Hello Jeremy!
I am formally putting in my green dye color and will be using my thickener on the mermaid scale
(For those who are unhappy with my selection. It appears there were some who liked the green and some who didn’t. But this is a collective potion that we the users made and supposed to be a fun experiment for us to do. It was getting to a point for me where I was wondering if I should or shouldn’t add those ingredient, but it was starting to drag on a little bit too long for me and making me feel like I was trying to make everyone happy. In the end, those who will like the green can rejoice in my addition and for those who don’t... Well... Happy Potion Brewing!)
I'm glad you went ahead and put in what you personally wanted. While it is nice to try and please everyone, there's no way that will happen. We will end up with a specially crafted collectible in the end anyways so in my opinion regardless of what colour we end up with it'll be a special treat to own one. Sure I have an ideal colour that I would like but it's much more interesting to see what the end result will be even if it's not a favourite colour of mine.