Mafia Among Us Mafia Game Thread (Town Win!)

[N e s s]

me being a sussy baka doesn’t answer if our alliance is up or not

also please reread yourself if you can -__- lots of bias

let me think on it for a minute, you have bestie potential but what if you're sus

 

[Dolby]

NESS
NESSSSSSSSS
HE'S BEING A SUSSY BAKA
NESS
HE'S BEING SUS

 

[voltairenism]

Here we go.


Okay I think I'm starting to see where the misinterpretation happened. I was not saying if Yoshi maf there would be a campaign to vote him out today from a maf partner. Just that it would be equally easy for a maf teammate, amidst all the Yoshi obviously town, to say nah I could see Yoshi being red but focus on the current POE. That's it. Just a simple 'I'm reading them red now so I look better in the future when this slot flips red'.

It is very much feeling like a town slap fight yes, and I now I can flat out admit I wasn't understanding your POV if you thought that I was suggesting that Yoshi would be an active vote target today. sejkfbksjbf. I did not mean to antagonize you I was just ???? because it felt like you were arguing with me over placing a simple idea out there and again. I was grouchy, I was tired, I'm admiting it was me who just completely misinterpretted you,


Welcome Ness.

thank you, and im sorry for snapping

 

[Dolby]

If I’m being honest, I don’t know either. While I don’t want to vote no elim, I have no idea who to vote for.

ok so a good way to do stuff would be possibly process of elimination. You remove the most town people to you, then of the remainder the next most. Since it's D1 you can probably remove the inactives. Then you have the most sus grouping left, and you find out who that grouping is to you.

 

[N e s s]

NESS
NESSSSSSSSS
HE'S BEING A SUSSY BAKA
NESS
HE'S BEING SUS

You're the smartest sigma I've ever met. But you're too sussy to see, he voted you 10 minutes ago

 

[FrostyAlmonds]

I haven't been replying to your reads as I felt like I've already explained enough about my support of you, and quite frankly, there's other users I need to focus my attention on, such as Zinnia and maybe Trundle (who likes to start random vote wagons from what I could tell). Go ahead and keep your vote on me if you wish, but keep in mind that I'm trying my best to continue supporting your latest opinions on others.

This isn't about me. I just think your activity dropped off but in all fairness you could have been busy with IRL yesterday, and I 100% respect that. Maybe it was because IRL. I don't want to be sheeped. My vote on you is that you're the main person to maf lean or I'm just throwing a knife at a dart board with the 5-7 low posters. And aggreeing with me will not make me drop a maf lean if that's what you're hoping for?????

 

[ribbitribbon]

Mog and Unravel have been on my suspicion list as well; I'm surprised especially that Mog isn't upset about Trundle's actions at all. As for Unravel, they've been quieter than the rest, so I've been feeling a bit uneasy about them for that alone.

You seem to do a good job of calling out the flaws in ribbit's post habits here. While I'm not going to lie and say that me jumping on the Mog wagon so quick was sort of a questionable decision, I can't help but notice ribbit's decisions going much further in depth than mine. I eventually knew when to pull out and think the decision over a second time; they didn't.

I don't think Zinnia is the most wolfy now; that would likely go to Trundle. The reason my suspicion of Zinnia still remains high is because of her lack of posts. If she were explaining her reasonings more, I'd focus more on Trundle.

omg

i have thought my decisions over !!!1!1!!1!1!11!!1!1!1!

*throws my computer out the window*

ANYWAYS i pulled out on the mog thing and said i doubted my reads!! i am still considering voting zinnia but that’s not entirely based on only a read but general info.

and also… i am just speaking my mind. i don’t like rehearse what im gonna say and make sure it’s perfect. i think i’ve been fairly consistent but im not a robot

 

[Dolby]

Mog and Unravel have been on my suspicion list as well; I'm surprised especially that Mog isn't upset about Trundle's actions at all. As for Unravel, they've been quieter than the rest, so I've been feeling a bit uneasy about them for that alone.

You seem to do a good job of calling out the flaws in ribbit's post habits here. While I'm not going to lie and say that me jumping on the Mog wagon so quick was sort of a questionable decision, I can't help but notice ribbit's decisions going much further in depth than mine. I eventually knew when to pull out and think the decision over a second time; they didn't.

I don't think Zinnia is the most wolfy now; that would likely go to Trundle. The reason my suspicion of Zinnia still remains high is because of her lack of posts. If she were explaining her reasonings more, I'd focus more on Trundle.

Trundle being most sus is kinda just ???? To me

Like I’m fine with lot of the rest of your worldview but I feel like that’s news to me or maybe I’ve just been skimming your posts to much. I think the thread state around Trundlea Mog read makes trundle likely town but since you’re one of the effected players with your Mog push maybe you feel different

Post automatically merged: May 12, 2024

This isn't about me. I just think your activity dropped off but in all fairness you could have been busy with IRL yesterday, and I 100% respect that. Maybe it was because IRL. I don't want to be sheeped. My vote on you is that you're the main person to maf lean or I'm just throwing a knife at a dart board with the 5-7 low posters. And aggreeing with me will not make me drop a maf lean if that's what you're hoping for?????

read this and think that the last "your" in that post was supposed to be a my? Post as a whole makes more sense as something that leaves someone's brain if I think like that

 

[TN4U]

This isn't about me. I just think your activity dropped off but in all fairness you could have been busy with IRL yesterday, and I 100% respect that. Maybe it was because IRL. I don't want to be sheeped. My vote on you is that you're the main person to maf lean or I'm just throwing a knife at a dart board with the 5-7 low posters. And aggreeing with me will not make me drop a maf lean if that's what you're hoping for?????

I'm not expecting you to drop your vote. It's totally fine to suspect someone of being wolfy because of activity reasons, but take a look at Annika, Unravel, Zinnia and Yoshi. Some of them I view as heavy town (Annika and Yoshi), others more wolfy (Zinnia and Unravel). Right now, Zinnia has not convinced me to change my mind about her because of post emptiness, while there's simply not enough information from Unravel to formulate a safe opinion on. I'm ignoring the "wehs" from Annika as it was only a small passing joke, while Yoshi seems to be very neutral-minded from what I can tell.

If it helps, I view you as the towniest of all in terms of post habits.

Trundle being most sus is kinda just ???? To me

Like I’m fine with lot of the rest of your worldview but I feel like that’s news to me or maybe I’ve just been skimming your posts to much. I think the thread state around Trundlea Mog read makes trundle likely town but since you’re one of the effected players with your Mog push maybe you feel different

Could you explain how you view Trundle as more town? For me, the red flags outweigh the towny-ness of his other posts.

 

[mogyay]

@t4nu i have the humbling experience of knowing trundle so im not upset by him doing that and ive said before hes done it before (altho i appreciate u wouldnt know that) , i think id be upset if i woke up and he had kept the push going but i rly do think he was just testing the waters, im not a strong player so its easy for ppl to jump on me and i honestly do think thats why he did it. i dont see mafia trundle doing it (or doing it in the same way)

 

[TN4U]

@t4nu i have the humbling experience of knowing trundle so im not upset by him doing that and ive said before hes done it before (altho i appreciate u wouldnt know that) , i think id be upset if i woke up and he had kept the push going but i rly do think he was just testing the waters, im not a strong player so its easy for ppl to jump on me and i honestly do think thats why he did it. i dont see mafia trundle doing it (or doing it in the same way)

Alright, fair point. This is my first mafia game on TBT, so of course I'm not going to know past relationships between players. I just find some of his latest posts iffy in my opinion.

 

[Dolby]

I'm not expecting you to drop your vote. It's totally fine to suspect someone of being wolfy because of activity reasons, but take a look at Annika, Unravel, Zinnia and Yoshi. Some of them I view as heavy town (Annika and Yoshi), others more wolfy (Zinnia and Unravel). Right now, Zinnia has not convinced me to change my mind about her because of post emptiness, while there's simply not enough information from Unravel to formulate a safe opinion on. I'm ignoring the "wehs" from Annika as it was only a small passing joke, while Yoshi seems to be very neutral-minded from what I can tell.

If it helps, I view you as the towniest of all in terms of post habits.


Could you explain how you view Trundle as more town? For me, the red flags outweigh the towny-ness of his other posts.

Trundle's Mog push was towny regardless of Mogs alignment. i think his push on Mog was sheeped potentially by mafia (possibly you and/or RibbitRibbon). I think his general posting is town-shaped and it looks well to my brain. I like his reads list though I do have some areas of disagreement with it. That's the quick notes

 

[lily2816]

i might look like im inactive. i have been doing my best to keep up with what has been posted since this morning. however, im still not convinced enough to change my vote.

 

[mogyay]

idk maybe ur not mafia but me, zinnia and unravel all seem opportunities that mafia can easily take and it sits weird w me : ( but im a baby

also i dont think u need meta to see that from trundle, he gave no real reason for me being mafia and didnt really push the fact , also as far as i know u havent given any reason for me past or present even tho im still on ur sus list so idkkkk , it feels off

 

[Dolby]

i might look like im inactive. i have been doing my best to keep up with what has been posted since this morning. however, im still not convinced enough to change my vote.

I'm sorry if this is a bit overwhelming in terms of how many posts have made in this thread. Do you have any thoughts on who seems the most like a crewmate and the most like an imposter?

Post automatically merged: May 12, 2024

idk maybe ur not mafia but me, zinnia and unravel all seem opportunities that mafia can easily take and it sits weird w me : ( but im a baby

also i dont think u need meta to see that from trundle, he gave no real reason for me being mafia and didnt really push the fact , also as far as i know u havent given any reason for me past or present even tho im still on ur sus list so idkkkk , it feels off

Eh, I kinda thought that your posting was empty, and thought that Trundle was seeing the same thing at the time Trundle made his push even though he didn't elaborate on it.

 

[TN4U]

Trundle's Mog push was towny regardless of Mogs alignment. i think his push on Mog was sheeped potentially by mafia (possibly you and/or RibbitRibbon). I think his general posting is town-shaped and it looks well to my brain. I like his reads list though I do have some areas of disagreement with it. That's the quick notes

While I did jump on that Mog wagon for a bit, ribbit did stay on the wagon longer than me after I heard what Mog had to say on the manner. If anything, I could be a bit suspicious of ribbit, but I'm not 100% sure of them.

 

[mogyay]

I'm sorry if this is a bit overwhelming in terms of how many posts have made in this thread. Do you have any thoughts on who seems the most like a crewmate and the most like an imposter?

Post automatically merged: May 12, 2024

Eh, I kinda thought that your posting was empty, and thought that Trundle was seeing the same thing at the time Trundle made his push even though he didn't elaborate on it.

i get that but there's other ppl he could have chose ig , but idk that was just a guess , maybe im giving myself too much credit but either way i dont think he actually could think i was mafia from some lackluster posts an hour into the game

 

[voltairenism]

@t4nu i have the humbling experience of knowing trundle so im not upset by him doing that and ive said before hes done it before (altho i appreciate u wouldnt know that) , i think id be upset if i woke up and he had kept the push going but i rly do think he was just testing the waters, im not a strong player so its easy for ppl to jump on me and i honestly do think thats why he did it. i dont see mafia trundle doing it (or doing it in the same way)

im not aware of trundles meta but reaction test or not i dont like it being done to a clearly innactive player; i mean you said yourself you are a lhf so it makes me more suspicious of trundle
and he kept it going even after the active players at the time had already gave their 2 cents so. idk


i think what i dont get abt tn4u is that he is sus of mog and trundle at the same time? @TN4U do you think they are teamed?

 

[N e s s]

Alright I'm at page 11 and these are my basic thoughts.

I think forming any kind of "obvious town" list at the moment could create a scenario where those players coast by, so I'm not willing to create anyone as "lock town" like my predecessor was seemingly doing with the likes of Dolby and Annika. That being said though, FrostyAlmonds strikes me as blatantly honest and I'm kinda here for it. Willing to give Frosty the town pass for Day 1.

Dolby's posts up until this point are cohesive. He hasn't said anything up to page 11 that is inherently bad I think he's making an effort to solve things. Still keeping my vote him though for the lols

I don't think Trundle is half as suspicious as people seem to think he is right now, feels like he was trying to get the ball rolling by saying mog is an obvious wolf. So far it's Mog vs. Trundle/TN4U/Annika/Zinnia from what I'm gathering, I think those 4 will be a good area to investigate for the rest of the game as there's not a chance in my mind that all of them are mafia together. At most I can see TN4U or Annika being one of or a team with Zinnia just kind of saying things for the heck of it.

Not sure how much I vibe with Volt either sorry bestie. Hard to explain that one but they haven't said anything that strikes me as inherrently town within pages 1-11 beyond the vibes I got in page 23. I get the impression Volt was trying to be disagreeable for the sake of it? Saw some post somewhere that felt mildly like they were trying to spread wolf influence (if that makes sense). This may just be my ramblings but I don't trust them.

TN4U is an oddity. Unsure how to feel about them, seems like they're town trying to help in all the wrong ways.

Back to reading

Post automatically merged: May 12, 2024

Yikes let me clarify: I see a low chance of a TN4U/Annika team, but Zinnia seems like they just agreed with the mog sus for the sake of it.

 

[ribbitribbon]

omg

zinnia don’t come back and just vote me without saying anything wtf