Villager Popularity List - Updated

[Kalhyna]

Hi I'm not sure about tier list 5 and 6 , but it's probably a lot of work to have 6 tiers and I wonder if many people use the tier 5 and 6 ? ( because animals from these tiers are not really popular and may be randomly adopted )
In my opinion it would be ok to just have 5 tiers

 

[trickyfox]

I don't think tier 6 should be organized by popularity; that's a lot of work for villagers that nobody is really looking after; it's not really easy and it's time consuming to classify them.
Bye the same reason stated above, I agree tier 6 and 5 should be merged.
I also want to thank you Alexi, for the amazing work.

 

[Chrystina]

I think tier 5 and 6 are nice because it defines the tier list more, however if you feel that the tier 5 villagers aren't really deserving of that spot and the whole tier is just a load of random villagers that one or two people want then merge them.

I think people would be more accepting of this if tier 6 was ordered by popularity though rather than alphabetically...

.....
Do you understand how impossible that would be for me to do?
Merge tier 5+6 and order it by popularity?
Yeah.... I'm sorry but that will never happen.

I do agree that tier 5 is a bit random really, one week you get a couple of people wanting a tier 6 but the next nothing again....
I'd agree with just a whole group tier 5.

Oh yay. Im glad someone agrees, cause I did so already for the next update haha. you'll see the change next sunday night =]

- - - Post Merge - - -

Hi I'm not sure about tier list 5 and 6 , but it's probably a lot of work to have 6 tiers and I wonder if many people use the tier 5 and 6 ? ( because animals from these tiers are not really popular and may be randomly adopted )
In my opinion it would be ok to just have 5 tiers

I don't think tier 6 should be organized by popularity; that's a lot of work for villagers that nobody is really looking after; it's not really easy and it's time consuming to classify them.
Bye the same reason stated above, I agree tier 6 and 5 should be merged.
I also want to thank you Alexi, for the amazing work.

Oh I missed these two! Thank you both <3

 

[Jared:3]

Can u fix Skye in tier 1? I think she should switch with Rosie

 

[Chrystina]

Can u fix Skye in tier 1? I think she should switch with Rosie

but just b/c you think so doesn't mean thats where she goes..
like I've put in the OP and said a few times, you have to have some sort of evidence to back up your opinion.
I think tier 1 is perfectly fine the way it is now.

 

[Jared:3]

Ok but do you see any people lurking for Skye? Look in the threads again

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

I think you're doing a fine job!
You will never please everybody unfortunately, it's not an easy task taking on something like this but you're doing it great

 

[Jared:3]

No offense but your tier 1 is very. Inaccurate

 

[Chrystina]

Ok but do you see any people lurking for Skye? Look in the threads again

I sit at my laptop for about 70% of my day, everyday, and view the entire VTP. If I miss something, I'm sleeping or working - which isn't a lot of the both. and once I do come back, I read through every single page in every cycle thread, every thread I missed - until 100% of the VTP is read.
If you think you can make a better list, by all means go ahead.

I am not tryng to be rude, but I think tier 1 is perfectly fine the way it is, so for now its staying the way it is until next update.

 

[Jared:3]

You didn't answer my question.. Is Skye in really any Looking threads? I check everyday, I haven't found Skye for a long time, she shouldn't Be ahead of most of tier 1

 

[Chicha]

I personally think mixing tiers 5&6 would be too much imo. On the other hand, I can see why people would want them to merge again because people are rarely looking for tier 5. I think there are tier 5s that have potential vs many tier 6s are extremely random. I do agree tier 5 doesn't need to be sorted by popularity. Anyway, do what works for you best tbh! <3

Thanks for putting so much hard work into this list!

 

[Jared:3]

But I agree I love the list, but Skye isn't worthy of being ahead of Julian, and even Rosie

 

[Chrystina]

You didn't answer my question.. Is Skye in really any Looking threads? I check everyday, I haven't found Skye for a long time, she shouldn't Be ahead of most of tier 1

Okay? And you aren't answering my question. Do you have any evidence as to where Rosie is being sold/looked for enough that she should increase?
Don't expect me to change something thats your opinion by asking ME to find the evidence for you.

 

[Jared:3]

I see Rosie lurked on almost every thread specifically Mayor Brooke's thread

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yes I went on Accfsally's thread, and went through the entire list, found zero lurkers for Skye maybe 1 or 2 in their but I found full of other tier 1, and chocopug has zero for Skye to

 

[radioloves]

Nice! So updates are every Sunday? :3

 

[Jared:3]

Went on cookielicious thread and found 3 for Skye, the most I've seen on any thread I see Rosie and Julian way more than Skye, I hope you move her down this week, my evidence is pretty convincing

- - - Post Merge - - -

Found one person lurking for Skye on mayor brook thread

 

[toadsworthy]

Went on cookielicious thread and found 3 for Skye, the most I've seen on any thread I see Rosie and Julian way more than Skye, I hope you move her down this week, my evidence is pretty convincing

- - - Post Merge - - -

Found one person lurking for Skye on mayor brook thread

skye has been on fire lately! I saw two people lurking for them a little bit ago when I had her in my cycling thread... I wanted to do an auction for her. Everytime Skye pops up in threads, she gets adopted super quick and for high prices. So I can totally see Skye's spot.

Rosie has been in a little bit of a bad spot recently, I had her with no takers, and don't see her being very popular around right now. The lurker lists on threads is very inaccurate, because they may be horribly outdated and I can definitely see her drop being warranted

- - - Post Merge - - -

There isn't an exact science to determining the Tier list. and a lot of different factors go into play when determining it... Alexi has been doing a great job on it so far, and she has been doing a great job of taking into account other people's views when they make sense

 

[Retroself]

Is this guy for real?

(Obvious troll is obvious)

 

[LinkToTheWorld]

Is this guy for real?

(Obvious troll is obvious)

Sadly I think he's genuine....

 

[Kalhyna]

Is this guy for real?

(Obvious troll is obvious)

♥♥♥