Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
Yeah I was hit at night. So between Dad and Amanda, without any bias, which would you rather lynch today?
Personally Amanda. I don't see her trying to defend herself or prove she isn't mafia. She's just sitting back and coasting and its getting annoying how she just posts in a polite type of way watching me and Dad go at it. Dad is using her against me too so if we can remove his side-kick that would be nice.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Honestly I would love for you guys to grill Amanda today.
- - - Post Merge - - -
By grill I mean put pressure on her by the ways.
FireNinja1
inactive: please read "about" tab on profile
What? No...
amanda1983
Senior Member
I understand I seem like the safest lynch as apparently I'm either Dad or Kayla's sidekick (which would have to be the worst role I can imagine in this game short of Punchy's tbh) but are you for real rn ( RE the vote on me)?? It's LYLO with multiple NewTown and you want to either lynch me outright or try pressuring me with a vote an hour into Day and risk players not following the nuances or keeping up with later developments thus putting us at serious risk of a ML??
Just when I was concluding remaining scum *has* to be Dad and Kayla working together because as scummy as I found much of your play, I still ultimately could not see you as actual scum, you make another scummy (from my PoV as I know my alignment) play, and Antonio and Ryumia are just not plausible Mafia for me (the latter being a complete Town-Lock now as far as I'm concerned).
Amanda thinks Dad/Kayla is scum
Kayla thinks Amanda/Dad is scum
Dad think Kayla/Amanda is scum
something isn’t adding up idk I’m starting to doubt both scum is in this triangle
- - - Post Merge - - -
also me voting you was just a rxn test, I’m probs voting Dad still anyway
- - - Post Merge - - -
Amanda, straight up, Dad or Kayla lynch?
Kayla thinks Amanda/Dad is scum
Dad think Kayla/Amanda is scum
something isn’t adding up idk I’m starting to doubt both scum is in this triangle
- - - Post Merge - - -
also me voting you was just a rxn test, I’m probs voting Dad still anyway
- - - Post Merge - - -
Amanda, straight up, Dad or Kayla lynch?
Okay you know what I've suddenly noticed? Antonio could easily be scum in this scenario.
Looking at the D1, D2 votes, literally everyone who placed a vote on him is CONFIRMED town
I realised a lot of the arguements made against him being town are literally 'everyone piled up against him' but literally not one scum, Panda, Mog, Kermit, Tom even voted him, and to add on, neither did Dad, Amanda, iLoveYou, assuming that one of them is scum.
Some Panda quotes that felt a bit weird;
Obviously I'm very inconfident about it and I definitely don't want him lynched today, preferably Dad, but I just really feel Kayla and Amanda are town ugh
- - - Post Merge - - -
not really a case, but I do find it awfully weird that the Dad Amanda Kayla triangle all passed Antonio as town too, eh
Looking at the D1, D2 votes, literally everyone who placed a vote on him is CONFIRMED town
D1
amazonevan19
glow
PunchyDaHufflepuff
Kammm
PunchyDaHufflepuff
amazonevan19
Ghostkid
FireNinja1
D2
amazonevan19
Heyden
Trundle
PunchyDaHufflepuff
FireNinja1
Ness
amazonevan19
glow
PunchyDaHufflepuff
Kammm
PunchyDaHufflepuff
amazonevan19
Ghostkid
FireNinja1
D2
amazonevan19
Heyden
Trundle
PunchyDaHufflepuff
FireNinja1
Ness
Some Panda quotes that felt a bit weird;
A very hard null, sussing someone without actually pushing them
A somewhat weird defense, she was literally fine with literally every other lynch except Antonio.
Obviously I'm very inconfident about it and I definitely don't want him lynched today, preferably Dad, but I just really feel Kayla and Amanda are town ugh
- - - Post Merge - - -
not really a case, but I do find it awfully weird that the Dad Amanda Kayla triangle all passed Antonio as town too, eh
Geoni
You're doing great!
I like how bluesniping wasn't at the front of our debate but you suddenly turn around to talk about it unsolicited as if a lot of people suspect you could be bluesniping and it really comes off as you covering your bases, especially since Evan brought bluesniping back up a few minutes before this post.
Also what you described is just bluesniping made easier. You can still organize a list of blue indicators in a qt in a no-PM game based on in-thread tells and just because you were around when tbt was mostly PM-allowed doesn't mean you're incapable of figuring out blues the harder way.
But you know what's funny? It might have not even been bluesniping on your part. Because 1) Toads hated Ness and on D1 I made a case against him, and 2) a bit later in the day, I started airing a distaste for glow based on her going after people I saw as vulnerable town and given Dedenne flipped VT and it would make her look worse if Oath flipped town-sided, you may have chosen to target who you target N1 because 3) you have aired that you think I'm a good player and saw that I might lead against either Ness or glow on day 2. Kate? ihdk.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Sorry but Kayla is poking the dragon and needs to know it.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Thanks for this glow, I understand what you were saying now.
(Post 'snipped' due to the length of my surrounding post.)
Oh my goodness Ryumia - you are such a sincerely kind, sweet, and thoughtful human being. I'm a little in awe at how ~pure~ and self-reflective and self-aware you are. I am so sorry to hear your health has been so impacted by this game, and I think you have made the right decision in the circumstances - no game is worth compromising your health for, ever.
Thank you so much for taking the time and effort to answer so thoughtfully, honestly, and comprehensively. I can see why you made the choices you did now, you were understandably confused and paranoid about what was going on around you as a result of us interpreting your words as a possible/likely/definite Blue soft-claim. Please don't be so hard on yourself, you did nothing wrong at all in the circumstances. As Vanessa said, you're not responsible at all for anyone dying, and we can all see you've been doing your best to help us.
If you ever talk to me like this I will fight you 1v1.
- - - Post Merge - - -
How was I trying to frame you? Honestly I'm pretty sure that Ness was saying he was going to give me an extra vote as a way to see if he'd be targeted over it instead of Vanessa but I think Vanessa can now confirm whether or not she was on herself N4 or on Ness N4, because if she can't protect herself and protect the same person two nights in a row, I think Ness might have been targeted. Plus he says he was saved in thread so he might also have PM confirmation.
Of course your first reaction is that this was a frame.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Would love to see you break down how you think our entire debate is fabricated.
Was waiting until dad posted to say this, I wasn't targetted at night and that was exactly what I wanted to see come from him.
Dad was unfazed by my hit, Amanda didn't mention it, and iLoveYou's first reaction is to make into look like I was being framed.
Dad was unfazed by my hit, Amanda didn't mention it, and iLoveYou's first reaction is to make into look like I was being framed.
Ghostkid
the Ghostkidliest guy
ness my boi u are the man.
*Correction, iLoveYou's first reaction is to make it look like my hit would be for framing dad
- - - Post Merge - - -
And just saying what sense would it make to target me when I literally have a BODYGUARD who would just take the hit for me
Kayla +1 scum points
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
woo thanks for the double vote Ness, I hope to use those votes well
I'm down for an Amanda or Dad lynch rn but let's talk it out
I'm down for an Amanda or Dad lynch rn but let's talk it out
Ness, if you were on my end of things what exactly would you think ? You said you got hit. You took Dad's side. There's 2 mafia left in a group of 3. Possible framing. I don't see why you're looking so much into that as a scum tell. Why would you even lie about getting hit when the mafia would know you didn't get hit so they would know how to play it off ?
Yes, The only possible idea that crossed my mind is because someone would try to frame me. Call me simple-minded but yes that was my initial reaction.
Also, you said what sense would it make due to your bodyguard ? What reason would I have to doubt you were hit if you said you were hit again. Regardless of whatever roles are in this game.
Yes, The only possible idea that crossed my mind is because someone would try to frame me. Call me simple-minded but yes that was my initial reaction.
Also, you said what sense would it make due to your bodyguard ? What reason would I have to doubt you were hit if you said you were hit again. Regardless of whatever roles are in this game.
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
oh hot damn son
- - - Post Merge - - -
what in the actual **** does this even mean Kayla? We know for a fact that I should have been hit if they went after Ness. The thought didn't cross your mind to question it, but instead try to spin it to your advantage, fully knowing that I should have died or been hit instead?
- - - Post Merge - - -
yes
someone's not paying attention
What about the doctor Evan ?
