Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[EpicGamer12]

Any1 else feeling at least 1 scum in Dad/Amanda

 

[cornimer]

Any1 else feeling at least 1 scum in Dad/Amanda

Possibly both :eyes:

- - - Post Merge - - -

But that's what this is. Paranoia. If I die from voting for Punchy ya'll can put a clown hat on my avatar but for now I'm going to reassert that this is such a silly concern.

I'm holding you to that

- - - Post Merge - - -

I might try to ISO Dad sometime before D4 starts. If I make any form of new reads list I'll post it right before the end of N3 like everyone else suggested.

 

[iLoveYou]

Any1 else feeling at least 1 scum in Dad/Amanda

To be honest, yes. I'm leaning towards Amanda/Gig because of what happened during the Day One voting where Gig jumped on the Antonio bandwagon.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Hopefully I got the replacement riht this time. Pretty much I am leaning Gigalabesh as a scum read.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also something else I want to add is that Giggs stayed quielty active on the thread until after the voting results post were made.

Is it fair to judge Amanda by [/b]Gig's[/b] actions ? I don't know. But at the end of the day they have he same role ?

 

[Ryumia]

To be honest, yes. I'm leaning towards Amanda/Gig because of what happened during the Day One voting where Gig jumped on the Antonio bandwagon.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Hopefully I got the replacement riht this time. Pretty much I am leaning Gigalabesh as a scum read.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also something else I want to add is that Giggs stayed quielty active on the thread until after the voting results post were made.

Is it fair to judge Amanda by Gig's actions ? I don't know. But at the end of the day they have he same role ?

I wouldn't think so in my opinion. I mean... I was a replacement for my first mafia game and I thought it was bizarre that I was being judged based off someone else's actions. To me... I think you should give Amanda some type of chance here. This is just how I feel about the matter because I can relate to it a lot.

 

[Kamzitty]

@ILY @Ryumia
I think it's understandable what Ryumia is saying, but when it comes to replacements, the actions of the person who was replaced should always be taken into account. I agree with ILY it was odd how they just appeared out of nowhere to vote that day. Amanda definitely does deserve a chance, but that doesn't mean we're gonna disregard any suspicions that were on gig because that will set us back a lot.
But imo , gig didn't really do enough to be able to judge whether they were scum or not. they posted like 4 times, and even though it was sus, maybe they just legit had no idea what they were doing lol. I'm neutral when it comes to gig and I would need to hear more from Amanda before anything.

 

[Antonio]

To be honest, yes. I'm leaning towards Amanda/Gig because of what happened during the Day One voting where Gig jumped on the Antonio bandwagon.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Hopefully I got the replacement riht this time. Pretty much I am leaning Gigalabesh as a scum read.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also something else I want to add is that Giggs stayed quielty active on the thread until after the voting results post were made.

Is it fair to judge Amanda by [/b]Gig's[/b] actions ? I don't know. But at the end of the day they have he same role ?

Why not? They both had the same role even if they had played different ways. Of course, it shouldn't be a major factor when deciding.

 

[glow]

guys my surface is stuck in UEFI boot loop

posting from my phone is HELL

 

[amazonevan19]

But that's what this is. Paranoia. If I die from voting for Punchy ya'll can put a clown hat on my avatar but for now I'm going to reassert that this is such a silly concern.

I'll hold you to that too

Made these for ya just in case

 

[Antonio]

I'll hold you to that too

Made these for ya just in case

I appreciate what you have done for this thread.

 

[amazonevan19]

dad brings up a decent point on Karen but if we're going to look at how peeps have interacted with punchy, I think nearly everyone townread him at the start, so the fact I or anyone else townleaned him shouldn't really be used as evidence. I think the timing of townleaning could be though, as mafia teammates could have piled on the punchy townleaning.

For example, let's look at dad's perennial scumlean, glow. First mention of punchy has glow passively mention him by grouping him in an easy lynch train for scum, implying punchy was town and lynch bait:

dad, in a game half full of brand new and newer players: "i'm an easy target"

(besides isn't Ness an easier target than 2/3 of my reads.......or katezilla)

oath/dedenne maybe easy targets i guess?? i mean as scum its a lot easier to just pick up traction for a lynch that's already been pushed (Ness, punchy, fire, Antonio, etc). i think the only sr I've shared with a couple people is oath. but oaths content is objectively bad

i will say i find it odd that you immediately compare me to my scumreads, i mean i believe my content has been nothing like theirs though i have no ambition to impress anyone. i would rather you just admit to you forcing your own underdeveloped reads out than you trying to speculate about reads i haven't even explained.

below isn't really to u, dad, but i'm too lazy to make a separate post and it's somewhat relevant so

i very much dislike how dedenne feels the need to constantly say "guys i'm posting my reads soon don't sus me" (they've done it 2-3 times) and in their first couple posts dedenne said something like "omg everything in my notes has been discussed! guess i will wait til d2 to post reads"

why not just say what you've agreed or disagreed with so far. constant excuses for small things read v paranoid.

The next time she mentioned punchy, it sounds like she thought punchy's claim was believable...

well i think there was 5 starting mafia and the most likely scenario is that dolby shot punchy believing there was no truth to punchy's role.

i think if we can answer whether or not dolby shot punchy, we can answer whether or not punchy's telling the truth. honestly, if i was dolby, i wouldn't have shot punchy, fearing that the weirdly specific role was too odd to be true. dolby seemed to believe the opposite:



i think dolby shot punchy, then was nightkilled, in addition to dying because of punchy's role.

there's also the possibility that dolby didn't shoot and he was simply killed, and upon seeing there was no third death punchy outed that he was "hit" --- but i find this less likely due to the timing of punchy's hit claim being so fast.

to me, it doesn't really make sense why mafia would have a veteran bomb role + a healing role (JOAT), which could give credibility to punchy's claim. something else that comes to mind is that if i was mafia with a veteran bomb role on my team, i wouldn't use KP on anyone who i believe would shoot punchy as vig, as they would die upon shooting the bomb and KP would be wasted.

that said, i think it's worth looking into how tina might have used veteran in the past. the common definition of veteran is a role that will shoot anyone who visits them, but on TBT its used as a different word for bulletproof (vested).

the part that throws me off is the part about a lover being included in his role PM, i feel like that's too weird to lie about in a time where nobody really believes what you're saying anyway.

i'm beyond hesitant to say this, but i do believe punchy is 100% telling the truth about his role. that doesn't make him town, but yeah that's where i'm at.

what's notable about this is that this is after punchy's claim and that he got hit. Glow purposefully avoided talking about punchy at all until this point...hmmmm

i still have like 10 pages to read but evan's town and punchys like 110% mafia

- - - Post Merge - - -



hostile = killing roles

the next mention? all of a sudden punchy's "110% mafia" wtf...

seems a little sketch to me

inb4 giant dad post on "hurr evan's putting more effort into memes than reads" welp guilty as charged

- - - Post Merge - - -

*talking about punchy directly

 

[Geoni]

Thanks Evan.

Feel free to ISOread me nerds. Then maybe you'll be forced to actually look at glow for once (looking at you Trundle).

 

[Ghostkid]

Can someone please explain y its better to self vote than no lynch?

 

[cornimer]

Can someone please explain y its better to self vote than no lynch?

Because multiple people could vote no lynch and then "no lynch" will actually happen. But if everyone votes for themselves, then each person will only have one vote and Punchy will be in the lead

 

[Ghostkid]

Because multiple people could vote no lynch and then "no lynch" will actually happen. But if everyone votes for themselves, then each person will only have one vote and Punchy will be in the lead

Oh i thought no lynch ment that the person dosnt want to lynch that day...

 

[cornimer]

Oh i thought no lynch ment that the person dosnt want to lynch that day...

No, if multiple people vote "no lynch" then nobody will be lynched.

 

[Ghostkid]

ok i changed my vote.

 

[cornimer]

I'm only like 1/6 of the way through the game but omk does the Dad/Glow war never end

- - - Post Merge - - -

this Dad ISO is prob gonna turn into both of them bc they're inseparable

 

[glow]

Thanks Evan.

Feel free to ISOread me nerds. Then maybe you'll be forced to actually look at glow for once (looking at you Trundle).

if i was mafia why would you be alive over Dolby

 

[cornimer]

if i was mafia why would you be alive over Dolby

I mean I think if one of you died everyone would assume the other was mafia

 

[glow]

dad brings up a decent point on Karen but if we're going to look at how peeps have interacted with punchy, I think nearly everyone townread him at the start, so the fact I or anyone else townleaned him shouldn't really be used as evidence. I think the timing of townleaning could be though, as mafia teammates could have piled on the punchy townleaning.

For example, let's look at dad's perennial scumlean, glow. First mention of punchy has glow passively mention him by grouping him in an easy lynch train for scum, implying punchy was town and lynch bait:



The next time she mentioned punchy, it sounds like she thought punchy's claim was believable...



what's notable about this is that this is after punchy's claim and that he got hit. Glow purposefully avoided talking about punchy at all until this point...hmmmm



the next mention? all of a sudden punchy's "110% mafia" wtf...

seems a little sketch to me

inb4 giant dad post on "hurr evan's putting more effort into memes than reads" welp guilty as charged

- - - Post Merge - - -

*talking about punchy directly

i wasn't listing people I thought were town i was listing "easy lynches"

punchys claim feels like it had merit due to the fact that i would expect Dolby to shoot punchy

yes because he said his wincon was to eliminate hostile parties when that is not in towns win con

- - - Post Merge - - -

I mean I think if one of you died everyone would assume the other was mafia

that's really a bad assumption coz i think there's a good chance dad is town

he always tunnels me in the hopes he will be right one day..

- - - Post Merge - - -

actually it wasn't in mafias wincon either

wild