Mafia The Quest for King - Mafia | Game Thread | GAME OVER

[ribbitribbon]

If Tessa is wolf, then Dan is cleared.

i agree with this and vice versa

though i like game solving with dan and still find him as one of my stronger townreads

Actually no I think I want Volt now. Seeing a future where Volt is the nightkill currently.

actually i have a different though on who mafia would target based on past actions, but i don’t wanna give them any ideas

volt also hasn’t pushed hard on today’s stronger foses but maybe im jinxing it

 

[annika]

killing ness or tess if im voted for king btw, don't mind killing either - whichever works better for everyone. I think both are wolves about equally

wait what abt geoni??

Post automatically merged: Apr 13, 2024

why does no one wanna kill geoni
like...

 

[voltairenism]

i think tessa is a slot worth flipping. still thinking abt the quote ribbit pointed out abt tessa noticing shiny's soft. in d2 everyone seemed to be dumbfounded by shinys death

im only down for jacob to take one for the team and kill ness, but it could be 3 town in one go so meh. we both agree on tessa but i would prefer to do it myself

 

[Damniel]

wait what abt geoni??

Post automatically merged: Apr 13, 2024

why does no one wanna kill geoni
like...

Geoni is okay but he’s more of a policy kill

 

[voltairenism]

wait what abt geoni??

Post automatically merged: Apr 13, 2024

why does no one wanna kill geoni
like...

im genuinely so interested in whats your deal with geoni lol

 

[ribbitribbon]

wait what abt geoni??

Post automatically merged: Apr 13, 2024

why does no one wanna kill geoni
like...

anni look at it from this perspective: what would killing geoni tell us?

the push right now is for information, and if there’s another potential mafia who’s interacted and has more information to give at their death, we should go for them

 

[annika]

anni look at it from this perspective: what would killing geoni tell us?

the push right now is for information, and if there’s another potential mafia who’s interacted and has more information to give at their death, we should go for them

i mean i don't know what it'd tell us, i just want to kill a wolf

my method of play is to, like, measure everyone by how townie they are and kill the least townie one

i don't think geoni has been very townie at all. ofc he's not contributed much, but what contribution he does have doesn't really inspire hope to me

i still think tessa/ness are somewhat townie even though i'm reconsidering my reads on them...

maybe it would be better if they were mafia and we would be able to glean more, but i personally think geoni has the highest chance of being red
(well actually i think dan does, but i don't wanna kill dan if no one else wants me to lol)

 

[oath2order]

i think tessa is a slot worth flipping. still thinking abt the quote ribbit pointed out abt tessa noticing shiny's soft. in d2 everyone seemed to be dumbfounded by shinys death

im only down for jacob to take one for the team and kill ness, but it could be 3 town in one go so meh. we both agree on tessa but i would prefer to do it myself

IMO Jacob killing Ness is not something we should do; that puts us in endgame tomorrow, same thing with me doing that same thing.

I'm inclined to agree with you on Tessa.

 

[ribbitribbon]

i mean i don't know what it'd tell us, i just want to kill a wolf

my method of play is to, like, measure everyone by how townie they are and kill the least townie one

i don't think geoni has been very townie at all. ofc he's not contributed much, but what contribution he does have doesn't really inspire hope to me

i still think tessa/ness are somewhat townie even though i'm reconsidering my reads on them...

maybe it would be better if they were mafia and we would be able to glean more, but i personally think geoni has the highest chance of being red
(well actually i think dan does, but i don't wanna kill dan if no one else wants me to lol)

that makes sense i can see your thought process

in that case who did you want to king?

Post automatically merged: Apr 13, 2024

general consensus of the town is leaning into them

 

[annika]

IMO Jacob killing Ness is not something we should do; that puts us in endgame tomorrow, same thing with me doing that same thing.

uh how do you know?

 

[oath2order]

uh how do you know?

Because it's been discussed elsewhere.

It's a town thought but if both are town probably puts the game into mylo

There are currently 10 people still alive.

Assume for this sake that Ness is in fact Hero and kills the King that kills him. Assume for this sake that Jacob is town.

Mafia will not kill Ness, obviously, because he is the King-Kill target. They will find another target. That is three town members dead. Seven people alive.

It is assumed that there are three mafia members for this game (5 town to 1 mafia member ratio seems like a fair ratio).

So of those seven people, with three mafia, four town, we would have to King-Kill mafia tomorrow, because if we kill town, we lose.

 

[Jacob4]

Because it's been discussed elsewhere.

There are currently 10 people still alive.

Assume for this sake that Ness is in fact Hero and kills the King that kills him. Assume for this sake that Jacob is town.

Mafia will not kill Ness, obviously, because he is the King-Kill target. They will find another target. That is three town members dead. Seven people alive.

It is assumed that there are three mafia members for this game (5 town to 1 mafia member ratio seems like a fair ratio).

So of those seven people, with three mafia, four town, we would have to King-Kill mafia tomorrow, because if we kill town, we lose.

why are you assuming i'm town in this hypothetical? and also why are you assuming ness town?

 

[Damniel]

If there’s 3 mafia, tomorrow is mylo. If there’s 4 mafia, it’s currently mylo

 

[ribbitribbon]

how useful do you think chris’ tracker report would be right now

Post automatically merged: Apr 13, 2024

or one of trent’s reports actually

 

[voltairenism]

i ISO'd geoni and he's almost like a pure null at the moment for giving opinions on only outdated information. i cant see where annika is comming from for not wanting to kill someone who has town points but geoni is just very much a gamble

Post automatically merged: Apr 13, 2024

why are you assuming i'm town in this hypothetical? and also why are you assuming ness town?

because its the worst case. moving on

 

[Jacob4]

i ISO'd geoni and he's almost like a pure null at the moment for giving opinions on only outdated information. i cant see where annika is comming from for not wanting to kill someone who has town points but geoni is just very much a gamble

Post automatically merged: Apr 13, 2024

because its the worst case. moving on

the assertion was that it will be endgame tomorrow, which isn't something assuming the worst case scenario is applicable to

currently 7v3, assuming i were to kill ness and one of us is mafia that'd likely be 6v2, that wouldn't be endgame

though ig i probably wouldnt kill ness if i were mafia but still if ness is mafia then would be 6v2

Post automatically merged: Apr 13, 2024

ya i dont feel as confident on geoni being a wolf as ness/tess but still think it's likely from how little meaningful interactions they've had with people, meaning he's in more possible wolf team pairings - still not my priority for kill tonight tbh cuz i think we need to kill the wolves controlling the game rn to stand a chance

 

[annika]

Because it's been discussed elsewhere.

I mean how do you know both Jacob and Ness are town

 

[Jacob4]

how useful do you think chris’ tracker report would be right now

Post automatically merged: Apr 13, 2024

or one of trent’s reports actually

probably very useful especially trent's lol, but doesnt seem like either of them softed their peeks from what i can see?

 

[annika]

dan + geoni + oath gg (/j)

 

[oath2order]

why are you assuming i'm town in this hypothetical? and also why are you assuming ness town?

Okay, you're mafia then. I'll vote for whoever promises to king-kill you. Happy?

I mean how do you know both Jacob and Ness are town

I do not know that, all I did is assume that, and at least Ness has a roleclaim that seems legitimate.