Holy moly, I forgot about this thread. I posted this question when I was brand new and knew nothing haha, It is nice to see it pop back up though! Although I have since learned, and agree with, that popularity based on polls and online rankings is silly and should definitely never influence you!
That being said, I have since fallen in love with a couple of other "unpopular" villagers.
First would be Cyrano. I am a sucker for cranky villagers and his eyebrows demand respect.
And Dora, with her mouth on the side of her face. It reminds me of the old Saturday morning cartoon "Snorks" where all of their mouths were off to one side.
And of course, the tiny man people seem to love to dislike, Rodney. I loved his dopey face, but since then I love that he is usually dancing and singing on his own with no music nearby.