Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[iLoveYou]

You and Trundle keep using "I would NEVER bus the scum joat!" as a shield. I'll read into your ISO after school because it feels a lot to me like you have the "big posts = town" effect which a leads a lot of Town players to sheep. With your level of experience, I do believe that you would bus Tom as a way to get yourself into this exact position.

If you're Town, then you should have nothing to worry about right? I'm just one voice in the crowd who doesn't want to give you a free pass while everyone else is townleaning you. You seem to be very defensive of "I wouldn't bus Tom!" each time someone even lightly mentions it.

It's not a shield Ness. I don't know about Trundle though. That would have been really risky to give up on Day Two honestly. So if you really believe that's a possibility then dissect all you want.

Sure, feel free to ISO me, I have no opposition to that. What do you mean I'm defensive about "I wouldn't bus Tom" ?

 

[glow]

hello friends im actually really busy so i don?t mind being the guinea pig / sacrifice wherever I need to be

karen why say this if ur blue

- - - Post Merge - - -

i need to do something tonight

why say this if you?re blue

(why weren?t you roleblocked)

 

[Geoni]

Oh and I forgot that moment when you suddenly didn't care about the game anymore after one of my big posts against you and didn't really respond to it at all. That's another point I find funky. Granted, Ness did it too and I tr the hell out of him rn.

http://www.belltreeforums.com/showt...the-Ships-to-Port-Game-Thread-Day-Four/page70

This.

 

[glow]

http://www.belltreeforums.com/showt...the-Ships-to-Port-Game-Thread-Day-Four/page70

This.

i think it was around the time where i thought you could be town

also how does not responding to you mean i don’t care about the game? honestly i was dealing w **** irl for the first two phases of this game bc that’s why i turned apathetic, but to say i don’t care about the game isn’t true

- - - Post Merge - - -

how exactly do i seem off lmao

- - - Post Merge - - -


ugh what even is this post it sounds so weird

- - - Post Merge - - -

its so tryhard-y and toneless

- - - Post Merge - - -

also dad does have a habit of tvt'ing me, i forgot about that lmao

- - - Post Merge - - -

i lost motivation for this game bc i lost motivation for life

ama if i live tho!!!!

bolded

- - - Post Merge - - -

(that was literally like the next thing i posted after you posted your rant on me

- - - Post Merge - - -

*)

 

[Geoni]

To clarify: I think that post, in combination with what Dedenne flipped, is you being shaken. I already know you're about to make a quippy little 'lmao' post about me saying I had you shook but you reacted how you reacted to a post that you went on to completely not acknowledge.

 

[Antonio]

Literally just gone on and totally forgot my last page? What's currently happening?

 

[iLoveYou]

Also @everyone sussing me for being opportunistic about Punchy, if you look back at all my other games when I tunnel someone that hard I'm town. If I knew he was going to flip town and I was scum, why would I take the risk and make myself look bad? My reads and stances have been totally off this game, I admit it, but if I'm scum I've been playing really carelessly.

Also I really thought "we had 3kp" was a scumslip, especially when he tried so hard to correct it after (he was like ******town). As first time scum I'm sure he would be nervous and would be prone to word messups like that.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Could it be possible BG is 1-shot bulletproof or something?

Ya but the easiest thing to say would be that it would look bad to try to lynch Punchy knowing he was Town because Punchy made a mess of things himself too. So if you were mafia I could definitely see you taking that opportunity to waste a day lynch on him. You could have taken the risk givwn how much of a mess Punchy made and be like " well didn't we all think he was mafia anyways ????".

 

[glow]

To clarify: I think that post, in combination with what Dedenne flipped, is you being shaken. I already know you're about to make a quippy little 'lmao' post about me saying I had you shook but you reacted how you reacted to a post that you went on to completely not acknowledge.

you think i felt shaken by evan? or by you?

can u restate the last sentence

 

[amazonevan19]

Trundle is being pretty lazy and rn I’ve kinda had it with excuses. Glow has had rl **** and has still managed to post maybe two times more than him

 

[glow]

obligatory lmao shook

 

[amazonevan19]

obligatory lmao shook

ObLiGAtorY LmAo sHoOk

 

[EpicGamer12]

Trundle is being pretty lazy and rn I’ve kinda had it with excuses. Glow has had rl **** and has still managed to post maybe two times more than him

It's not really laziness... I'm working 40 hrs a week, doing an online course, and writing a technical report for my co-op term. I usually would use mafia as procrastination but the game isn't super interesting to me.

 

[Geoni]

(that was literally like the next thing i posted after you posted your rant on me

Which not only is in no way shape or form a valid response to all of the points the post in question brought against you but it disenfranchises the points specific to this game by just saying 'Oh that's just Dad being Dad about something he's always been wrong about'.

Also, you townreading me makes my side of me vs you look pushier, which in turn helps the decision not to kill me reflect well on you because it can be a means to further disenfranchise all of the points I have not only brought against you, but continue to point out with you, because I must be wrong if we're both alive right?

 

[Antonio]

It's not really laziness... I'm working 40 hrs a week, doing an online course, and writing a technical report for my co-op term. I usually would use mafia as procrastination but the game isn't super interesting to me.

Would would make it interesting?

 

[Geoni]

you think i felt shaken by evan? or by you?

can u restate the last sentence

Combination tbh. You saw that somebody was already finding them agreeable.

 

[EpicGamer12]

Would would make it interesting?

We could start with inactives being modkilled lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

Hard to have motivation to play when the majority of the scum aren't even playing

 

[cornimer]

Ya but the easiest thing to say would be that it would look bad to try to lynch Punchy knowing he was Town because Punchy made a mess of things himself too. So if you were mafia I could definitely see you taking that opportunity to waste a day lynch on him. You could have taken the risk givwn how much of a mess Punchy made and be like " well didn't we all think he was mafia anyways ????".

I mean that's true, that could be a mafia tactic and I can't really argue against that, but I personally think mafia is more likely to pretend to be unsure about the lynch in order to look good. That's what I've done as mafia in the past

- - - Post Merge - - -

I'll try to make a reads list a little later (I feel like it'll end up more like a "pros and cons of each player list") but at this point the only people I fully trust are FireNinja and Ness. Second class town-leans would probably be Ryumia and Dad just because of his continuous pushing of Glow, I feel like if he were mafia he'd look more at other candidates to blend in but he clearly just wants her gone and it comes off as town frustration to me as I mentioned in my mini-ISO

 

[iLoveYou]

I mean that's true, that could be a mafia tactic and I can't really argue against that, but I personally think mafia is more likely to pretend to be unsure about the lynch in order to look good. That's what I've done as mafia in the past

Normally I would agree but from a mafia perspective Punchy musr have been such an easy lynch to conduct and not be thought of as anything bad. Now considering we hit red the day before, I don't see why someone wouldn't take this opportunity. I don't see why the mafia would play it safe on Punchy considering almost everyone thought he would flip mafia.

 

[glow]

Combination tbh. You saw that somebody was already finding them agreeable.

i think what you don?t see is that i didn?t WANT to be townread

so no i didn?t become shooketh because it?s what i wanted/expected

 

[Geoni]

Heyden I know you've gone to bed but why have those instances you see as pocketing by Trundle tipped the scale from Karen to him suddenly? You could call any points of agreement as pocketing so I'm kinda thrown off that you'd sus him the most just because of that.

- - - Post Merge - - -

i think what you don’t see is that i didn’t WANT to be townread

so no i didn’t become shooketh because it’s what i wanted/expected

Then why did you not respond to all my points in that post?

'I didn't want to be townread'

Is that a general statement this game or about me in particular?