EpicGamer12
Senior Member
Well either you or her, but I think it's you
Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
Well either you or her, but I think it's you
I agree I don’t really see town winning at this point. Still very pissed (no offence Tina) a role like that was put in, especially given to Punchy.
Rn I’m sorta just trying to lynch for the sake of it and if we lost then idrc cos this game was doomed to begin with, and I def believe human balancing is vital for future games.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Again, Dad vs Glow town vs town. zzz
going to bed bye
Honestly I'm on the same page as you here. I feel super defeated and there's players staying extremely quiet so there's probably mafia amongst them riding these days out in there and it's damn hard to even think about how they probably won't even talk to help us out. Literally everything feels against us at this point.
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
yeah I'll start a new reads list but I have a feeling its going to be very wishy-washy
This. So. Much.
cornimer
grab acorns 'til you're delirious
Also @everyone sussing me for being opportunistic about Punchy, if you look back at all my other games when I tunnel someone that hard I'm town. If I knew he was going to flip town and I was scum, why would I take the risk and make myself look bad? My reads and stances have been totally off this game, I admit it, but if I'm scum I've been playing really carelessly.
Also I really thought "we had 3kp" was a scumslip, especially when he tried so hard to correct it after (he was like ******town). As first time scum I'm sure he would be nervous and would be prone to word messups like that.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Could it be possible BG is 1-shot bulletproof or something?
Also I really thought "we had 3kp" was a scumslip, especially when he tried so hard to correct it after (he was like ******town). As first time scum I'm sure he would be nervous and would be prone to word messups like that.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Could it be possible BG is 1-shot bulletproof or something?
Yeah that's because I don't think you did bus Tom. The only time you genuinely considered him a good lynch was when everyone else was already on the wagon, rather I think what you did was a easily a form of distancing. The only person in this game I think could have legitimately bussed Tom was iLoveYou, and I'm starting to consider her a possibility as well. You were investing so nuch time in Day 1 on Tom, yet you decide the best lynch is Antonio because he's an inactive? That's weak af.
idk why u left out amanda
she?s def good as scum
- - - Post Merge - - -
why do you hope that
This is based off of impressions only but I'm reading Amanda as townish from her tone. In Woodpines Oregon I often noticed that's amanda was incredibly self conscious about how she appeared at all times and would constantly backpedal on things so she could look more appealing.
Also part of my defeatism here is that I feel very strongly about glow being scum, it hasn't changed, and yet people just shrug it off because it seems like I'm tunneling but she's done so much **** to be scumread for:
-Her first post in the game was a bizarre post about Dolby and (someone - FireNinja?) and Antonio and myself being incompatible teams and left vague
-The push on Dedenne initiated the lynch that was eventually executed on her even though she didn't vote
-She 'forgot' to vote on the day with Dedenne flipping when it seemed like that is who she was intent on voting for. I know I didn't vote on D2 and that's hypocritical of me but it's fair to point it out of her too
-The whole 'Tom's tone makes him seem town but Oath's tone is scummy' as an answer to me pointing out how she was sussing Oath for doing what Tom was doing but not talking about Tom at all
-Got sus of Antonio for some reason and that's a townread of mine atm and also it fit in with her tendency to go after weak people like she did with Dedenne and Oath
-Sus of FireNinja earlier on and he's a townlock of me at this point
-Participation in the Punchy lynch. Another hypocritical point of mine but she voted him too and seemed to not really raise too much care about the paranoia of his role killing voters, but I can understand why a lot of people would vote this, given I did
-She's been having this tendency all game to say 'if I was mafia I would do this' or 'if I was mafia I would do that'. She's done it at least 5-6 times if not more
-Her talking about 'if she doesn't die' multiple times fits in with the point above
-Is lowkey going after Ness at the beginning of this day just because he said he was bodyguarded and that mafia only using 1 KP in order to fake that is a distracting point to bring up and weirdly pushy in a way I don't see a day 4 town glow being
-The small moment I pointed out in 2822
-On the same page, another moment I pointed out in 2828
-There's got to be somebody skilled enough to have bluesniped both Toads and Oath and then moving forward killing off people who were being townread the most (Dolby, Jacob, Rune, Ness) is something I only see a more experienced player capable of doing. Only glow, Ness, Kayla, Trundle, and maybe Heyden seem sharp enough to have accomplished all of that out of the people still alive. And glow is the most sus out of all those people for me.
There are probably other points but these are the ones that come to mind. So forgive me if I'm annoyed at this point that people would sus me over her considering all of this.
-Her first post in the game was a bizarre post about Dolby and (someone - FireNinja?) and Antonio and myself being incompatible teams and left vague
-The push on Dedenne initiated the lynch that was eventually executed on her even though she didn't vote
-She 'forgot' to vote on the day with Dedenne flipping when it seemed like that is who she was intent on voting for. I know I didn't vote on D2 and that's hypocritical of me but it's fair to point it out of her too
-The whole 'Tom's tone makes him seem town but Oath's tone is scummy' as an answer to me pointing out how she was sussing Oath for doing what Tom was doing but not talking about Tom at all
-Got sus of Antonio for some reason and that's a townread of mine atm and also it fit in with her tendency to go after weak people like she did with Dedenne and Oath
-Sus of FireNinja earlier on and he's a townlock of me at this point
-Participation in the Punchy lynch. Another hypocritical point of mine but she voted him too and seemed to not really raise too much care about the paranoia of his role killing voters, but I can understand why a lot of people would vote this, given I did
-She's been having this tendency all game to say 'if I was mafia I would do this' or 'if I was mafia I would do that'. She's done it at least 5-6 times if not more
-Her talking about 'if she doesn't die' multiple times fits in with the point above
-Is lowkey going after Ness at the beginning of this day just because he said he was bodyguarded and that mafia only using 1 KP in order to fake that is a distracting point to bring up and weirdly pushy in a way I don't see a day 4 town glow being
-The small moment I pointed out in 2822
-On the same page, another moment I pointed out in 2828
-There's got to be somebody skilled enough to have bluesniped both Toads and Oath and then moving forward killing off people who were being townread the most (Dolby, Jacob, Rune, Ness) is something I only see a more experienced player capable of doing. Only glow, Ness, Kayla, Trundle, and maybe Heyden seem sharp enough to have accomplished all of that out of the people still alive. And glow is the most sus out of all those people for me.
There are probably other points but these are the ones that come to mind. So forgive me if I'm annoyed at this point that people would sus me over her considering all of this.
amanda1983
Senior Member
I'm what now?? Do you recall how "good" I was last game??
Ness, please explain to me in what danger was I on Day Two that I would feel the need to "bus" a mafia player ? That I would feel the need to lose KP and a JOAT who still had abilities to be used since only one night went by ?
I wasn't being considered as a lynch candidate and I wasn't even having suspicions placed onto me.
I didn't vote Tom on Day One because several people were saying it would be so obvious whether he was scum or town over time. So I went with that too ? What if I was wrong about his quietness on Day One ? He said he never takes Day One seriously either.
I wasn't being considered as a lynch candidate and I wasn't even having suspicions placed onto me.
I didn't vote Tom on Day One because several people were saying it would be so obvious whether he was scum or town over time. So I went with that too ? What if I was wrong about his quietness on Day One ? He said he never takes Day One seriously either.
o wait amanda replaced in
honestly i don’t think it’s really that hard to read for blues so i mean i wouldn’t use that as a reason here
- - - Post Merge - - -
WERENT U MAFIA
i’m SO CONFUSED
- - - Post Merge - - -
YA u were mafia and won
lmao
honestly i don’t think it’s really that hard to read for blues so i mean i wouldn’t use that as a reason here
- - - Post Merge - - -
WERENT U MAFIA
i’m SO CONFUSED
- - - Post Merge - - -
YA u were mafia and won
lmao
amanda1983
Senior Member
Ya, and I sucked at it and was being scum-read by Evan + others from the start, even before accidentally helping you meet you Win / Con. That we won had precious little to do with me and a lot more to do with the particular dynamics against Town.
You and Trundle keep using "I would NEVER bus the scum joat!" as a shield. I'll read into your ISO after school because it feels a lot to me like you have the "big posts = town" effect which a leads a lot of Town players to sheep. With your level of experience, I do believe that you would bus Tom as a way to get yourself into this exact position.
If you're Town, then you should have nothing to worry about right? I'm just one voice in the crowd who doesn't want to give you a free pass while everyone else is townleaning you. You seem to be very defensive of "I wouldn't bus Tom!" each time someone even lightly mentions it.
And I've read what you've refuted. And I wasn't swayed with a great deal of those defenses.
Also did you ever respond to the things I pointed out in 2822 and 2828?
- - - Post Merge - - -
easy lynch
- - - Post Merge - - -
Oh and I forgot that moment when you suddenly didn't care about the game anymore after one of my big posts against you and didn't really respond to it at all. That's another point I find funky. Granted, Ness did it too and I tr the hell out of him rn.
