Mafia American Politics Mafia - Game Over - Town Wins!

[PunchyTheCat]

Mk soooooo 1. The Oracle is basically a cop, not a messenger. 2. Bianca could have been too lazy to bolden and make it red, but it is in the pm, or Trundle could have just forgotten about boldening it. Let's stop asking about it.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Heyden kind of seems desperate to keep the lynch off of Locket. We should definitely take a risk and vote Locket so we can learn if we can trust the Oracle.

 

[cornimer]

ok in this game..i've been called..


useless

trash

stupid

drunk

and on drugs

geez louise...can you give a girl a break?

Don't listen to the haters Bianca you're doing fine

i feel like todays lynch is more for gathering more information about peoples allignments and buying cop (if there is one which there probably is) possible groupings than actual scumhunt. if were able to determine the validity of biancas message then i think we can go from there. im still not sure whetehr we should go for that or for choosing between the two millers, theres good arguments for either side. its looks like my vote isnt gonna matter tho so we

i think today is choosing between two different risks, whether to choose between the two millers or kill locket and check the validity of the oracle report. right now im leaning towards the millers because of nesses claim but i honestly think it doesnt matter too much which one happens first unless something comes up because were probably just gonna take care of the other one tomorrow

BOY do I not like these two posts. It reminds me of what I was doing in RHOM, trying to look unsure about the lynch so people would think I was considering both sides and not just driving the lynch on an innocent to save myself.

Anyways, as other have stated, Ness having messaging abilities doesn't really affect the alignment of Bianca's messenger because I think ANYONE who became the president, including a scum, would've gotten that ability. However, I'm starting to believe Heyden that if it was an oracle "inspection", the word "mafia" would've been red on Bianca's message. I would still not be opposed to lynching Locket today just to be sure, but as Evan said I guess we could wait, see what tomorrow's "inspection" says, and then decide if it seems legit.

Also, I really doubt we have a cop if an oracle does indeed exist.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And I'm either voting Locket or Rune but rn I'm leaning towards Rune

 

[unravel]

So we are still going for locket because of the message?

 

[EpicGamer12]

this is true

stop lynching locket

- - - Post Merge - - -



also true, but ness reads pretty town? weird u casted doubt here

- - - Post Merge - - -



it was my understanding that ness' inherited this ability because of him specifically becoming pres.

can trundle confirm this being a mechanic specific to ness? or is it specific to pres?

I can not confirm nor deny the events of this thread.

 

[Locket]

I am Jeb Bush. I'm a vanilla townie.

I doubt I'm unaware miller.

 

[cornimer]

I am Jeb Bush. I'm a vanilla townie.

I doubt I'm unaware miller.

He's a republican if we're going with the "republicans are town" thing
Tbh I feel like she might've claimed something more important if she was scum trying to save herself?

- - - Post Merge - - -

He's a republican if we're going with the "republicans are town" thing
Tbh I feel like she might've claimed something more important if she was scum trying to save herself?

Tho Dolby was Biden and Punchy is Obama (I think) so thats probably not reliable

- - - Post Merge - - -

And Tina's character was a democrat too ok scratch that idea party means nothing

 

[Jacob]

it was my understanding that ness' inherited this ability because of him specifically becoming pres.

can trundle confirm this being a mechanic specific to ness? or is it specific to pres?

Since trundle can't reveal the answer I wanna believe that anyone who became president would've had the ability to send a message, not just Ness. Considering Natty said it was cut off at 280 characters like a twitter message, and trump seems to be twitter happy in the messages he sends. It's like satirical

 

[Locket]

Since party doesn't mean anything, maybe the scum is set up with people like Putin or Kim Jong Un.

 

[toadsworthy]

I made half of the most important people from BOTW mafia safe claims.... trying to reason anything is bad logic and gets you into trouble more than anything. Lockets set up for her claim just reads so bad, I still think lynching her is best idea

 

[glow]

dad stop splitting the vote

a vote for rune is a vote for locket

- - - Post Merge - - -

lockets towniest point of the game would be when they said "if i was scum i'd have a team to help catch me up" or something along the lines of that

imo their claim also bleeds genuine i don't know why toads was picking at it

- - - Post Merge - - -

it worries me that ness is going to likely be the one to decide this as the wagons are pretty close

because he's most likely lynching locket

 

[Byngo]

ok i can concede that there’s probably not an oracle, not even including glow and Hayden’s reasoning, id assume by now the oracle would’ve just come forward to confirm locket

if toad is actuslly scum then there’s def bussing going on since nearly everyone has sus’d him

any motivation i had is gone lol

 

[Locket]

I made half of the most important people from BOTW mafia safe claims.... trying to reason anything is bad logic and gets you into trouble more than anything. Lockets set up for her claim just reads so bad, I still think lynching her is best idea

How does is read bad to you?

 

[amazonevan19]

glow, why toads over rune?

 

[toadsworthy]

How does is read bad to you?

Saying I would rather not claim, you aren't gonna believe me.... but then like later out of nowhere you claim anyway. It just looks fake, like you had a safe claim and had to decide which one was best to use. If we lynch me when we were straight told that locket is scum, that's stupid. What if the other messenger is a day cop too?

- - - Post Merge - - -

An oracle would and should not come out rn... they can send investigations that get told each day with no risk to revealing themselves

 

[amazonevan19]

If ness is gonna vote locket anyway dad and I have no reason to change from rune, but if Ness goes with Rune then some toad people will have to change over I think?

Either way I am pretty set on rune. Can't know for sure if the Locket message is true (and it's very likely it could be fabricated), and the miller situation is just a whole big clusterscrew

 

[toadsworthy]

I'm about to start celebrating my sisters bday... and we're going to a brewery. I won't be too active from here on out. I'm a Miller, two millers isn't that outlandish of an idea if you think of a balance standpoint. Really think about why you are voting me before finalizing votes. I may pop on at some point, but I may be drunk soooooo...

 

[N e s s]

More content coming in the next hour or so about Toad, but I more or less think that he is the best lynch at this moment. To generalize why, I was kinda leaning towards him playing like a Jester earlier but at this point I want to say that it feels like it's sorta faked, that and I feel like he's taking the Locket message as his golden opportunity to get out of the lynch. He's focused less on contributing this game and more on saying things that help HIM in the long run; and at this exact moment he's not pushing the game forward by considering anyone other than Locket when its a little evident that there is something fishy with the message.

Big post coming about Toads soon enough.

- - - Post Merge - - -

And even if Toads is telling the truth right now, I'm pretty certain there is a lot of information to be gained from whether he flips either alignment.

 

[toadsworthy]

Well then RIP.... none of my scum reads are stronger than the possibility of locket being scum. Waffles, runeraider, and Jacob are all my reads. Idk what else you could want me to do, I'm just turning off my phone and focusing on family then.

 

[glow]

ok i can concede that there’s probably not an oracle, not even including glow and Hayden’s reasoning, id assume by now the oracle would’ve just come forward to confirm locket

if toad is actuslly scum then there’s def bussing going on since nearly everyone has sus’d him

any motivation i had is gone lol

i think if there's a world where toads is town, rune could be mafia

like i just have had so many trs that i know multiple are wrong

i think in order of confidence

punchy
vanessa
you
ness
locket

[confidence drops significantly]

rune
dad
evan
hayden
bianca

scumpool:

toad
jacob
waffles
hikari

 

[N e s s]

Alright so I've just read through every post in the game and this is what I've noticed from skimming: 14 players in total have accused/suspected Toadsworthy from D0 to now. The list of these people are as follows:

Tina - Dead
Dolby - Dead
glow
Heyden/Chele
N e s s - Myself
AmazonEvan19
Dad
Runeraider
ITookYourWaffles - Virtually no reasoning stated
PunchyDaHufflepuff - Only confirmed town on this list
Biancasbotique
Byngo - I Think?
Jacob
Locket

Whether or not I missed someone is mostly based on how accessible their post was... but this kinda makes me want to rethink things a bit. Anyway I'm leaving to the airport in about 5 minutes so I may or may not be home in time to give a good clear read, but I'll probably be voting near the last couple hours.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh, and theres also Vanessa I guess but I'm pretty sure she's townleaning toads still

- - - Post Merge - - -

Actually yeah, the only person in the game who hasn't stated anything about Toad is Hikari, and the only player who has been on Toads side consistently is Vanessa. Yeah this really does make me want to reconsider things a bit, but if Toads is mafia I can see Amazonevan/ITookYourWaffles/Dad possibly being team mates.