Villager Popularity List - Updated

Just thought I would let you know that the sprite left of Rocco is actually a bird called Otis and I think it's meant to be Robin?

You can tell because it's a different colour, has wide eyes and the little dots above them!

oh dang you're right... idk what I did there tbh ahaha. will fix it now - thanks!
 
I like things being shaken up. I wonder how Marshal's continuing popularity will develop going forward now that he has lost his crown.

"I swear to you, sitting a throne is a thousand times harder than winning one."
 
Question for you all -

Have been deciding maybe to put tier 5's into tier 6 next update.
So, really this would only have 5 tiers.
After doing this for a while I definitely understand why Hound00med only had 5. There are just so many villagers that randomly will be looked out after, but not steadily enough to be in a higher tier.

Idk. I have a feeling a lot of you will not like this idea. lmao. Taking 45 villagers from the lowest tier was very very time consuming for me to do (when I first started this), so I'd hate for all that time to go to waste... but to me, both the tiers (5 & 6) still should be merged.

I won't do this if the majority of you all like the way it is now.
Thanks in advance. =]
 
I never thought I'd see the day where someone surpassed Marshal on the charts. Congratulations to Whitney, our new queen.

- - - Post Merge - - -

6fubnZc.png

t1NeSu0.png

4/11 [click]
E9CSwNd.png

● This list is used as a guide for cyclers & sellers to determine how easily some villagers can be sold for.
● Do not think that because of this list, all of your villagers must be tier 1-2?s. Pick villagers for your town that you want!
● Tier 1-5 is ordered by popularity / most sought after. Tier 6 is ordered alphabetically.
QjmIPXb.png

How much can I sell a villager for?
Ⓐ Prices vary, which is why I don't have them posted. To get a basic idea of how much each tier is worth it's best to check for threads with a [Cycling] prefix. Or if you're looking for a specific villager, try searching the forums for said villager with a [Selling] prefix to see what prices they were sold at. One thing to keep in mind is originality. Some people don't mind, while some do so an unoriginal villager most likely would be worth less tbt/igb than an original.
How do you determine which villager goes where?
Ⓐ For a villager to increase; multiple people looking for them in lurker lists and the Looking For thread, increase in buyouts in auction threads, and ones that are sold quickly.
Which villagers have been in Tier 1?
Ⓐ Tia, Maple, Stitches, Punchy, Rudy
When are updates done?
Ⓐ I try my best to do them every Sunday night, sometimes it's delayed to Monday.
I think a villager belongs somewhere else, why are they in tier #?
Ⓐ I am always open to suggestions/feedback. I will possibly implement your suggestion if you're active on the forums & have links or some kind of logical evidence to back up your opinion.

Can't see the list? click for picture version


Tier 1 - Extremely popular
  1. bERBL2E.gif
    Whitney
  2. ZlJOgsF.gif
    Marina
  3. j2k8mFM.gif
    Beau
  4. CFK3KLl.gif
    Marshal
  5. MKZdvLp.gif
    Fang
  6. 8FSfyAa.gif
    Diana
  7. pj9Aqa0.gif
    Skye
  8. uAPucI6.gif
    Lolly
  9. HG1skZX.gif
    Molly
  10. 2JKTqlV.gif
    Julian
  11. 3YDM5gd.gif
    Fauna
  12. dwqCijJ.gif
    Merengue
  13. WFLYVTI.gif
    Rosie
  14. CldoK87.gif
    Bob
  15. 5Cu0NXi.gif
    Chief

Tier 2 - Very popular
  1. 5JbdGR7.gif
    Stitches
  2. FbJxJRu.gif
    Cookie
  3. X4w6Ogy.gif
    Rudy
  4. 7tn8EjP.gif
    Punchy
  5. ylwg9cH.gif
    Maple
  6. ecxKKoI.gif
    Ankha
  7. BFtaxek.gif
    Zucker
  8. jvljPBs.gif
    Flurry
  9. 1vbxvTb.gif
    Goldie
  10. 2XWfImb.gif
    Tangy
  11. 9zfLUM7.gif
    Chrissy
  12. KGklo6x.gif
    Francine
  13. M3O2ILL.gif
    Melba
  14. iktR0Em.gif
    Octavian
  15. B9WSijk.gif
    Phoebe
  16. Uw5u990.gif
    Poppy
  17. U4wCh7G.gif
    Drago
  18. UolftI6.gif
    Ruby
  19. mVcVIFm.gif
    Felicity
  20. RuAd92g.gif
    Kyle
  21. hULqKqj.gif
    Muffy
  22. 08IYfrV.gif
    Bluebear
  23. aNPDAAu.gif
    Coco
  24. dsvBQip.gif
    Genji
  25. DN5dncM.gif
    Kabuki
  26. dQnZWHx.gif
    Kiki
  27. msBE4G5.gif
    Mitzi
  28. F2O1Y16.gif
    Wolfgang
  29. bq6seMV.gif
    Tia
  30. UflPXO0.gif
    Pietro

Tier 3 - Quite popular
  1. Ok2JwlK.gif
    Bam
  2. ZZuzlWH.gif
    Erik
  3. xwviQlh.gif
    Lobo
  4. C1mFIv1.gif
    Bruce
  5. 0zYOt8O.gif
    Cherry
  6. 7QYLp31.gif
    Poncho
  7. 3NV9AWA.gif
    Apollo
  8. 3Ip2tjc.gif
    Zell
  9. bT6qmT2.gif
    Lopez
  10. R16mV2R.gif
    Flora
  11. zuxR2nY.gif
    Bunnie
  12. jR87LPv.gif
    Shep
  13. Kdi0zAP.gif
    Merry
  14. Dqe4RHv.gif
    Freya
  15. 9SzA7sX.gif
    Kid Cat
  16. wKxtKkE.gif
    Peanut
  17. 121c4WH.gif
    Filbert
  18. 4Wm7iUk.gif
    Lily
  19. mTskUmL.gif
    Pekoe
  20. FZmRWyG.gif
    Chevre
  21. ZTqb1Fo.gif
    Cole
  22. 3kyesfy.gif
    Willow
  23. fhNYyvq.gif
    Lucky
  24. IOAVTqN.gif
    Roscoe
  25. NEjuHiC.gif
    Hamlet
  26. 7IcoI39.gif
    Sprinkle
  27. f4goRSY.gif
    O'Hare
  28. aoCG9oJ.gif
    Tammy
  29. BujDirw.gif
    Fuchsia
  30. eCidrH0.gif
    Blanche

Tier 4 - Somewhat popular
  1. dDwFnF2.gif
    Purrl
  2. smh6IkR.gif
    Static
  3. Ww5vRqI.gif
    Deirdre
  4. fNilz7V.gif
    Olivia
  5. eoGu092.gif
    Alice
  6. f3UBzfh.gif
    Carmen
  7. iG3FuMS.gif
    Tom
  8. rXlZG70.gif
    Hamphrey
  9. uNOrO6b.gif
    Mira
  10. AIUbhUu.gif
    Jacques
  11. D8XiTGQ.gif
    Ribbot
  12. 7BK0ihY.gif
    Cheri
  13. j6JxoDD.gif
    Rolf
  14. dpAoQ6F.gif
    Mint
  15. IhjCPYU.gif
    Snake
  16. hsRIzya.gif
    Dotty
  17. 8Cm4YzE.gif
    Biskit
  18. qje9EVs.gif
    Daisy
  19. 4S1ZEwC.gif
    Teddy
  20. 2u8JH5k.gif
    Eugene
  21. nNz1sia.gif
    Hazel
  22. 8RwoySM.gif
    Portia
  23. dfOAndI.gif
    Celia
  24. Uw0lfrL.gif
    Gala
  25. EfCQYk7.gif
    Chester
  26. 4UN6fF4.gif
    Vesta
  27. khHxwZF.gif
    Butch
  28. nasqh0i.gif
    Agnes
  29. 6sA60Lq.gif
    Aurora
  30. IKONbwd.gif
    Roald
  31. 4OxETHv.gif
    Apple
  32. 1Hj96OR.gif
    Bonbon
  33. AFNR1xq.gif
    Sterling
  34. R1pavpq.gif
    Walker
  35. 1VxHBMw.gif
    Bree
  36. TK38vgb.gif
    Yuka
  37. KAKbs00.gif
    Agent S
  38. 55xhDF5.gif
    Kidd
  39. BZE9Lmv.gif
    Blaire
  40. 4JN84zH.gif
    Avery
  41. HQdUecD.gif
    Marcie
  42. 0EJyM4J.gif
    Frita
  43. Cp5r3nj.gif
    Bill
  44. csZdIhV.gif
    Cally
  45. Shkbwew.gif
    Bones

Tier 5 - Barely popular
  1. QqknRZ3.gif
    Katt
  2. c6U2WmH.gif
    Scoot
  3. Y9CGFuY.gif
    Gladys
  4. FvvuXDm.gif
    Bianca
  5. 5Mf1DlZ.gif
    Pashmina
  6. lwlzHw6.gif
    Pecan
  7. xlVHrN4.gif
    Bangle
  8. biu0Br0.gif
    Colton
  9. OAyh1EE.gif
    Cranston
  10. IUnqBou.gif
    Caroline
  11. 0J5PxWT.gif
    Savannah
  12. NPv9Fgn.gif
    Papi
  13. 8HrMnST.gif
    Penelope
  14. EMrYp5E.gif
    Moe
  15. PqeHZoE.gif
    Wendy
  16. 1fOoqZw.gif
    Kitty
  17. 8Q2LRE9.gif
    Nan
  18. JbjLXhB.gif
    Ozzie
  19. Z8WPi5w.gif
    Rod
  20. dykntWx.gif
    Cube
  21. JDYHy5P.gif
    Rowan
  22. 8luiDzM.gif
    Soleil
  23. DJzK9Ah.gif
    Ed
  24. aekxnQB.gif
    Eunice
  25. 96Il4wU.gif
    Dora
  26. My7gw2j.gif
    Gaston
  27. KgI636p.gif
    Baabara
  28. 9FeWIUn.gif
    Jeremiah
  29. 2bK1jbe.gif
    Grizzly
  30. s7k38Gx.gif
    Opal
  31. 9uhR4nb.gif
    Tiffany
  32. zDmkwjC.gif
    Sydney
  33. 8ARtSw9.gif
    Margie
  34. azLwByw.gif
    Sally
  35. SM7MRQ6.gif
    Hans
  36. I5bZMcY.gif
    Nana
  37. cJED0Wp.gif
    Nate
  38. VlUaF32.gif
    Kody
  39. UgPJe9n.gif
    Winnie
  40. zuEnBpv.gif
    Keaton
  41. XqzIrmn.gif
    Lyman
  42. nLk23en.gif
    Ren?e
  43. uFmY3mD.gif
    Hopper
  44. MNh1yxV.gif
    Mott
  45. B4zC4RV.gif
    Walt

Tier 6 - Not popular
Al
Alfonso
Alli
Amelia
Anabelle
Anchovy
Angus
Anicotti
Annalisa
Annalise
Antonio
Astrid
Ava
Axel
Barold
Beardo
Becky
Bella
Benedict
Benjamin
Bertha
Bettina
Biff
Big Top
Boomer
Boone
Broccolo
Broffina
Bubbles
Buck
Bud
Camofrog
Canberra
Cesar
Chadder
Charlise
Chops
Chow
Claudia
Clay
Clyde
Coach
Cobb
Cousteau
Croque
Curlos
Curly
Curt
Cyrano
Deena
Del
Deli
Derwin
Diva
Dizzy
Doc
Drake
Drift
Egbert
Elise
Eloise
Elmer
Elvis
Flip
Flo
Frank
Freckles
Friga
Frobert
Gabi
Gayle
Gigi
Gloria
Goose
Graham
Greta
Groucho
Gruff
Gwen
Harry
Henry
Hippeux
Hugh
Iggly
Jambette
Jay
Jitters
Joey
Ken
Kevin
Kitt
Klaus
Knox
Leonardo
Limberg
Lionel
Lucha
Lucy
Mac
Maelle
Mallary
Marcel
Mathilda
Midge
Miranda
Monique
Monty
Moose
Naomi
Nibbles
Olaf
Pancetti
Pango
Pate
Patty
Paula
Peaches
Peck
Peewee
Peggy
Phil
Pierce
Pinky
Pippy
Pompom
Prince
Puck
Puddles
Pudge
Queenie
Quillson
Rasher
Rhonda
Ricky
Rizzo
Robin
Rocco
Rocket
Rodeo
Rodney
Rooney
Rory
Samson
Shari
Sheldon
Simon
Sly
Sparro
Spork
Stinky
Sylvia
Tabby
Tammi
Tank
T-Bone
Tex
Timbra
Tipper
Truffles
Tucker
Tutu
Twiggy
Velma
Vic
Victoria
Violet
Vladimir
Wart Jr
I just noticed that Tammy is shown twice in the picture version. In Tiers 3 AND 4. Which one is she in now?
 
yeah i really rushed the picture version this update. my apologies. i will update it in a few hours - promise.

she is #28 tier 3.
 
yeah i really rushed the picture version this update. my apologies. i will update it in a few hours - promise.

she is #28 tier 3.
I was wondering why she showed up twice. But thanks for replying I look forward to the update. BTW, I STILL can't believe someone managed to dethrone Marshal. Then again, I've read Whitney HAS topped the charts several times before, so I guess it seems fitting that she'd be the one to dethrone him.
 
I was wondering why she showed up twice. But thanks for replying I look forward to the update. BTW, I STILL can't believe someone managed to dethrone Marshal. Then again, I've read Whitney HAS topped the charts several times before, so I guess it seems fitting that she'd be the one to dethrone him.

Stitches did overtake Marshal, at one point, as the king of the VTP.

But it only lasted for about a week, lol
 
Wow it's been a long time since i saw it and I'm very shocked to see marshal is down by 3 wow....
Very surprised
 
I think tier 5 and 6 are nice because it defines the tier list more, however if you feel that the tier 5 villagers aren't really deserving of that spot and the whole tier is just a load of random villagers that one or two people want then merge them.

I think people would be more accepting of this if tier 6 was ordered by popularity though rather than alphabetically...
 
I do agree that tier 5 is a bit random really, one week you get a couple of people wanting a tier 6 but the next nothing again....
I'd agree with just a whole group tier 5.
 
Back
Top