Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[glow]

Oh yeah I definitely did, her blue softing early on felt genuine, and now I'm back to scumread. I really really want her to claim bc I feel like she could easily glide this lynch and I have no idea what her role could even be. And like glow said, why didn't she do it last night?

For my Trundle read, I've read 2 or 3 of his past games and his first suspicions are literally always his scummates, but you can notice he never actively pushes them unless everyone else is. His obvious pocketing, WIFOM, and in general lack of reads sort of contributes to the fact he's not playing for town imo. Looking at his last town game in Egyptian Kingmaker, he was very sus of Tina on D1, probably the same level as Tom this game, and displayed a much more tunnel approach to his suspicion on her, while this game it's sort've been, 'Tom is scummy but X is scum too so I'll vote X', intentionally avoiding Tom, like he's done in past games e.g. Zendel in Steven Universe 2.
Oh and PoE, that's a big one too. If he's not scum then idfk at this point.

how did it feel genuine

i literally have NO idea what karen's doing and i'm the type to try to consider literally every scenario

she said she wanted to sacrifice herself to towntell, then she said "o no nvm i need to do one more thing" then now asks for another night to presumably target her scumread

i have one (1) theory but i'll wait to see

i just really want a full claim from her. there's been three nights of actions and i'm quite sure that being left alive to d4 is more than generous

- - - Post Merge - - -

Have you already mentioned these susses of Trundle in this thread? Because if not, I want other people to explain why they decided to vote for Trundle when they did. Not in agreement with these points you just brought up if you're just now bringing them up. I'm specifically looking at you two, Evan and GhostKid. And Kayla if she ends up voting for Trundle, why her switch will happen. Because Karen is an easy target too. Both Karen and Trundle tend to say things that put their own foot in their mouths and they get sussed because of it.

dude i'm pretty sure you've called everyone in the entire game an easy lynch besides me it's actually hilarious

 

[Heyden]

Have you already mentioned these susses of Trundle in this thread? Because if not, I want other people to explain why they decided to vote for Trundle when they did. Not in agreement with these points you just brought up if you're just now bringing them up. I'm specifically looking at you two, Evan and GhostKid. And Kayla if she ends up voting for Trundle, why her switch will happen. Because Karen is an easy target too. Both Karen and Trundle tend to say things that put their own foot in their mouths and they get sussed because of it.

I'm pretty sure I mentioned them in my reads I posted 5 mins before EON3 but I'm not sure.

Also if you think Karen/Trundle are easy pushes, who do you thing the remainder four scum are? Evan/Ghost are townreads for me so I'm not particularly worried as of now honestly.

Plus notice how when everyone was sussing Antonio/Ryumia people would just happily drop votes everywhere, I'm sort of feeling a resistance rn with the lack of voting 24 hours in so I'm actually not too inconfident rn.

 

[glow]

It seemed to me like you legit scumread her tbh but okay. I'll read back as to why Trundle is so scummy for you.

Because I 100% can see mafia hiding in this Trundle voting.

Not much else left and it's a classic mafia roleblocker claim. Even people like Endless try to pull it off.

do you think trundles town?

 

[Heyden]

I'm pretty sure this is a standard for every game but;
If a replacement replaces someone with an action, will they be informed of actions performed previously by their predecessor?

 

[glow]

dad can u not split votes when lynching actually matters now

 

[Ryumia]

Ryumia - had me concerned for a while there with her inscrutable comments and apparent unwillingness to contribute. She answered my questions, as well as others, in a way that seems utterly genuine and would be night impossible to fake as Newbie scum all things considered. I think she's doing the best she can with a type of game that seems outside of her comfort zone. She's definitely too trusting of particular players (Tom, Ness) for reasons a more experienced player would know not to rely upon, but that can only be learned with time. I would like to see her keep up the questioning of players, and try to give more of her thoughts about opinions, and explain them (not how uncertain she is, that has been adequately expressed and we all know that nothing is certain here until we see the results from the host), but I have already seen significant improvement from her so far this game and I'm sure she will continue to further do so.

Thanks for saying that you saw some significant improvement from me. I wasn't sure if I was making any progress, so it is really nice to hear that from someone. So... Thank you very much, Amanda.

did everyone lose motivation

To be honest... Yeah. I kind of lost some motivation. :X But... Amanda's read on me helped me gain a little bit of motivation back for the game.

 

[Heyden]

how did it feel genuine

i literally have NO idea what karen's doing and i'm the type to try to consider literally every scenario

she said she wanted to sacrifice herself to towntell, then she said "o no nvm i need to do one more thing" then now asks for another night to presumably target her scumread

i have one (1) theory but i'll wait to see

i just really want a full claim from her. there's been three nights of actions and i'm quite sure that being left alive to d4 is more than generous

- - - Post Merge - - -



dude i'm pretty sure you've called everyone in the entire game an easy lynch besides me it's actually hilarious

Ok it wasn't really genuine but I read back looking at mogyays few posts, and her only stated townreads were Jacob/Dolby/Hayden. N1 Jacob got the double vote, N2 I got the double vote, N3 you got the double vote. Initially I thought Karen replaced on D3 so I assumed Mogyay was the vote gifter cos it made a lot of sense, but then I realised Karen replaced before the end of D2 so that theory was sort of dead. And the fact she claimed non-vote gifter and bodyguard, so.

I'm back to square one with Karen basically but I don't mind a Trundle lynch

- - - Post Merge - - -

glow who do you think the 4 remaining scum are

 

[iLoveYou]

Have you already mentioned these susses of Trundle in this thread? Because if not, I want other people to explain why they decided to vote for Trundle when they did. Not in agreement with these points you just brought up if you're just now bringing them up. I'm specifically looking at you two, Evan and GhostKid. And Kayla if she ends up voting for Trundle, why her switch will happen. Because Karen is an easy target too. Both Karen and Trundle tend to say things that put their own foot in their mouths and they get sussed because of it.

Well actually I'm voting KermitsTea ( mogyay's replacement ) based on the following:

- Day One mogyay was one of the bandwagoners who re-hashed Dolby's arguments to add content to her posts. Back then I had posted that it looked like her and Ryumia were intentionally doing this to appear seemingly pro-Town with the whole "omg don't you dare suggest we lynch the inactives". My issue wirh that moment is that we were all well and past that so for them to bring it back up, it felt like they just needed content to get by. Oddly enough it happened once I started to call people out.

- As Jacob had posted Day One, mogyay was the most okay to lynch anyone out of players like Antonio and Dedenne2. I did say that I was tempted to vote for her due to her voting herself but I knew it would be too impulsive. For this reason I am actually starting to look at AmazonEvan19 because during this time of only needing 2 mislynches to lose, he honestly seems the most okay jumping on anyone right now, which I feel may be mafia driven.

- mogyay randomly became active during the end of the day when she needed to place a vote and I feel like her bandwagoning onto the two players I mentioned, was to ensure a safe lynch for her and her team ( should she be mafia ). Prior to that she wasn't even helping much with the discussions except hidjng behind that typical blanket statement of " omg how dare you suggest we lynch inactives !! ".

- Karen is literally coasting by. She's saying stuff and for some reason people are believing her ridiculous soft blue claim whatever you guys say. Literally right now the madia needs to coast to get by these lynches to be able to win and I feel like that's exactly what she's doing. She's using excuses to get by nights and saying stuff like " oh I'll let you guys know what I'm doing tonight / tomorrow " or whatever. It's not adding up at all. She just wants to stay alive but not help us find mafia as you can tell by her weird, random posts.

Also why would town want to pretend to be a Town roleblocker ? Can someone please explain that ?

 

[Geoni]

dude i'm pretty sure you've called everyone in the entire game an easy lynch besides me it's actually hilarious

Okay but you haven't been easy to lynch obviously.

 

[Heyden]

Also why would town want to pretend to be a Town roleblocker ? Can someone please explain that ?

slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip

 

[Geoni]

dad can u not split votes when lynching actually matters now

You mean mislynching?

 

[iLoveYou]

slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip

What do you mean ? That's a genuine question ? I'm not connecting the dots on that at all.

 

[Geoni]

slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip slip

How do you see this as a slip? You think it's a dumbtell of some sort?

 

[Heyden]

What do you mean ? That's a genuine question ? I'm not connecting the dots on that at all.

I'm partially kidding but you sorta just assumed Glow was town.

Also what are your thoughts on Trundle? I feel like I'm asking everyone this but w/e

 

[iLoveYou]

Lemme guess glow is town roleblocker.

It's in reference to this post, Heyden.

 

[glow]

You mean mislynching?

so you think both votes are a ML?

- - - Post Merge - - -

It's in reference to this post, Heyden.

dad thinks i am the mafian

 

[Geoni]

Ok it wasn't really genuine but I read back looking at mogyays few posts, and her only stated townreads were Jacob/Dolby/Hayden. N1 Jacob got the double vote, N2 I got the double vote, N3 you got the double vote. Initially I thought Karen replaced on D3 so I assumed Mogyay was the vote gifter cos it made a lot of sense, but then I realised Karen replaced before the end of D2 so that theory was sort of dead. And the fact she claimed non-vote gifter and bodyguard, so.

I'm back to square one with Karen basically but I don't mind a Trundle lynch

- - - Post Merge - - -

glow who do you think the 4 remaining scum are

How does that kill the theory of the vote gifting btw?

 

[Heyden]

It's in reference to this post, Heyden.

Okay but why did you assume she's town pretending to be a town roleblocker out of nowhere, I'm sort of missing the part where you got that idea from.

 

[iLoveYou]

I'm asking that question because I don't get it. Dad said even Endless tried that move. Hold on let me get the post

 

[Heyden]

How does that kill the theory of the vote gifting btw?

Karen said she wasn't gift voter or bodyguard didn't she