Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

Okay, first of all Trundle is way too quiet for Day Two. I know for a fact he is usually pretty vocal throughout these games. Also he said he would put up a post on Day Two so I really want to see that, hopefully before the day ends. At this point he definitely looks like he's "hiding" behind Dolby. He is coasting right now and I don't think that's a good thing. I am hoping that we get Tom lynched though because, personally for me, he is my biggest scum lean right now. I honestly find it weird that no one is bringing Trundle up though ?


So. Oath is an interesting kill in that I think it was for one of these two reasons:

1) Dolby the bluesniper

2) Mafia wants to bring attention to me vs glow and glow vs Oath. My concern with Oath's kill over somebody like Dolby/myself/glow/Ness is that one of us will lead wrongly based on the choice. This could be mafia glow making herself seem less scummy because why would she kill somebody she scumread to flip them as important? This could be another crafty player on the mafia team in a game where both myself and glow aren't mafia leaving me alive to rail against glow, especially given another leading type like Dolby also has aired that he finds glow sus.

In response to your points:

1. Is he known to be a blue sniper ? You and Jacob seem to share that opinion.

2. That's a good point that the mafia could have kept you and Glow in the game due to your heated debate. Personally I don't see how the names you mentioned are leading this game because none of you stepped up to organize the vote on Day One, which I want to mention is very weird that you all stayed quiet during the last few voting hours. Honestly I feel like your argument with Glow might be made up mainly because I don't lean that much towards Town on you. My stance on Glow is very shaky right now too. The reason being is that I find a lot of your posts were mainly just recaps of what happened which I think can be considered filler posts. But don't get me wrong, I find Glow hard to read into too. This is a reason why I refrained from commenting on your argument with her: I just can't side with either of you. So in that regard I do find it weird that Dolby is siding with you. I can't tell if Glow is just an easy target for you two or if she is actually seen as mafia by you two. I'm nervous that any of you three might flip mafia / red. How come no one else is so against Glow as you two are ?? I just don't get it ? I'm starting to think I'm really bad at this game because I'm not getting the same reads as you guys are able to post.

The thing I don't like about how Dolby has aired some sus of glow is that he hasn't really talked about it much. He just continues to say 'I side with Dad more on this situation and that is why I also townread Dad'. For one, this can be buddying. And two, this is him stepping back to let me do the work on a mislynch without actually rationalizing why he agrees with my reads. I have gone over a lot of different points regarding glow and there is a lot to agree and disagree with when it comes to that and I just don't see Dolby as the type to agree with all of it.

I agree with you that Dolby getting on Glow's case is pretty "random" ( for lack of a better word ) and that I never fully understood why he sided with you over Glow. Wasn't he just on Locket's case ? I don't get the switch, or if he still thinks Locket is mafia or what ? I actually agree with you that if Glow flips Town, you will be a number one mafia suspect. So if Dolby is supporting you and she flips Town, you would get the heat in my opinion and not Dokby as much.



Buuut if glow is mafia and Kayla is playing a crafty return to mafia, this could be some soft defending but idk. Because if glow is scum I kinda see Tom as a potential partner but this also doesn't seem like a Kayla and Tom team so the alignments wonky

To me it's just pretty obvious that a mafia wouldn't kill their own suspicions to reveal them as Town. It brings heat onto them immediately. Should Glow end up being mafia, I think that's a pretty amazing risk she tried to do because she would be risking getting lynched right away ? I don't know.
 
Antonio & N e s s while you're still here, who are you voting for ? Leaning towards anyone ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

RuneReyedah you too.

- - - Post Merge - - -

LYNCH TOM DAY TWO let's go fam please let's not let him live another day. We might not even have any more Vigilantes who can do the job for us.
 
Yeah sorry I'm at work. I promise I'll get my share of posts in before EOD, but I have a date with my girl tonight.
 
Antonio & N e s s while you're still here, who are you voting for ? Leaning towards anyone ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

RuneReyedah you too.

- - - Post Merge - - -

LYNCH TOM DAY TWO let's go fam please let's not let him live another day. We might not even have any more Vigilantes who can do the job for us.

Cannot adequately answer this right now since I haven't analyzed any other payers than glow and kinda ryumia, so when I get home I'll try and do that ASAP
 
guys i had a dream Tom flipped third party and then it made sense why he had no self preservation
 
Yeah you need to explain that quote of yours I messed up Dolby because I don't see how Evan townslipped there and you haven't explained it.

Speaking of which I need to read Evan's wall of what will probably be defense but I have a headache. I admittedly skipped it because it seemed like a task but I can already say...that's a long post for defending. Granted, he had a long post thrown at him.

But yeah if it isn't obvious, Dolby is no longer a townlock for me like his D1 play could have potentially fooled me into.

Yeah. Personally, I felt that scum Evan wouldn't actually look back into prior games and bring up anything that would destroy his case against a townie (Evan/Ryu are def not a team). Should've said town indicative, but it was during track practice and I wanted to be quick because I knew that I wasn't going to post again that cycle and I was afraid of dying last night

1. Is he known to be a blue sniper ? You and Jacob seem to share that opinion.
I was known even back in the old days when you were still playing

I agree with you that Dolby getting on Glow's case is pretty "random" ( for lack of a better word ) and that I never fully understood why he sided with you over Glow. Wasn't he just on Locket's case ? I don't get the switch, or if he still thinks Locket is mafia or what ? I actually agree with you that if Glow flips Town, you will be a number one mafia suspect. So if Dolby is supporting you and she flips Town, you would get the heat in my opinion and not Dokby as much.
Getting on Glow's case there and then was purely because Glow was in the thread at the time and Locket wasn't. This gave me a chance to actually interact with Glow, and I still remain more sus of Locket, as her play is distinctly weaker than even her worst game as a townie right now.

I probably have taken for granted the need to explain why I'm sus of Glow and siding with Dad in the argument, because I've kinda taken for granted that it should be obvious. A straight and abrupt lack of any sort of content first

it's ok Kam ur honestly obv town

did someone sus u? i will devour them
Like, this is honestly her second or third best post

Glow is always sort of sarcastic, but she's been acting downright petulant to Dad in her tunnel of him, and has barely even considered anyone else. She's had only one good post this game, breaking down why she townreads Toads for his interaction with Ness. She has a really large ratio of fluff:content which is kind of uncharacteristic. Even when she was tunneling Dad LAST game, she at least gave reads on other players. Unlike now

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also, ftr, I was on Glow's side in the very beginning, right after Dad made that big post that was basically a recap

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also gonna respond to Iloveyou's vote question, probably Locket or Tom. I somewhat want to leave Glow around on the chance that she steps it up
 
Well one thing I am noticing more and more about Glow is that her posts are appearing way too "comfortable " like she has nothing to worry about in terms of her position in this game. I feel like her jokes & sarcasm are a reflection of that too. It's just hard to read for me personally.
 
gonna catch up; if tom hasn't posted anything by now I'll probably vote for him. He's had his time to put up something substantial and if he hasn't by now, that's a really bad sign.

course if he has, I'll evaluate it and go on from there

- - - Post Merge - - -

Well one thing I am noticing more and more about Glow is that her posts are appearing way too "comfortable " like she has nothing to worry about in terms of her position in this game. I feel like her jokes & sarcasm are a reflection of that too. It's just hard to read for me personally.

Perhaps it's because she knows that dad is the only one who really suspects her? I put her as a SL initially too for her posts lacking content, but in my view she has been doing a little bit better as of late. idk gotta reevaluate things

Glow is always sort of sarcastic, but she's been acting downright petulant to Dad in her tunnel of him, and has barely even considered anyone else. She's had only one good post this game, breaking down why she townreads Toads for his interaction with Ness. She has a really large ratio of fluff:content which is kind of uncharacteristic. Even when she was tunneling Dad LAST game, she at least gave reads on other players. Unlike now

And wasn't she lyncher last game? Maybe her lack of content here and dad tunnelling shows she's TP again...idk

- - - Post Merge - - -

ok yeah, voting Tom, this is unacceptable behavior from him, I'm sure we'll get a waterfall of excuses later on but sorry m8 you've had your chance
 
I'm ok with a mog lynch, but I want to hear from a lot of the lurkers/inactives (Tom and Giga in particular) before making a final decision.

>says he wants to Lynch Antonio
>Scumreads Mog
>suddenly, Tom vote

:eyes::eyes::eyes:

- - - Post Merge - - -

Tom hasn't posted anything since N1 either and you said you wanted to hear more from Tom before making any final decisions...we have over 36 hours remaining atleast give it until tonight...Evan you're seriously all over the place right now

- - - Post Merge - - -

Like, yeah. I get it Tom is strange but this is jumping on a man who isn't around to defend himself
 
And wasn't she lyncher last game? Maybe her lack of content here and dad tunnelling shows she's TP again...idk
I was refering to APM. Tunneling was a strong word for that, but she was pretty focused on Dad the whole time
 
Perhaps it's because she knows that dad is the only one who really suspects her? I put her as a SL initially too for her posts lacking content, but in my view she has been doing a little bit better as of late. idk gotta reevaluate things

But it's not just Dad anymore. Now it's Dolby too. On top of that the majority of people are leaning Town on Dolby.
 
Back
Top