Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!
- Thread starter Chris
- Start date
amazonevan19
DLELELEWOOOOP
oh guess I can't split my vote
hmmm
hmmm
His vote counted as two votes. But he has free will to change his vote anytime up until the end of day, just like everyone else.
Last edited:
Okay. Thanks, Tina. ^.^
1) You're going pretty hard on this 'plant a seed of doubt' thing because like I said, you are one of the most inconvenient people to save all the way to the end, especially when I'd have killed Jacob over you when he died. Not only that, but in the first few hours of the game? Lol. And again, I can explain that it was done so early because it was done for the sake of reverse psychology. Or, if anything, an easy stance for Tom to fall on that people wouldn't necessarily blame you for. Because indeed that's too obvious. But then again so is Kermit voting for you and then somehow dying during the night.
And good god you're over-explaining Mafia II here. I more or less repeat that you're fully capable of reverse psychology and bussing and that explains it. Of course you're pushing the narrative that it's because you'd already lost your teammate in that game but with Tom you most certainly hadn't, but my point is that Tom isn't exactly the most confident mafia player and hasn't played in a while, so I can see him just being like 'I know I'm not gonna last long in this game'.
2) I'm not buying that excuse for the self-voting at all lmao, especially because I don't see how you would buy into that paranoia either. But on the no lynch vote, fair, and I had the same view of the No Lynch being the safe track, but it's still something that looks pro-town. The scummier thing here is your self vote though because it's coming off as overly safe.
3) "How could we know it and plan it out that blues would claim" IS VERY RELEVANT IF YOU ARE GOING TO ARGUE THAT YOU HAVE BEEN SET UP FOR THIS SINCE THE BEGINNING OF THE GAME. Not set up to be lynched, set up to be in this pool. Yes, anything that looks bad on you can be seen as a 'seed of doubt' but when you try and say they were all planned out you discount that there were way more people in this game that looked like better targets for 'seeding' and prepping for endgame than you and you were near-universally townread the first two days of the game in the least, and mostly townread up until D5.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Like I said I'd be down to lynch Amanda as well, but after this argument, I feel much more sure about Kayla. And this is much different than how I felt about you, as tunnely as it seems, because it's much more PoE at this point in the game.
Dad for the sake of not another wallpost war I'll answer briefly.
I do have a question for you which you may have answered but I can't recall and you have many posts: Why do you think Kermits was killed at night ? At that moment it seemed obvious the mafia did not want us to have extra days of discussion when it was obvious Kermits would get lynched. What was your opinion of that moment ?
I don't remember Tom as being under confident as a player for the mafia team. With out-of-thread communication, he used to play very hard actually ( even as mafia ) and I was expecting that when I came into this game as well.
I am not familiar with many of these new roles that have been spoken about throughout the game thus far. Why wouldn't I believe the roleclaims people have done ? What basis do I have to go on to say a role like that would never exist ?
Dad you're fighting to argue that I said I was being set up from the beginning to be in the sus pool but that's not what I was saying at all. I said those seeds of doubts would work regardless of the state of the game towards the end. Who would have been a better target to plant a seed of doubt on in your opinion ?
- - - Post Merge - - -
I'm sure you guys planted seeds of doubt on other people too. I never said they were all done on me, just that there were several I can count which would make players look back and start doubting.
I do have a question for you which you may have answered but I can't recall and you have many posts: Why do you think Kermits was killed at night ? At that moment it seemed obvious the mafia did not want us to have extra days of discussion when it was obvious Kermits would get lynched. What was your opinion of that moment ?
I don't remember Tom as being under confident as a player for the mafia team. With out-of-thread communication, he used to play very hard actually ( even as mafia ) and I was expecting that when I came into this game as well.
I am not familiar with many of these new roles that have been spoken about throughout the game thus far. Why wouldn't I believe the roleclaims people have done ? What basis do I have to go on to say a role like that would never exist ?
Dad you're fighting to argue that I said I was being set up from the beginning to be in the sus pool but that's not what I was saying at all. I said those seeds of doubts would work regardless of the state of the game towards the end. Who would have been a better target to plant a seed of doubt on in your opinion ?
- - - Post Merge - - -
I'm sure you guys planted seeds of doubt on other people too. I never said they were all done on me, just that there were several I can count which would make players look back and start doubting.
Im assuming that was out of anger? XD
See though thats the thing, I just genuinely feel like that has been her entire shield this game. She never developed anything leading up to the Tom lynch, she just sort of started shouting "Lynch Tom!" and has been saying that the entire game to anyone who feels suspicious of her
and Panda was a needed role, she had to survive to Day 3 in order for the ability to work. What are the mafia roles again I forgot
- - - Post Merge - - -
but then again I have a very hard time seeing her develop the Punchy vote first/last plan as mafia....
maybe I'm just overthinking this
- - - Post Merge - - -
tbh I think it is dad but I have very hard time seeing it as him at the same time
- - - Post Merge - - -
if dad flips town i can't wait to say in the endgame "ZOMG I WAS RIGHT ABOUT KAYLA!"
I did make posts about Tom on Day One.
There were probably more too but they need to be found.
There were probably more too but they need to be found.
Essentially what looked even worse was that he came to post around EoD, then voted himself to appear neutral as I pointed out here:
