Best octopus villager?

[CinnamonCrab]

Marina's my favorite for sure. I kind of wish they'd add a couple more octopus villagers!! They're so cute, after all.

 

[SirOctopie]

I have all three on my island. Since the octopus is my favorite animal, I just had to have them all. ❤

I do like Marina and Octavian more than Zucker, mostly because I'm a bit iffy on how lazy villagers are portrayed in NH. I guess some of his antics involving gross food things would make sense *because* he's based on takoyaki.

 

[hakutaku]

Zucker! I have him on my island and I love his design

 

[princess.looking.for.frog]

I love all of them but my favourite has to be Zucker, he has such a different kind of design and I love the Japanese tribute to the takoyaki balls

 

[Tutle]

Definitely Marina!!! She has a cute house, very cute and distinct look and she has an awesome personality. Love her catchphrase as well!!! I loved having her more than Zucker.

 

[pinkfawn]

Marina, I love her house, I love pink, I love her cute little bow. She's adorable.
I've never had Zucker, so I can't really say anything about him. But I have had Octavian in New Horizons, he's alright. I had a bias against him though since I had him in WW when I was a kid. He yelled at me all the time and I was very afraid of him. Not a fan.

 

[Nosfurratu]

I wasn’t a huge fan of Marina until I came across her on a random island and invited her to move to mine. After getting to talk to her for a while she really grew on me. & not only that but I don’t care for the octopus villager designs but Marina is my winner.

 

[moonlights]

Zucker 100%, I love his design

 

[Rosch]

I had Marina on my island. She's adorable. NH normal/sweet villagers are really bland, sadly.

I encountered Zucker several times while island hopping. He looks pissed. As usual.

I never had Zucker, but I have seen him on other islands. I had him in New Leaf though. I also like takoyaki. So Zucker wins.

 

[Slaxmax]

I love Marina best, then Zucker, and then Octavian. Octavian reminds me of octopus pokemon a bit XD

 

[TheSillyPuppy]

Marina looks like such a sweetie. Runner-up would be Octavian for me, as my S/O had him as his cranky for a while. I'm not a big fan of the food-themed villagers, though I do appreciate the shout-out to takoyaki/octopus balls.

 

[DarkSlayer1331]

I've had Marina on both NL and NH, and she's cute. Although she's not one of my favorite villagers in general. But she's sweet, and I do really enjoy the fact that she just can't seem to help but sing around the island. Or at least on my island she was singing an awful lot.

 

[niko@kamogawa]

I am not a big fan of their species. However, I voted for Marina because she's adorable. I still have her in my island but will likely move her out soon.

 

[Moonlight.]

marina's easily my fave out of the three, but inkwell's probably my favorite overall...wish he and the other crossover characters were in new horizons smh

 

[returnofsaturn]

I picked Marina cuz anytime I'd walk into her house when I had her in NL, she'd be sitting on the toilet.


ps. I wish they'd make a cute light green one lmao.

 

[peachycrossing9]

My all time fave is Zucker It used to be Marina, but I have become really attached to Zucker once he moved onto my island a while ago.

 

[idiotdoomspiral]

definitely zucker. i had marina on my island for a bit, she kinda wore off on me though, the ribbon on the back of her head looks very weird since it looks like it was drawn on lol. if i didnt have 2 lazies already i would think about island hopping for zucker. octavian used to be my favourite octopus during nl days,

 

[Pintuition]

MARINA!! But I like Zucker and Octavian a lot as well! I really wish they would make more octopus villagers, there's so much untapped potential in that.

 

[saucySheep]

Personally I despise all of the octopi, they're disgusting and I would hate to have one on my island.
Zucker is somewhat of an exception, though. He's still nasty-looking as he is an octopus but like almost cute ig? Idk.

 

[Fantasyland]

My jaw actually dropped when Octavian wasn't the poll winner! I always tend to prefer villagers that have "realistic" coloring, and Octavian is my dude - though his house interior totally ruins the idea of him I have. I have Zucker on my island as well, and while he's adorable, I can't help thinking about how sticky he would be if I were to accidentally bump into him like my villager does.

I suppose there could be pink octopus in real life, so I should give Marina more of a chance!