Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[glow]

Dad

what solidified your scumread on dad

 

[Antonio]

good Lord can you just quote the relevant portion of the post you're responding too? Quoting the whole thing already makes this thread more of a chore to go through

I was on mobile, sorry.

To get people off my back, Neilin the Castle Servant and green.

Full discussion on page 72-73.

 

[FireNinja1]

Scum have soft claims. That doesn't mean Antonio is mafia but it definitely doesn't mean that Antonio is cleared.

Note this.

 

[KermitTea]

eh to clarify the 33% thing, im quite certain out of my main 3 suspects at least 1 is scum so the probability is banked on picking the right person. theres a lot of variability now that i think about it but im gonna go for it anyway

 

[Heyden]

eh to clarify the 33% thing, im quite certain out of my main 3 suspects at least 1 is scum so the probability is banked on picking the right person. theres a lot of variability now that i think about it but im gonna go for it anyway

so you’re a result role
and you expect us to trust you and lynch your result that’s only if you pin down the correct scum..?

wtf are you doing

- - - Post Merge - - -

can you legit just, claim

 

[cornimer]

What's a result role

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also how many blues are in this game omk

 

[Heyden]

Detective/Watcher/Tracker, roles that return results

Currently the blue count is 8, 9 if glow is serious

 

[cornimer]

Detective/Watcher/Tracker, roles that return results

Currently the blue count is 8, 9 if glow is serious

O ok I thought there was a legit role called Result Role
That's a fishy amount of blues

 

[glow]

eh to clarify the 33% thing, im quite certain out of my main 3 suspects at least 1 is scum so the probability is banked on picking the right person. theres a lot of variability now that i think about it but im gonna go for it anyway

why didn't you do the thing that you are referring to on the previous night?

you said "theres one more thing i want to do" and then preceded to not do an action?

 

[N e s s]

hey guys I'm claiming too I'm Jos? the Taco Vender

 

[Ghostkid]

eh to clarify the 33% thing, im quite certain out of my main 3 suspects at least 1 is scum so the probability is banked on picking the right person. theres a lot of variability now that i think about it but im gonna go for it anyway

Please i beg of u stop with these mind games stop with the encrypted codes just tell us ur suspects ur reads on them then roleclaim.

 

[FireNinja1]

hey guys I'm claiming too I'm Jos? the Taco Vender

Can't tell if serious or joking.

 

[Heyden]

did everyone lose motivation

 

[Geoni]

Lemme guess glow is town roleblocker.

 

[Heyden]

Also can we start voting, we can’t afford modkills and I don’t really wanna leave this last minute

- - - Post Merge - - -

Trundle if you see this can you claim pls?

 

[FireNinja1]

I'm going off for the night, I will post more in the morning.

 

[glow]

Lemme guess glow is town roleblocker.

why guess that

there’s a 0% i claim before karen i’ll say that!!

 

[Geoni]

@dad, I voted Kermit to put pressure but then I thought I knew her role, and now idk anymore with the 33% stuff. But currently voting Trundle atm cos I scumread him too so.

It seemed to me like you legit scumread her tbh but okay. I'll read back as to why Trundle is so scummy for you.

Because I 100% can see mafia hiding in this Trundle voting.

- - - Post Merge - - -

why guess that

there’s a 0% i claim before karen i’ll say that!!

Not much else left and it's a classic mafia roleblocker claim. Even people like Endless try to pull it off.

 

[Heyden]

It seemed to me like you legit scumread her tbh but okay. I'll read back as to why Trundle is so scummy for you.

Because I 100% can see mafia hiding in this Trundle voting.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Not much else left and it's a classic mafia roleblocker claim. Even people like Endless try to pull it off.

Oh yeah I definitely did, her blue softing early on felt genuine, and now I'm back to scumread. I really really want her to claim bc I feel like she could easily glide this lynch and I have no idea what her role could even be. And like glow said, why didn't she do it last night?

For my Trundle read, I've read 2 or 3 of his past games and his first suspicions are literally always his scummates, but you can notice he never actively pushes them unless everyone else is. His obvious pocketing, WIFOM, and in general lack of reads sort of contributes to the fact he's not playing for town imo. Looking at his last town game in Egyptian Kingmaker, he was very sus of Tina on D1, probably the same level as Tom this game, and displayed a much more tunnel approach to his suspicion on her, while this game it's sort've been, 'Tom is scummy but X is scum too so I'll vote X', intentionally avoiding Tom, like he's done in past games e.g. Zendel in Steven Universe 2.
Oh and PoE, that's a big one too. If he's not scum then idfk at this point.

 

[Geoni]

Oh yeah I definitely did, her blue softing early on felt genuine, and now I'm back to scumread. I really really want her to claim bc I feel like she could easily glide this lynch and I have no idea what her role could even be. And like glow said, why didn't she do it last night?

For my Trundle read, I've read 2 or 3 of his past games and his first suspicions are literally always his scummates, but you can notice he never actively pushes them unless everyone else is. His obvious pocketing, WIFOM, and in general lack of reads sort of contributes to the fact he's not playing for town imo. Looking at his last town game in Egyptian Kingmaker, he was very sus of Tina on D1, probably the same level as Tom this game, and displayed a much more tunnel approach to his suspicion on her, while this game it's sort've been, 'Tom is scummy but X is scum too so I'll vote X', intentionally avoiding Tom, like he's done in past games e.g. Zendel in Steven Universe 2.
Oh and PoE, that's a big one too. If he's not scum then idfk at this point.

Have you already mentioned these susses of Trundle in this thread? Because if not, I want other people to explain why they decided to vote for Trundle when they did. Not in agreement with these points you just brought up if you're just now bringing them up. I'm specifically looking at you two, Evan and GhostKid. And Kayla if she ends up voting for Trundle, why her switch will happen. Because Karen is an easy target too. Both Karen and Trundle tend to say things that put their own foot in their mouths and they get sussed because of it.