The Official "Rank My Villagers!" Thread

[Xara]

Hey there ! I wanted to do this for a long time, since my villagers are quite stable now I'm curious to know how you'll rank them ☺
Don't hesitate to explain why you like or dislike some of them

Here they are in order of obtention :

- Deirdre
- Flora
- Raymond
- Kiki
- Cyd
- Tiffany
- Zucker
- Scoot
- Kabuki
- Vesta

10. cyd
9. flora
8. tiffany
7. raymond
6. vesta
5. kabuki
4. scoot
3. deirdre
2. kiki
1. zucker

 

[EmperorGandhi]

1. Raymond
2. Zucker
3. Vesta
4. Deirdre
5. Kabuki
6. Flora
7. Cyd
8. Kiki
9. Scoot
10. Tiffany

 

[Bk1234]

Here they are in order of obtention :

- Deirdre
- Flora
- Raymond
- Kiki
- Cyd
- Tiffany
- Zucker
- Scoot
- Kabuki
- Vesta

1. Raymond
2. Zucker
3. Kabuki
4. Scoot
5. Tiffany
6. Deirdre
7. Kiki
8. Flora
9. Cyd
10. Vesta

 

[basicbobagirl1130]

Here are my villagers if anyone wants to rank them~
View attachment 283233

1.) Stitches
2.) Merengue
3.) Marina
4.) Tangy
5.) Bluebear
6.) Opal
7.) Scoot
8.)Ursula
9.)Marcel
10.)Tammi
I didn’t really like Tammi when she was in my town, she was one of my starters! Stitches and Merengue are one of my dreamies, so that’s why they are at the top XD, and I have visited my friend that had Tangy before, she was really sweet!

 

[Xara]

Here are my villagers if anyone wants to rank them~
View attachment 283233

10. tammi
9. marcel
8. opal
7. bluebear
6. merengue
5. ursula
4. scoot
3. stitches
2. marina
1. tangy

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Mine have changed a fair amount since I last did this, so decided to post again:

in order of arrival:

Genji
Bangle
Flurry
Ruby
Kabuki
Freya
Fauna
Graham
Fuchsia
Cole

I didn’t mean to get so many bunnies, hamsters, and deer. I guess I’ve really lost my variety. Freya, Fauna, and Fuchsia were all unplanned additions via the campsite.

Post automatically merged: Jul 12, 2020

Here are mine atm, feel free to rate them:

- Alice
- Sally
- Zucker
- Sprinkle
- Admiral
- Genji
- Pietro
- Stella
- Marcie
- Charlise
- Raymond (Charlise is in boxes and I am about to get Raymond from someone)

(highest you lowest)

1. Genji
2. Alice
3. Stella
4. Charlise
5. Raymond
6. Zucker
7. Sally
8. Marcie
9. Pietro
10. Sprinkle
11. Admiral

Raymond, zucker, and Sally are all pretty close! Charlise gets points for being an uchi, because I like them.

 

[Xara]

Mine have changed a fair amount since I last did this, so decided to post again:

in order of arrival:

Genji
Bangle
Flurry
Ruby
Kabuki
Freya
Fauna
Graham
Fuchsia
Cole

10. genji
9. bangle
8. graham
7. ruby
6. cole
5. kabuki
4. freya
3. flurry
2. fauna
1. fuchsia

 

[WaileaNoRei]

Mine are: Bones, Marshal, Blaire, Muffy, Daisy, Hamlet, Jeremiah, Tutu, Apple, Stella.

1. Apple
2. Stella
3. Daisy
4. Muffy
5. Bones
6. Blaire
7. Marshal
8. Tutu
9. Jeremiah
10. Hamlet

Are there purposely pairs of squirrels, hamsters, dogs, and sheep?

 

[InstantNoodles]

Mine have changed a fair amount since I last did this, so decided to post again:

in order of arrival:

Genji
Bangle
Flurry
Ruby
Kabuki
Freya
Fauna
Graham
Fuchsia
Cole

I didn’t mean to get so many bunnies, hamsters, and deer. I guess I’ve really lost my variety. Freya, Fauna, and Fuchsia were all unplanned additions via the campsite.

1. Graham ofc!!
2. Genji is best bunny
3. Ruby is 2nd best bunny
4. Flurry
5. Kabuki
6. Fuchsia
7. Cole
8. Fauna
9. Freya
10. Bangle

Post automatically merged: Jul 12, 2020

Hey there ! I wanted to do this for a long time, since my villagers are quite stable now I'm curious to know how you'll rank them ☺
Don't hesitate to explain why you like or dislike some of them

Here they are in order of obtention :

- Deirdre
- Flora
- Raymond
- Kiki
- Cyd
- Tiffany
- Zucker
- Scoot
- Kabuki
- Vesta

1. Kiki
2. Vesta
3. Cyd
4. Kabuki
5. Deidre
6. Zucker
7. Raymond
8. Scoot
9. Tiffany
10. Flora

 

[WaileaNoRei]

My villagers: Gaston, Dotty, Claude, Ruby, Marina, Mac, Nan, Soleil, Lopez & Deirdre

1. Soleil
2. Ruby
3. Dierdre
4. Dotty
5. Nan
6. Lopez
7. Gaston
8. Marina
9. Mac
10. Claude

Tbis one was so tough! There was no one o wanted to put at the bottom. They are all cute and lovely! So sorry Claude, Mac, and Marina, you deserve better!

 

[Meelie]

My updated villager list:
10. Tipper
9. Katt
8. Vivian
7. Wolfgang
6. Poppy
5. Zucker
4. Bonbon
3. Olivia
2. Marshal
1. Chevre

Post automatically merged: Jul 23, 2020

10. tammi
9. marcel
8. opal
7. bluebear
6. merengue
5. ursula
4. scoot
3. stitches
2. marina
1. tangy

10. Ursula
9. Tammi
8. Opal
7. Meringue
6. Bluebear
5. Stitches
4. Marina
3. Tangy
2. Marcel
1. Scoot

 

[WaileaNoRei]

My updated villager list:
10. Tipper
9. Katt
8. Vivian
7. Wolfgang
6. Poppy
5. Zucker
4. Bonbon
3. Olivia
2. Marshal
1. Chevre

Post automatically merged: Jul 23, 2020

10. Ursula
9. Tammi
8. Opal
7. Meringue
6. Bluebear
5. Stitches
4. Marina
3. Tangy
2. Marcel
1. Scoot

1. Tipper
2. poppy
3. Olivia
4. Bonbon
5. Marshal
6. Wolfgang
7. Zucker
8. Chevre
9. Vivian
10. Katt

Very quickly ranked because I have to go to work! Might change my mind if I thought on it more (for example, recently saw tipper on an island and thought she was really cute so she is on my mind).
Thanks for posting, I love this thread

 

[Magus]

Mine have changed a fair amount since I last did this, so decided to post again:

in order of arrival:

Genji
Bangle
Flurry
Ruby
Kabuki
Freya
Fauna
Graham
Fuchsia
Cole

I didn’t mean to get so many bunnies, hamsters, and deer. I guess I’ve really lost my variety. Freya, Fauna, and Fuchsia were all unplanned additions via the campsite.

1.Kabuki
2.Freya
3.Ruby
4.Genji
5.Cole
6.Fauna
7.Fuchsia
8.Bangle
9.Graham
10.Flurry

Great villagers ! The only ones I don't really like are Graham and Flurry.
Kabuki and Freya are some of my favorites, and you have great bunnies too I love them all 3 !

1. Kiki
2. Vesta
3. Cyd
4. Kabuki
5. Deidre
6. Zucker
7. Raymond
8. Scoot
9. Tiffany
10. Flora

You're the first to rank Cyd this high and I'm very happy about it

My updated villager list:
10. Tipper
9. Katt
8. Vivian
7. Wolfgang
6. Poppy
5. Zucker
4. Bonbon
3. Olivia
2. Marshal
1. Chevre

1. Zucker
2. Katt
3. Olivia
4. Poppy
5. Wolfgang
6. Chevre
7. Vivian
8. Marshal
9. Bonbon
10. Tipper

I absolutely love the first 3
Poppy, Wolfgang, Chevre, and Vivian are cool too !

 

[Hobowire]

With my ostrich lineup;

10: sprocket
9: Queenie
8: Sandy
7: Blanche
6: Cranston
5: Phil
4: Gladys
3: Phoebe
2: Flora
1: Julia

 

[Magus]

With my ostrich lineup;

10: sprocket
9: Queenie
8: Sandy
7: Blanche
6: Cranston
5: Phil
4: Gladys
3: Phoebe
2: Flora
1: Julia

Hard to rank between the same species...
So....

1.Phoebe
2.Gladys
3.Flora
4.Cranston
5.Blanche
6.Phil
7.Sandy
8.Julia
9.Sprocket
10.Queenie

Ostrich are great in general.
The only one I don't like from your list is Queenie, also I prefer Ribbot over Sprocket in terms of robots

 

[Xara]

With my ostrich lineup;

10: sprocket
9: Queenie
8: Sandy
7: Blanche
6: Cranston
5: Phil
4: Gladys
3: Phoebe
2: Flora
1: Julia

10. sandy
9. queenie
8. cranston
7. phoebe
6. sprocket
5. flora
4. gladys
3. blanche
2. julia
1. phil

 

[craftyshack]

Rank my villagers! In order of when they arrived at my island

Tangy
Cole
Coco
Marshall
Stitches
Dobie
Ankha
Pietro
Sprocket
Raymond

 

[Hobowire]

Rank my villagers! In order of when they arrived at my island

Tangy
Cole
Coco
Marshall
Stitches
Dobie
Ankha
Pietro
Sprocket
Raymond

10 Sprocket
9 Marshall
8 Cole
7 Raymond
6 Pietro
5 Ankha
4 Tangy
3 Stitches
2 Dobie
1 Coco

 

[Xara]

Rank my villagers! In order of when they arrived at my island

Tangy
Cole
Coco
Marshall
Stitches
Dobie
Ankha
Pietro
Sprocket
Raymond

10. raymond
9. cole
8. sprocket
7. ankha
6. coco
5. dobie
4. pietro
3. marshal
2. stitches
1. tangy

 

[rubyrubert]

Rank my villagers please! Bolded are ones I’m planning on keeping (I’m debating on Ruby, but I at least want her original house)

1. Ruby*
2. Dotty
3. Marina
4. Audie
5. Whitney
6. Mathilda
7. Marshal
8. Roald
9. Stitches
10. Pashmina

I’m thinking about getting Cranston, Chief or Fang and then… maybe Colton? I have too many of the same personalitly… I wish we could have 15 villagers lol