Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER

[ribbitribbon]

s this implying that Shiny directed the king kill onto themselves or the mafia kill, because I could buy Shiny protecting someone

i was talking about the king kill, but trundle already debunked that here:

Some clarification on this:
The King action cannot be altered by other PR actions. It always goes through on the intended target. But the kill itself is treated like any other kill, where it could potentially be protected against, etc.
I apologize for the confusion.

but redirecting the mafia kill isn’t something i thought of actually, though again shiny didn’t have many reads going back so i’m not sure we could take a guess on who

 

[tessa grace]

tired of everyone saying my takes are weird but not saying why

i did say why

Post automatically merged: Apr 8, 2024

weird comment because nobody had brought that up

 

[N e s s]

Maybe I'm just seeing red because Ribbit said I should be killed by the king at the last minute yesterday. Jacob/Oath wanted me dead too but they both kind of had their reasons.

Actually Oath really has just kind of been passively saying stuff up until this point.

@tessa grace Chris was Tracker and Arstotzkan said somewhere between page 1-10 that they would love to see a Tracker in the game. That was why Chris was being so vague about their townread on Arstotzkan.

 

[voltairenism]

i did say why

Post automatically merged: Apr 8, 2024

weird comment because nobody had brought that up

sorry ill parrot everyone from now on?

Post automatically merged: Apr 8, 2024

it doesnt explain why bringing it up is weird

 

[tessa grace]

@tessa grace Chris was Tracker and Arstotzkan said somewhere between page 1-10 that they would love to see a Tracker in the game. That was why Chris was being so vague about their townread on Arstotzkan.

ohhhh ty for the clarification
I don't think i understand what that says about kats alignment though hmm

 

[N e s s]

i was talking about the king kill, but trundle already debunked that here:

but redirecting the mafia kill isn’t something i thought of actually, though again shiny didn’t have many reads going back so i’m not sure we could take a guess on who

Thats what I thought you were saying. It's weird to me that you said that, since it was kind of obvious that Chris was the king kill with what were all thinking at EOD yesterday.

Your honesty here strikes me as genuine though.

Post automatically merged: Apr 8, 2024

ohhhh ty for the clarification
I don't think i understand what that says about kats alignment though hmm

it says... nothing lol.

 

[tessa grace]

sorry ill parrot everyone from now on?

Post automatically merged: Apr 8, 2024

it doesnt explain why bringing it up is weird

its weird because nobody was on me and you were defending me
i just dont get it

 

[Damniel]

Maybe I'm just seeing red because Ribbit said I should be killed by the king at the last minute yesterday. Jacob/Oath wanted me dead too but they both kind of had their reasons.

Actually Oath really has just kind of been passively saying stuff up until this point.

@tessa grace Chris was Tracker and Arstotzkan said somewhere between page 1-10 that they would love to see a Tracker in the game. That was why Chris was being so vague about their townread on Arstotzkan.

don't get why Chris would townread off of that

Post automatically merged: Apr 8, 2024

but Chris is a confirmed dead town so oh well

 

[N e s s]

Ig with the nature of Shiny's role we can't truly know if they were the intended kill or not but the most logical explanation was that it was a blue snipe with how it was kinda obvious

 

[ribbitribbon]

Maybe I'm just seeing red because Ribbit said I should be killed by the king at the last minute yesterday. Jacob/Oath wanted me dead too but they both kind of had their reasons.

that’s true let me explain that since i didn’t get a chance:

Shh is ok don’t panic you’ll have all day tomorrow

here and other parts of d1 in the back of my mind i thought you kept buddying people, so i threw out your name instead of chris since lowkey all of the people fosing them made me tr him.

feels weird telling it to your face thought because you could just be a genuinely nice person and i’d have no idea

 

[N e s s]

don't get why Chris would townread off of that

Post automatically merged: Apr 8, 2024

but Chris is a confirmed dead town so oh well

Maybe its just a coincidence tbh. Doesn't really matter but I'd assume that to be the logical explanation for it. Maybe we can take what people were saying about Chris TRing Arstotzkan for some info?

 

[tessa grace]

Thats what I thought you were saying. It's weird to me that you said that, since it was kind of obvious that Chris was the king kill with what were all thinking at EOD yesterday.

Your honesty here strikes me as genuine though.

Post automatically merged: Apr 8, 2024

it says... nothing lol.

yeah i have to stop banking off of confirmed town takes its not good lol

 

[N e s s]

that’s true let me explain that since i didn’t get a chance:


here and other parts of d1 in the back of my mind i thought you kept buddying people, so i threw out your name instead of chris since lowkey all of the people fosing them made me tr him.

feels weird telling it to your face thought because you could just be a genuinely nice person and i’d have no idea

Honestly yeah I had no fear that Tessa was going to kill me. The chance was there with her uncertainty but I trusted her and Dan to do some good.

 

[voltairenism]

its weird because nobody was on me and you were defending me
i just dont get it

i meant that i had a very clear strat. we dont talk about reads, we dont make chaos, we decide on who's the best candidate for king, towniness and all like some asked for, and we vote them, and in the next day, we question the king to death
but we cant question you, because everyone mooted chris, and you were just following everyones suggestions
im not defending you, i'm just saying it makes little to no sense to question your decision, what is the opposite of i wanted for d2

 

[N e s s]

Also I wanna be king today, emphasizing that again. I didn't wanna be the king yesterday because other people wanted my ideal kill dead (Chris) and I wasn't fussed about being the one NK'd, was a bit of a gamble. Figured I'd only die if Chris flipped red, which even then I was betting they'd want a better target.

 

[Damniel]

i meant that i had a very clear strat. we dont talk about reads, we dont make chaos, we decide on who's the best candidate for king, towniness and all like some asked for, and we vote them, and in the next day, we question the king to death
but we cant question you, because everyone mooted chris, and you were just following everyones suggestions
im not defending you, i'm just saying it makes little to no sense to question your decision, what is the opposite of i wanted for d2

who is this biggest mafia read from EOD for you

 

[oath2order]

Also I wanna be king today, emphasizing that again. I didn't wanna be the king yesterday because other people wanted my ideal kill dead (Chris) and I wasn't fussed about being the one NK'd, was a bit of a gamble. Figured I'd only die if Chris flipped red, which even then I was betting they'd want a better target.

why and who do you want to kill

 

[ribbitribbon]

Also I wanna be king today, emphasizing that again.

i agree that we should start getting candidates together but also keep in mind it’s 9v3; a third of the town, so most popular king might not be the way to go today

are we assuming all of the mafia are active? definitely at least two from the kill, but one could be in the vegetables.

 

[N e s s]

why and who do you want to kill

you you've been in the background saying nothing this whole time, and that you wanted myself and Chris dead without an explanation

Post automatically merged: Apr 8, 2024

am I still mafia between myself and Chris, oathy?

 

[voltairenism]

i don't really know why they're sheeping me (i guess because i townleaned them) but that's not why i was townleaning them

i just thought their theory about bussing seemed real and like an odd thought for them to fake

i generally think mafia don't take an angle like that, when it feels like it makes two enemies. it's easier to just play along and townread some random person

i could be wrong ig but i think they're not a good kill based on today

who is this biggest mafia read from EOD for you

annika
mostly under radar, but would quickly answer whenever pinged so they were active at the time. voted for tessa what wouldnt turn any eyes
also their strongest read on anything was a townlead on ribbit which is justified by that post that is up there bc i cant cut and paste under. i dont think it has much depth and just felt like a plot point cherry picked. more than a couple of people talked abt bussing bc it feels very natural in this setup