

Ok, I've seen what I need to from Seroja.

Lemme explain. I was baiting an OMGUS reaction from Seroja by trying to lump her in with people who legit steered the vote away from punchy. I knew Seroja really didn't, and obviously went after glow. I wanted to see if anything of what I said could make her tick/scumslip. She insta-OMGUS'd me to be sure, which is concerning, but it also makes sense from town!perspective. What I am reading is giving me significant reason to TR. The glow read was pretty spot on. I wasn't here EoD cuz of RL stuff so I could only sort out stuff afterwards.

I'm not insulting you Seroja. I don't think you're a terrible person. I just didn't like your boastfulness when hindsight's 20/20, but the read was solid, and you already apologized for the arrogance aspect, so it's all good. Ik this makes me look super sus but I'm willing to accept criticism for a bad rxn test attempt.

So at this point, I am very confident Punchy and Amanda are teammates, and the last one is a toss-up between Farobi, and Panda. I would need to look into Panda more but the fact I could barely remember she was in the threat makes her insanely sus tbh. Since we know there's a hostile TP, that'd make four scums super unlikely (even though I want to believe in four scums cuz the punchy vote has four people come away looking ultra scummy)

Amanda's explanation sounds a lot like she was posting something to hope town would switch from punchy, but just enough so she wouldn't get sussed afterwards for waffles dying. "Didn't want to lead a lynch on someone not here" yada yada yada...seems very convenient to me.

 

[dedenne]

but but but thats my thing

I don't want to read 20 pages when I should be at the bus stop!!!

- - - Post Merge - - -

Rip ninjad by Evan lemme read

 

[amazonevan19]

*in the thread

- - - Post Merge - - -

dammit dedenne

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh, and I didn't put panda in my list precisely because she was almost a non-entity in my reading of EoD and yet had such an outsized impact on steering away from punchy

 

[dedenne]

I feel like panda is town because iirc in RHOM panda wasn't posting much and if she did it wasn't really contributing, correct me if I'm wrong tho

 

[amazonevan19]

Here's the thing though. If we lynch punchy and he somehow flips town, we're in a heap of trouble. We'd have gained essentially nothing from D1 results cuz all of my analysis rn is predicated on mafia redirecting the d1 lynch. I'm having some issues with carte blanche accepting that scum made it that obvious to save a teammate d1. Course the only way to find out is to investigate or lynch punchy...

- - - Post Merge - - -

I feel like panda is town because iirc in RHOM panda wasn't posting much and if she did it wasn't really contributing, correct me if I'm wrong tho

iirc I don't believe she intervened like she did this D1.

 

[Biancasbotique]

evan, can you put iirc in maftanica, i forgot what it means

 

[cornimer]

I feel like panda is town because iirc in RHOM panda wasn't posting much and if she did it wasn't really contributing, correct me if I'm wrong tho

No you're right, she did exactly that in RHOM. And she did show up at the end of D1 to say she wasn't ok with the lynch candidate at the time (Glow), just like she did here with Punchy

- - - Post Merge - - -

evan, can you put iirc in maftanica, i forgot what it means

It's an abbreviation for If I Recall Correctly

- - - Post Merge - - -

So at this point, I am very confident Punchy and Amanda are teammates, and the last one is a toss-up between Farobi, and Panda. I would need to look into Panda more but the fact I could barely remember she was in the threat makes her insanely sus tbh. Since we know there's a hostile TP, that'd make four scums super unlikely (even though I want to believe in four scums cuz the punchy vote has four people come away looking ultra scummy)

How do we know that???
Or are you saying Glow was hostile

- - - Post Merge - - -

Ok wow that size 7 font looks really obnoxious LOL sorry

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also you're right Evan that reaction test looks super sketch

 

[Biancasbotique]

No you're right, she did exactly that in RHOM. And she did show up at the end of D1 to say she wasn't ok with the lynch candidate at the time (Glow), just like she did here with Punchy

- - - Post Merge - - -




It's an abbreviation for If I Recall Correctly

- - - Post Merge - - -


How do we know that???
Or are you saying Glow was hostile

- - - Post Merge - - -

Ok wow that size 7 font looks really obnoxious LOL sorry

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also you're right Evan that reaction test looks super sketch

thanks hun!

- - - Post Merge - - -

I just notice there are people who intentionally avoid the voting deadline hour to post in the thread...

- - - Post Merge - - -

There's always that one who will always try to be inactive among the mafia i tell you

 

[toadsworthy]

Yeah Evans reasoning and what he did looks really weird, but I'm havinmg a hard time seeing any reason to make that long ass post as mafia. I see it as him being town, but just being misguided. I continue to see punchy as scum, seroja still looks scummy too. I will ISO both before the next lynch to see if a team is likely

 

[amazonevan19]

I was referring to glow being hostile, Vanessa

Yeah, I expect seroja to utterly roast me when she comes back, and I deserve some bad treatment for performing an almost-toads-in-last-game level bad play to try and make sense of d1 results. Though I probably shouldn't be comparing myself to toads last game since he was scum last game

w/e vig shoot me, or investigate investigate me, or lynch me d2 idgaf I played poorly and have been reduced to a Punchian "I suck so kill me now" attitude

 

[Biancasbotique]

Dedenne, Antonio, Amanda, Farobi

can we look into them?

 

[cornimer]

I was referring to glow being hostile, Vanessa

Gotcha, I totally thought you scumslipped for a second (when I did the bold underline size 7 font) but then realized Glow was TP

 

[toadsworthy]

I was referring to glow being hostile, Vanessa

Yeah, I expect seroja to utterly roast me when she comes back, and I deserve some bad treatment for performing an almost-toads-in-last-game level bad play to try and make sense of d1 results. Though I probably shouldn't be comparing myself to toads last game since he was scum last game

w/e vig shoot me, or investigate investigate me, or lynch me d2 idgaf I played poorly and have been reduced to a Punchian "I suck so kill me now" attitude

Uh my balance of goading apathy/sympathy with still trying to contribute last game was oscar worthy. No one can recreate that AtE

 

[Biancasbotique]

Gotcha, I totally thought you scumslipped for a second (when I did the bold underline size 7 font) but then realized Glow was TP

so there should really be 3 scum left and i expect no more TPs

- - - Post Merge - - -

and let's stop focusing on Punchy, coz we have other 2 to fry

 

[toadsworthy]

Dedenne, Antonio, Amanda, Farobi

can we look into them?

Lol what happened to locket?
Amanda and Farobi yes, but the other two not so much

 

[cornimer]

Uh my balance of goading apathy/sympathy with still trying to contribute last game was oscar worthy. No one can recreate that AtE

Forget Gary Oldman you deserve that best actor award

- - - Post Merge - - -

so there should really be 3 scum left and i expect no more TPs

That's what I'm thinking yes

 

[Biancasbotique]

Lol what happened to locket?
Amanda and Farobi yes, but the other two not so much

I mean I assumed it is given considering it is me lol. What do you think about Farobi voting me? or Amanda voting for waffles , firmly, i might add during the voting hour, when iirc waffles isnt even on her radar?

- - - Post Merge - - -

or Antonio reduced to saying strange quirky things when he was very active day 1. Did mafia tell him to lay low?

- - - Post Merge - - -

or Dedenne , who seems to come right after the lynch iirc?

 

[cornimer]

I mean I assumed it is given considering it is me lol. What do you think about Farobi voting me? or Amanda voting for waffles , firmly, i might add during the voting hour, when iirc waffles isnt even on her radar?

- - - Post Merge - - -

or Antonio reduced to saying strange quirky things when he was very active day 1. Did mafia tell him to lay low?

He voted for you??
I totally forgot that, that's scummy as heck!

Also that's not a bad theory about Antonio tbh

 

[Biancasbotique]

He voted for you??
I totally forgot that, that's scummy as heck!

Also that's not a bad theory about Antonio tbh

oh nvm about Farobi, he either got sheepled or mafia piled Waffle