Mafia American Politics Mafia - Game Over - Town Wins!

[amazonevan19]

at least there is no shadow lingering whether both of them are mafia..we do a couple of mislynches in the history of mafia so what is one mislynch to see the truth?

because intending to mislynch is way worse than unintentionally mislynching someone who's actually scummy

ik punchy has been acting chaotic neutral this game but Dolby has done nothing to deserve lynching.

Seriously bianca you're making it really difficult to trust you, and I see nothing but scummy motivations behind putting forth such a lynch.

Then again, scum!Bianca would not be as bold and dumb as this...I pray not anyway...

 

[Biancasbotique]

In the history of mafia, has there ever been a day 1 lynch that really got Mafia?

- - - Post Merge - - -

because intending to mislynch is way worse than unintentionally mislynching someone who's actually scummy

ik punchy has been acting chaotic neutral this game but Dolby has done nothing to deserve lynching.

Seriously bianca you're making it really difficult to trust you, and I see nothing but scummy motivations behind putting forth such a lynch.

Then again, scum!Bianca would not be as bold and dumb as this...I pray not anyway...

Well I wanna lynch Punchy more than Dolby

 

[Hikari]

well those are my inactives..but for the scummy ones..why dont we lynch either Dolby or Punchy. As Dolby said, they are not lovers, only Masons, so one dying because the other dies is a poo poo...So if we lynch Dolby, then turned out Mason, it clears Punchy and likewise.

Why would we want to lynch someone that is pretty much confirmed to be town? (It would be better for a cop to check their role versus eliminating a most-likely town member to confirm if the other was town or not.) We should be focusing on potential mafia members.

 

[amazonevan19]

and why is it bad if they are mafia?

- - - Post Merge - - -

either we kill two birds with one stone...or we just let them be...

we know Mafia is not gonna kill them now

- - - Post Merge - - -

I meant we kill two birds with one stone...or even if we mislynch, we have a confirmed town

I can understand this position, but you're essentially asking us to waste a lynch on nigh confirmeds. I'd be down for lynching punchy if he doesn't stop posting useless fluff lol. Ok in all seriousness though, I think scumhunting is better than lynching confirmeds. <-- never thought I'd have to write that or explain that to someone in mafia

 

[Biancasbotique]

Why would we want to lynch someone that is pretty much confirmed to be town? (It would be better for a cop to check their role versus eliminating a most-likely town member to confirm if the other was town or not.) We should be focusing on potential mafia members.

again with the confirmed towns...they are not confirmed yet!

and if they are truly masons, there should be no cops right?

 

[cornimer]

We are absolutely not lynching Dolby or Punchy
Obviously, I want to lynch runeraider

 

[Biancasbotique]

Exactly, there's my point no one wants to lynch Punchy or Dolby.

If they are mafia, they achieved being townleaned. good job town!

 

[cornimer]

Despite these anti-town ideas I'm like 99% confident Bianca is town though

 

[Hikari]

again with the confirmed towns...they are not confirmed yet!

and if they are truly masons, there should be no cops right?

Sorry, it's been a long time since I've last played, but how are the masons and the cop related at all?

 

[Biancasbotique]

Sorry, it's been a long time since I've last played, but how are the masons and the cop related at all?

the last time I had a Mason and a cop...well, lets just say it didnt jibe well with town.

- - - Post Merge - - -

i meant when I hosted a game lol

 

[Byngo]

the only person that i can say i sus enough to consider lynching is ityw, everyone besides my tl’s r null

at some point ill put out a half-assed read list

 

[Hikari]

the last time I had a Mason and a cop...well, lets just say it didnt jibe well with town.

- - - Post Merge - - -

i meant when I hosted a game lol

Oh, are you saying it might be unbalanced for there to be a cop in a game with masons? I never considered that possibility (I thought cops were a part of every mafia game) but I suppose that could be true.

 

[amazonevan19]

Sorry, it's been a long time since I've last played, but how are the masons and the cop related at all?

if masons are in a game, it's very unlikely a cop is in that game. Mason converts are used to confirm who is or isn't town, which eliminates the need for a cop

 

[Biancasbotique]

Oh, are you saying it might be unbalanced for there to be a cop in a game with masons? I never considered that possibility (I thought cops were a part of every mafia game) but I suppose that could be true.

well im pretty sure even if there is a cop, Trundle might have other balancing mechanisms so I am 50/50 on that.

 

[Dolby]

if masons are in a game, it's very unlikely a cop is in that game. Mason converts are used to confirm who is or isn't town, which eliminates the need for a cop

We aren’t that type of mason. I’ve read about it on mafiascum, but those aren’t typically used here. We’re merely linked

 

[Biancasbotique]

if masons are in a game, it's very unlikely a cop is in that game. Mason converts are used to confirm who is or isn't town, which eliminates the need for a cop

Yeah after night 1, we can pretty much see if there are cops and masons. So yeah ur right, lynching Dolby or Punchy this day cycle is not as good because we can confirm if there is a cop after night 1. (hopefully we can know by day 2)

 

[amazonevan19]

We aren’t that type of mason. I’ve read about it on mafiascum, but those aren’t typically used here. We’re merely linked

oh

so a cop could still be in this game then?

though I'd still see balance issues having two confirmeds at the get-go and an investigative role, without the investigative role being nerfed somehow (crazy, naive, etc.)

 

[Byngo]

again with the confirmed towns...they are not confirmed yet!

and if they are truly masons, there should be no cops right?

bianca did you pay attention to d0. besides them even claiming masons, punchy is being his usual erratic self, and tbh if Dolby were to make a Mason gambit play as scum, i really, really don’t think he’d want to do that with punchy. because there’s high probability scum punchy would slip up

idk why we’re still talking about this, but honestly Bianca’s latest thoughts are so out of left-field that I am more comfortable with tl’ing her because scum would be far more safe

 

[PunchyTheCat]

OML BIANCA DO NOT LYNCH US.

 

[amazonevan19]

Yeah after night 1, we can pretty much see if there are cops and masons. So yeah ur right, lynching Dolby or Punchy this day cycle is not as good because we can confirm if there is a cop after night 1. (hopefully we can know by day 2)

well yeah, but even now knowing that the masons don't convert, it's best to just let cop (who we don't know exists) do their job and go after actual scummy peeps