Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[cornimer]

Well guys, I handed in my major paper, and while I still have 500 other things to do I'm going to start working on an ISO of iLoveYou. This is mostly because my opinion of her has changed a lot throughout the game and I think other people are a little conflicted as well, so I'm hoping to get some clarity.

- - - Post Merge - - -

^also because nobody's really gone through all her posts yet

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh no she has 173 posts is it too late to take that back

 

[iLoveYou]

Why am I not surprised that people want to waste a lynch on me ? Hi mafia ( unless you are generally concerned about me ).

Guys think about it. Seriously, what did I need to prove on Day Two ? Was I being suspected to the point of being a lynch candidate ? No. What danger was I in that I would need to throw away a mafia JOAT & 1 mafia KP ? Literally none. I was read as Town by so many people. So why would I go out of my way to try to lynch mafia on DAY TWO ?

If I were mafia, I would let Dolby get lynched so that KP would still be 3 and be able to continue to use JOAT abilities and then save "coaster" Tom for an easy lynch late in the game to delay Town from catching mafia as quickly as possible.

 

[EpicGamer12]

You really don't need to defend yourself so hard, I don't think anyone said they want to lynch you, especially not today. Suspicion != Scum read

 

[Geoni]

Got a ****-ton to read but at quick glance we have Dolby and Jacob dead and Punchy hit? I'm gonna be at work tonight so I will be able to read here and there and post late-night. I will say this though: I'll try my best not to tunnel glow but she's still very sus for me, pre-catchup. I do like that someone is willing to look into Kayla though because I can see her bluesniping very well if she hasn't played in a while. Sometimes it takes not playing for a while to be able to better see alignment. And I feel like I've been giving her too much of a pass on thinking she can't be acting through all this so well. Given how well she acted during TBT's 2nd mafia game.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Why am I not surprised that people want to waste a lynch on me ? Hi mafia ( unless you are generally concerned about me ).

Guys think about it. Seriously, what did I need to prove on Day Two ? Was I being suspected to the point of being a lynch candidate ? No. What danger was I in that I would need to throw away a mafia JOAT & 1 mafia KP ? Literally none. I was read as Town by so many people. So why would I go out of my way to try to lynch mafia on DAY TWO ?

If I were mafia, I would let Dolby get lynched so that KP would still be 3 and be able to continue to use JOAT abilities and then save "coaster" Tom for an easy lynch late in the game to delay Town from catching mafia as quickly as possible.

Let Dolby get lynched? You do realize it takes effort to lynch someone like Dolby, right?

- - - Post Merge - - -

This is a weird post overall. Anyways bbl. Throwing my vote on glow now but may change if someone somehow becomes scummier in my caught up reads.

 

[iLoveYou]

Let Dolby get lynched? You do realize it takes effort to lynch someone like Dolby, right?

You do realize that many people wanted to lynch him right ? For information ? If I were mafia, the best play to make that day would be to sit back and let it happen. Not ho out of my way to lynch a mafia that no one even wanted to lynch ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

You really don't need to defend yourself so hard, I don't think anyone said they want to lynch you, especially not today. Suspicion != Scum read

No I know, but I'm not going to let any potential mafia try to find an excuse to lynch me and make us waste a lynch.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also Dad, the double voter Jacob wanted to lynch him so bad he had already placed his vote on him. That's how confidently people wanted to lynch Dolby Day two.

 

[Geoni]

Whether or not you sit back on day 2 Tom was going to probably get lynched due to how universally he was scumread so I don't know why you're trying to argue that you could possibly sit back and hope people would lynch Dolby instead of Tom.

And Tom was probably not very confident coming back as mafia after a long time away from playing it.

 

[N e s s]

Kayla isnt 100% confirmed but we're definitely not lynching her today js

 

[Geoni]

These are my last few hours of my days off I'm not wasting them on mafia again byyye

 

[iLoveYou]

Whether or not you sit back on day 2 Tom was going to probably get lynched due to how universally he was scumread so I don't know why you're trying to argue that you could possibly sit back and hope people would lynch Dolby instead of Tom.

And Tom was probably not very confident coming back as mafia after a long time away from playing it.

Are you serious right now ? The double voter already placed a vote on Dolby almost 10 hours before end of day. People were literally PUSHING for Dolby to get lynched. People were literally saying they did NOT want to lynch Tom.

- - - Post Merge - - -

These are my last few hours of my days off I'm not wasting them on mafia again byyye

Wtf ??

 

[cornimer]

Why am I not surprised that people want to waste a lynch on me ? Hi mafia ( unless you are generally concerned about me ).

Guys think about it. Seriously, what did I need to prove on Day Two ? Was I being suspected to the point of being a lynch candidate ? No. What danger was I in that I would need to throw away a mafia JOAT & 1 mafia KP ? Literally none. I was read as Town by so many people. So why would I go out of my way to try to lynch mafia on DAY TWO ?

If I were mafia, I would let Dolby get lynched so that KP would still be 3 and be able to continue to use JOAT abilities and then save "coaster" Tom for an easy lynch late in the game to delay Town from catching mafia as quickly as possible.

Omk I don't think anyone wants to lynch you, I'm ISOing you with a pretty neutral stance just to get a better idea for future days

 

[iLoveYou]

Omk I don't think anyone wants to lynch you, I'm ISOing you with a pretty neutral stance just to get a better idea for future days

That's fine.

 

[cornimer]

Whether or not you sit back on day 2 Tom was going to probably get lynched due to how universally he was scumread so I don't know why you're trying to argue that you could possibly sit back and hope people would lynch Dolby instead of Tom.

And Tom was probably not very confident coming back as mafia after a long time away from playing it.

Hmm honestly this seems like a strange attempt to start getting Kayla sussed more and it makes me trust Dad a little less
Also why are you voting for glow, what about Punchy?

 

[Kamzitty]

Kammm You're doing an awesome job, especially for your very first game - you're a natural!

I just want to point out though that Ryumia has been consistently happy to vote for their own potential lynch (even needing to be convinced to remove their self-vote when votes were close during the (iirc) Tom lynch. In context, I do not see her willingness to put herself at risk by voting Punchy to be indicative of her alignment.

Is that scenario, of Punchy flipping as Mafia, is that result the only reason you plan to drop your sus of Ryumia?

- - - Post Merge - - -



@ ILoveYou : I didn't see Antonio volunteer, or even post at all - do you mean Ryumia instead?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Tina, could you please add the post filters for us replacements to the OP when you can? Thanks

Thank you Amanda! <3
My reasons for dropping suspicions on Ryumia are because she's been more cooperative and has been contributing more ever since I and others had pushed her to earlier in the game. I don't necessarily think her voting punchy is alignment indicative, but I don't think she would be so willing to if she was mafia.
I worded my post wrong when I said ALL my suspicions would be dropped,but I will definitely not be as certain she's scum if she helps with his lynch, she doesn't seem like the type to bus her teammates.

I'll try to post some reads at some point today. I'm still pretty ok with lynching punchy but I think it's good to consider other candidates because the way punchy is so accepting of his death is making me feel slightly uneasy lol.

 

[cornimer]

I also like that Ryumia is willing to risk voting for Punchy b u t if nothing is gonna happen when he flips, mafia would be the only ones to know and thus will vote to make themselves look good, knowing nothing is gonna happen. This is something we should keep in mind for everyone, not just Ryumia

 

[iLoveYou]

Dad is acting strange. He literally came here to promote suspicion on me and then say " well I'm out now, but I'll vote for Glow on my way out ". Seriously what about the Punchy issue ??

- - - Post Merge - - -

Hmm honestly this seems like a strange attempt to start getting Kayla sussed more and it makes me trust Dad a little less
Also why are you voting for glow, what about Punchy?

I didn't see this post sory for repeating.

 

[Kamzitty]

I just looked at dad's read list from yesterday and he put ILY as one of his strongest greens/town leans. Lol I agree it's weird he's sussing you all of a sudden and then just leaves with no explanation?

 

[cornimer]

I just looked at dad's read list from yesterday and he put ILY as one of his strongest greens/town leans. Lol I agree it's weird he's sussing you all of a sudden and then just leaves with no explanation?

Yeah, that's even weirder. I don't think I town lean him any more after this interaction

 

[amazonevan19]

I don’t think dad’s prone to such sloppy play but idk, he did seem a bit tipsy/weird lol.

Tbh I’m ok with myself voting punchy because I’m very confident everything about him is BS and we have nothing to fear voting him.

 

[iLoveYou]

I'm trlling you guys, they're going to try to have Town waste a lynch on me.

 

[cornimer]

I'm trlling you guys, they're going to try to have Town waste a lynch on me.

That's not happening, PunchyDaScum needs to go