Mafia Xenoblade Chronicles Mafia-Endgame

[Nightmares]

Didn't catch your post merge.

OMGUS means "Oh my god, you suck. I'm suspicious of you, because you're suspicious of me."

Which I actually defined yesterday evening, which makes me believe you've yet to catch up from what you missed. So, please do so.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Quick topic. What scum uses to chat with each other.


Meh, this is just more town slips.
Basically, what would be very helpful is for you to just give a basic read on everyone. Null/Slight town/Town/Sus/Slight scum/Scum.

Alright, thank you

 

[Cadbberry]

Hmmm. Okay.
It looks like I did entirely misread that post in response to Cory, and your reads as well. (For the record I never saw that flip-flop to Ashtot scummy. )

So Tina is basically this now.

- - - Post Merge - - -

please post merge.






tae, you seem very sold on the fact that Tom's claim is not genuine. Is this just because it's a closed setup and you really don't believe any claim, or?


I hope you can elaborate on at least some of these at some point today.

Please contribute in at least something today. Please.

I can elaborate, so my town reads rely on being helpful and scum hunting, Panda and Xine are scum hunting a lot making me feel like I can put them in town though last game Panda was scum and was very helpful so there is always a possibility that they could be scum but am not getting that read currently. Ares soft claimed, I did make a vote before and I do regret that decision since it made no sense to do such, and I am going to trust that soft claim for now. Cory has also claimed as a townie and I am inclined to believe him though he has been a bit of a lacking town, acting like Ashtot early in game, being very troll like, but after his claim I am going to believe him. Tae, it is more of a gut feeling, he is being much more inquisitive this game and has been trying to get some good reads over people.
As for my null, Jacob, I just can't tell, I have known him for a while and I cant tell if he plays like this or it is just his personality shining through. Dolby hasn't really contributed enough for me to decide if I am totally suspicious yet compared to other reads of him. Also he claimed he was busy with AP exams so I can understand how he has not posted much of anything. Mother doesn't post anything at all, I really don't like playing with them for that reason. But looking at their play style, they are just coasting and bandwagoning on anything that is happening, I probably move them to scum for this behavior, much like the last game where they were scum and didn't say anything when it came to busing their team mates or when they were just coasting along. Tardis has been unusually silent and I would have to say I would also move them in sus for this, they are a very mouthy person, posting a lot of opinions, even de-railing things but this game they are being very pop in and go, usually from the play style of last game.
Tom has claimed as a third party, I am going to trust his claim and thus put him as a yellow third party.
Tina had almost everyone read as sus and has been awkward in her posting, I want to go back and find quote but her front page link isn't there and I am about to bike to school. It just a tiny sus though, nothing too big and they could easily be town and it could just be me over thinking things. Alexi has just been everywhere, though they are very questioning and pushing this just reminds me of last game where they were mafia, so it may just be their meta and I don't know it as well as others but I can say that I just don't have a deep trusting with her play style this game. Nightmares is just coasting by and is being useless, they are posting everywhere on tbt but only getting single sentences sent out to explain, maybe they can't handle their role or maybe they just aren't helpful, its hard to say but I have to don't trust that. Also they are 'town slipping', as this is their third game I would expect them to know some of the terms, I had some issues with words in my first game but I just don't believe these ones, they just look so fake to me. Hayden has been unusually quiet, they are usually like Tardis and have been just absent, it looks awkward and I don't know if I trust a quiet Hayden like this, I honestly can't tell how much they posted since his link is broken on the OP but I know it isn't like the other game I played with them, it just has me on edge. My read on Xero really doesn't matter since they are banned, but I didn't like their wording and everything came off as a joke when I read it.
Inkling and Ashtot both have been de-railing, saying contradictory things, though Ashtot has gotten a bit better and is trying to help a little. I would say though that Inkling is the prime target we have right now, it just hasn't been making so much sense and with inkling not even trying to defend them self, claim, anything, it just looks like they cant decide what to say now that everyone turned and called them mafia, like they didn't have a back up something to say.

I gotta jet to school but I can use the computer a bit so I will try and pop in.

 

[Chris]

Tina had almost everyone read as sus ...

Four people. FOUR. Cory, Ashtot, Xerolin, and you.

 

[Cadbberry]

Four people. FOUR. Cory, Ashtot, Xerolin, and you.

Was it four, my mistake, I must have thought about someone elses reads, my mistake. A big error on my proof reading part

 

[Nightmares]

Four people. FOUR. Cory, Ashtot, Xerolin, and you.

Hmm, I do agree with a couple of these people

- - - Post Merge - - -

How come no one is suspicious of Tardis? He's been quite inactive...

 

[Cadbberry]

Hmm, I do agree with a couple of these people

- - - Post Merge - - -

How come no one is suspicious of Tardis? He's been quite inactive...

I mentioned that in my explanation of my reads. It is out of character for them

 

[Nightmares]

I mentioned that in my explanation of my reads. It is out of character for them

Ah yeah, I see....I thought more people would've picked up on it doe

 

[Kirbystarship]

Hmm, I do agree with a couple of these people

- - - Post Merge - - -

How come no one is suspicious of Tardis? He's been quite inactive...

I'm more active than you are.

 

[Chrystina]

Hmm, I do agree with a couple of these people

- - - Post Merge - - -

How come no one is suspicious of Tardis? He's been quite inactive...

He posted his reads on everyone yesterday, and contributes when needed, I don't see him inactive at all. He's following his usual town meta. For me, the only thing that stuck out was the RQS but when I questioned him about it, his reactions were good enough for me. His posts remind me of the same when he's town.

 

[Nightmares]

He posted his reads on everyone yesterday, and contributes when needed, I don't see him inactive at all. He's following his usual town meta. For me, the only thing that stuck out was the RQS but when I questioned him about it, his reactions were good enough for me. His posts remind me of the same when he's town.

I've hardly seem him post, only about 4 times, but I suppose

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm more active than you are.

And? You're still inactive to me, but most people are only saying that only I am....maybe I missed most of your helpful posts or something, not sure

 

[Cadbberry]

He posted his reads on everyone yesterday, and contributes when needed, I don't see him inactive at all. He's following his usual town meta. For me, the only thing that stuck out was the RQS but when I questioned him about it, his reactions were good enough for me. His posts remind me of the same when he's town.

If that is his town meta then I accept it, I have only played one game with him and he was a lot more active and spammy so that is just my limited knowlege. I trust your vouching of a town meta like this

 

[Chrystina]

I've hardly seem him post, only about 4 times, but I suppose

- - - Post Merge - - -



And? You're still inactive to me, but most people are only saying that only I am....maybe I missed most of your helpful posts or something, not sure

Tardis2016
Posts: 87


.. and all of these aren't unnecessary comments, and actually relate to the game.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If that is his town meta then I accept it, I have only played one game with him and he was a lot more active and spammy so that is just my limited knowlege. I trust your vouching of a town meta like this

well I have no reason to 100% FULLY believe he is town, of course, as with everyone else.
The only game he was scum though, he slipped and claimed when nobody was even asking.
I think if he was scum again he would've done something like nervous mafia again, such as role claiming. and given that trundle even asked for his role and he didn't give it, further adds to why I think he's town.

 

[Nightmares]

Ok....please don't get annoyed....but uh....w-what's role claiming? Is that where you say you're Town or something?? Someone needs to give me a Mafia dictionary of something xD

- - - Post Merge - - -

*OR Dx

 

[Chrystina]

Ok....please don't get annoyed....but uh....w-what's role claiming? Is that where you say you're Town or something?? Someone needs to give me a Mafia dictionary of something xD

- - - Post Merge - - -

*OR Dx

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Category:Glossary

 

[Nightmares]

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Category:Glossary

Oh my gosh, thank you lmao

 

[xine]

That's a big assumption. I chose not to vote for him right now because after he replied to the thing that made me most certain on him, and I weighed his response with what I know about him as a player and a person (I've been playing mafia with Cory over two years), I considered his response plausible.

... I'm actually more confident about my initial read because he said he wasn't informed about killer third parties. Why did I bring up the point in the first place? Because I'm town and my own PM tells me that there are killer third parties. So it struck me as weird that Cory seemed to think this was new information which he explicitly stated was based off of reading Crys' PM. So if Cory were town, he'd know this too. Had anyone besides Cory said they didn't actually read their PM, I wouldn't have believed them. But it's Cory. And, even so, my deduction was actually correct. A person who was town and knew their win con would not have made a comment like that. And Cory admitted he never read the win con.

Whether or not you and others are "ok" with my opinion is irrelevant to me. If I believe in something I'll push it. And if I get lynched for it other than it being hilarious for me as it'll be my first time ever being lynched as town, then at least you guys will have my opinions to refer back to later and do with them what you want.

Too bad literally nothing you just said adds up. Do you think Cory is mafia or third party?

Entropy also made a similar statement. Are you saying that if they were still alive, you would think they were scum as well? Ironically, I am not even defending Cory here but this is inconsistent. The reason being is that mafia has that same sentence in their Win Con, so EITHER WAY he would have noticed, regardless of alignment. Your only possible correct answer to my questions would be that you believe Cory IS the killing third party. Which the KP does not add up for, the only way this is possible is if he hit whoever was jailed. Which was likely Tom- and in what world would a SK ever hit Tom? And since Cory made a similar statement that Entropy did, it is not a slip in the slightest way. Skimming over your Win Con is entirely rudimentary, I won't deny you that. But I do deny your reasoning. In fact, would scum not be more likely to notice something like that in their Win Con than town?

Stop backtracking.

 

[tae]

tae, you seem very sold on the fact that Tom's claim is not genuine. Is this just because it's a closed setup and you really don't believe any claim, or?

give me some time on this one, I've got something I've been working on for the duration of this day phase.
promise it won't disappoint. think back to T

I've hardly seem him post, only about 4 times, but I suppose

- - - Post Merge - - -



And? You're still inactive to me, but most people are only saying that only I am....maybe I missed most of your helpful posts or something, not sure

go back, read the thread, stop calling out others for being inactive when you're worse.
you've been just as bad of an unhelpful distraction as inkling and ashtot. why do you jistrefuse to contribute.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'm on mobile sorry, but @xine why do we think tom would be jailed at all? why would she jail the guy who tunneled her so hard.

 

[Nightmares]

I have contributed - I said who I who I thought was definitely town, and said I agreed with Tina about some of the people she suspected...not much, but I still said something xD

- - - Post Merge - - -

*Who I; not who I who I omfg

 

[Cadbberry]

Tardis2016
Posts: 87


.. and all of these aren't unnecessary comments, and actually relate to the game.

- - - Post Merge - - -



well I have no reason to 100% FULLY believe he is town, of course, as with everyone else.
The only game he was scum though, he slipped and claimed when nobody was even asking.
I think if he was scum again he would've done something like nervous mafia again, such as role claiming. and given that trundle even asked for his role and he didn't give it, further adds to why I think he's town.

Those are some great points, I appriciate you bringing those up, it helps me re read him a bit.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I have contributed - I said who I who I thought was definitely town, and said I agreed with Tina about some of the people she suspected...not much, but I still said something xD

- - - Post Merge - - -

*Who I; not who I who I omfg

Well, I would appreciate some reasons from your point of view on the scum, why do you think anyone is scum? Is it because of the exact reasons Tina said so you dont feel like you need to explain or do you have your own opinions on them?

 

[Chrystina]

give me some time on this one, I've got something I've been working on for the duration of this day phase.
promise it won't disappoint. think back to T

noted, thank you. backing off now.

Too bad literally nothing you just said adds up. Do you think Cory is mafia or third party?

Entropy also made a similar statement. Are you saying that if they were still alive, you would think they were scum as well? Ironically, I am not even defending Cory here but this is inconsistent. The reason being is that mafia has that same sentence in their Win Con, so EITHER WAY he would have noticed, regardless of alignment. Your only possible correct answer to my questions would be that you believe Cory IS the killing third party. Which the KP does not add up for, the only way this is possible is if he hit whoever was jailed. Which was likely Tom- and in what world would a SK ever hit Tom? And since Cory made a similar statement that Entropy did, it is not a slip in the slightest way. Skimming over your Win Con is entirely rudimentary, I won't deny you that. But I do deny your reasoning. In fact, would scum not be more likely to notice something like that in their Win Con than town?

Stop backtracking.

I actually do agree that entropy could've possibly jailed Tom... what I don't understand is why a SK wouldn't try and go after Tom?