Underrated villagers?

Dude you gotta mention Tex. He's a big fat smug penguin who likes to flirt with you and looks stoned all the time. How that is not the most popular villager, I'll never know.

View attachment 74014

you gave me the best idea
a town full of high looking villagers
maybe called kush vill
mayor's name would be Mary Jane

must do
 
I love some of the villagers that are of a certain species but look like another one. I can't believe how underrated some of them are, like Keaton, Savannah, and Hans.

Hamphrey is really underrated too. He's a cranky hamster, that's probably the cutest thing ever.
 
you gave me the best idea
a town full of high looking villagers
maybe called kush vill
mayor's name would be Mary Jane

must do

Or Molly. Because Meth.

Then again that sounds like a great idea. Someone please make it happen.
 
Dora is really underrated. Even when people think most mice in this game look weird, Dora should be the exception because her design is very different from the other mice. She also does that cute thing where short villagers will be hidden in flowers with only their heads sticking out. I really love her house too.

Pashmina is another villager that is really underrated, I can't believe she's a tier 5 considering how many people complain that Uchi villagers look weird. She's probably the least weird-looking of them all and has really nice furniture in her house.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Kiki, Bertas, Bettina, and bree are all so good

Kiki isn't underrated now, I think she's in tier two or three so there's clearly a lot of people looking for her. :)
 
Last edited:
I think most of the unpopular but cute animals are only less known because of what their default t-shirt is. I mean, look at what I did with Poncho when he moved into my town. If this was his default t-shirt then he'd be a LOT more popular.

tumblr_n1nokfJjJR1synidro1_400.jpg


fyi I took this photo with the caption "
Poncho would make such a good secretary! Especially with that adorable formal suit he?s wearing. "
 
Portia, she's my favorite, and while not disliked, I never see anyone talk about her.
Rasher, he's cool, I let him move though.
Opal and Eloise are both qt's
Nan and Mathilda are both really cool, but Nan was of the starting villagers in my first town ever in wild world (idek how I remember)
Snake looks wild, I love it.
 
i really love ribbot, hes a robot frog!! how cool! and its super cute when its raining because he doesnt wear an umbrella because hes a frog but it just doesnt make sense haha! and when he talks his mouth just moves up and down and omg hes just too cute

blanche is another one of my favorites!! i have a hard time believing shes tier 5 (as far as im aware?) because shes so adorable! i seriously expected her to be a more popular character, i mean a white snooty ostrich whats not to like? im definitely going to have her in my second town if i ever decide to make one
 
scoot. he's cute as heck with his little cheeks and helmet. a good choice of a jock. there's also curt. i never had him in my town, but when my friend played animal crossing she had him and we both loved him a lot.
 
[Scoot.] he's cute as heck with his little cheeks and helmet. a good choice of a jock. there's also curt. i never had him in my town, but when my friend played animal crossing she had him and we both loved him a lot.

Scoot is terrific. The duck is one of my first five starting villagers in my original town, Applewin. (You can visit him in my Dream Address.)

One Jock villager I really like, and I've added him to my developing new town, is Kevin. I like the looks of him a lot. That orange pigmentation to, well, this pig character makes him interesting to me before all else.


It's a similar reaction I had to Bam, the blue-colored deer, who can be illuminating. (Long as he isn't dressed too badly. Then again ? that is generally true with most villagers.)


There are a number of underappreciated, not just "underrated" villagers, and you can tell a lot of them from The Bell Tree Forums member's Hound00med's list. Take a look at those listed in the middle of the pack and down.
 
Keaton.png
Whenever anybody makes a "most popular villager" list, Keaton always manages to find himself in the very last tier, the bottom of the bottom. From what I can tell, he's not hated...but nobody ever seems to mention him, either. I never understood that. He's my absolute favorite villager in the entire game, that cuddly neon eagle, and I even make it a point to talk to him more than any other character in the game because having him move would just destroy the game for me. Not to mention that he's an absolute bro and has given me not one, not two, not three, but four legitimate paintings over the last week, two of them for free. And pays ridiculous amounts of money for the small fish in my pockets. And constantly gives me free stuff.

Yup, definitely my favorite.
 
Last edited:
View attachment 74950
Whenever anybody makes a "most popular villager" list, Keaton always manages to find himself in the very last tier, the bottom of the bottom.

I agree with you. I've had Keaton in my town almost from the start and he's awesome. He's so different from the other eagles in design, his house is awesome, and even though I initially disliked smugs, I started to really like him. He's given me lots of great items like a violin and it's usually just because I've done something simple for him like giving him fruit. He keeps sending me cute letters with really nice paper. I just love him so much that I feel bad for wanting to adopt him out. If I could have more than 10 villagers and didn't want to meet any new ones, I'd keep him forever.
 
There's a lot of underrated villagers out there (including entire species! I'm very fond of the ostriches and anteaters myself). I'm actually more fond of the lower tiers myself and most of my village are 5-tiers. But I have a few favorites that aren't in my town and I would love to have if any of my villagers move away:

Charlise
Nate
Jitters
Sparro
Vic
Ava
Ken
Naomi
Tammy
Cherry
Marcel
Derwin
Maelle
All the eagles, horses, kangaroos, koalas, lions, anteaters, and ostriches,
Most of the frogs, monkeys, pigs, and goats,
Boone
Hans
Violet
Clay
Chadder
Bettina
Penelope
Puck
Timbra
Hazel

I'm particularly perplexed about Peggy. She looks so cute! <3 I can't see why she isn't more popular.
 
Last edited:
Goldie is super cute. I don't know why she is only tier four. Bluebear was one of my original villagers before I joined. I always thought she was super popular to have because she was so awesome.
 
Back
Top