Mafia The Murder of Woodpines Oregon - Game Thread - Endgame

[illunie]

Ok i didn't word it correctly but I'm pretty sure most people got my point...
I think...
But I don't think a newb scum would ask this (unless getting coached via qt)

i thought that was possible too but that would be fairly next level and im not sure if anyone here is good enough to think of that, i could be underestimating people tho

- - - Post Merge - - -

I was going to hold off on commenting on other players until I've read up on them, but I realised it's better if I just put my first impressions done now, so here they are real quick :

1. Amazonevan19 - seems to know what they're doing and offered opinions, albeit only all in the one post so far
2. Vampnessa - Town Lean. Paying attention and thinking about the dynamics (player count vs Mafia) in a natural way
3. PunchyDaHufflepuff - similar to Vampnessa, they seem to be trying to figure the game out in a natural way. Town Lean
4. Toadsworthy
5. Farobi - was a part of KP/3rd party discussions, seems to be candid with their posts, though I'm a bit hazy on who was posting exactly what (need to read back through all that carefully later) ; null for now
6. Amanda1983 - a sleep-deprived moron who should have learnt by now to not have 5839 tabs open on her damned phone and then be surprised when Chrome won't ****ing work long enough to send a Mafia post through before bedtime..
7. Locket - null
8. Antonio - new player, active and asking questions and taking things in. Town Lean
9. Biancasbotque - null
10. Seroja
11. glow
12. Runeraider - discussion with Farobi and others was a bit confusing, need to read back through that carefully later ; null for now
13. Dedenne2 - null
14. PandaDarling
15. ITookYourWaffles - null

is it just me or does this feel fairly wishy washy? like i get it, noones really been talking enough to be able to get a concrete scum read from it but literally all of these reads can be boiled down to either 'theyre contributing, tr' or 'they havent said enough, null'. idk, it doesnt feel like its very townish to be so lenient like this, if amanda is scum i could definitely see some partners in there

- - - Post Merge - - -

also 4 separate people in anonymous mode lmao

 

[Biancasbotique]

Since this is a MURDER mystery, there must be one killer on the loose , n'est-ce pas?

 

[cornimer]

also 4 separate people in anonymous mode lmao

Ikr smh you scummy people

- - - Post Merge - - -

@Antonio what did glow say to make you believe she's a townie?

 

[illunie]

Ikr smh you scummy people

is there an argument for town using it or no, it feels like its only useful for maf
ik ik its nitpicky but id prefer if there was a rule about people having to be able to be seen on the viewing list

 

[dedenne]

is it just me or does this feel fairly wishy washy? like i get it, noones really been talking enough to be able to get a concrete scum read from it but literally all of these reads can be boiled down to either 'theyre contributing, tr' or 'they havent said enough, null'. idk, it doesnt feel like its very townish to be so lenient like this, if amanda is scum i could definitely see some partners in there

Well it is still day 1 so I don't think there would be any solid reads atm.

Day is 48 hours right? I forgot .-.

- - - Post Merge - - -

is there an argument for town using it or no, it feels like its only useful for maf
ik ik its nitpicky but id prefer if there was a rule about people having to be able to be seen on the viewing list

Some people generally use it outside of mafia as well for whatever reason so it's not just for scum

 

[illunie]

Well it is still day 1 so I don't think there would be any solid reads atm.

Day is 48 hours right? I forgot .-.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Some people generally use it outside of mafia as well for whatever reason so it's not just for scum

true, but if theres no solid reads why write up a whole post detailing it? idk it rubs me the wrong way

 

[PandaDarling]

Glad to see activity, I’m at work, I’m gonna read what I can on my lunch break and then I’ll posts some thoughts once I’m off later this evening.

 

[Seroja]

yo i'm on invisible so that i can stalk people's profiles without being discovered u got a prob with that?

@rune you're saying amanda's reads is wishy-washy, what about mine? also do you have one u care to share with us?

 

[illunie]

yo i'm on invisible so that i can stalk people's profiles without being discovered u got a prob with that?

@rune you're saying amanda's reads is wishy-washy, what about mine? also do you have one u care to share with us?

obviously town since u read me town ty

but yeah theyre kinda wishy washy too with no real substance or call outs, maybe there really just isnt much scumminess to go off of yet

 

[amanda1983]

I never asked how many people are mafia or the ratio, I just said there could be 4 instead 3 and we may not know about it.

It really wasn't a question though. It was more like throwing an idea out there. Also:

Antonio = Town Lock for me at this point. I just cannot see this being a play by Mafia, it's too genuine and off-the-rack random a strategy for no gain (getting Antonio widely read as Town could be done much more easily than this by a player skilled enough to keep talking like this).

- - - Post Merge - - -

is there an argument for town using it or no, it feels like its only useful for maf
ik ik its nitpicky but id prefer if there was a rule about people having to be able to be seen on the viewing list

A lot of people prefer to stay in "invisible" mode on the forums for privacy reasons, mainly I think. Also, a rule that players must use "visible" mode during a game wouldn't mean much. You can see the thread without logging in, or via emails if you "subscribe" to the thread.

 

[Antonio]

But I'm a genuine guy, even out of mafia. Why would that change?

I think glow is a townie because she refered to me as towniest. It's quite specific! Town members don't know who is who, and pointing out someone who is the most towniest based on a single message (Not the 4 mafia thing but the 4 questions forn) means she/he is trying to figure out who is who while trying to so-called eliminate me in the process. People are making accusations about me but wasn't glow the first or second to do it and based it on a one-off message? Wouldn't a mafia member just ignore that message as it doesn't add much to the game? I might be wrong and this is my opinion alone..

- - - Post Merge - - -

form**

 

[dedenne]

But I'm a genuine guy, even out of mafia. Why would that change?

Because let's say a and b are mafia, a would theoretically have to town lean b and b would have to town lean a etc etc thus their posts might come off a bit forced

 

[dedenne]

But I'm a genuine guy, even out of mafia. Why would that change?

Because let's say a and b are mafia, a would theoretically have to town lean b and b would have to town lean a etc etc thus their posts might come off a bit forced

 

[dedenne]

Rip tbt

 

[cornimer]

I think glow is a townie because she refered to me as towniest. It's quite specific! Town members don't know who is who, and pointing out someone who is the most towniest based on a single message (Not the 4 mafia thing but the 4 questions forn) means she/he is trying to figure out who is who while trying to so-called eliminate me in the process. People are making accusations about me but wasn't glow the first or second to do it and based it on a one-off message? Wouldn't a mafia member just ignore that message as it doesn't add much to the game? I might be wrong and this is my opinion alone..

It's quite easy for mafia to call people town because they know who the town members are, while town members do not so have more reason to be skeptical. Also, sometimes a mafia member will townread a player specifically to get them on their good side, not saying that Glow specifically is doing that because I've seen her say things like that before as town.

 

[Antonio]

Why is my post the towniest post here? Why are you referring to it as "towniest" and not like "something a town member would say"? Towniest is quite specific.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm paranoid though so...

It's quite easy for mafia to call people town because they know who the town members are, while town members do not so have more reason to be skeptical. Also, sometimes a mafia member will townread a player specifically to get them on their good side, not saying that Glow specifically is doing that because I've seen her say things like that before as town.

Those are some good points! Maybe she is mafia, is there anything else we can add to that?

 

[cornimer]

Those are some good points! Maybe she is mafia, is there anything else we can add to that?

I'm totally not saying she's mafia I'm just saying that townlocking people quickly is not really a towntell thing.

I'm null on her atm

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I'm trying not to post as much, been busy all day too. I need to reread the reads again, but I'm getting a good feeling from amanda's reads.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Possible link: Antonio and glow. Have you read up on any games Antonio?

 

[Antonio]

This is my first game

 

[PunchyTheCat]

This is my first game

I know, have you read any previous games to make a sense of what people do as town, and what people do as scum?