Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[iLoveYou]

i mean, i knew he was mafia or blue so if i was mafia and he wasn't on my team i would def kill him lmao

I don't get it. Why do you keep saying you knew he was blue ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

So you "knew" he was blue and you're saying if you were mafia you would definitely kill him ? He died last night ...

 

[glow]

I don't get it. Why do you keep saying you knew he was blue ?

- - - Post Merge - - -

So you "knew" he was blue and you're saying if you were mafia you would definitely kill him ? He died last night ...

yeah, i feel like blues act way different than regular townies, and i read a lot of the behavior patterns as similar to mafia

i didn't think he was blue, i thought he was mafia. but if i was mafia i'd think he was blue. imo i think oath was blue-read by an experienced player. it's definitely a strange kill from a new player perspective. (1) of dolby, dad, tom would be my go-tos for that sort of kill BUT i've decided to spare myself from the pain of reading in those 3

 

[N e s s]

but i did say that i forgot to vote, i'm not sure what you're trying to say

Sure, you did say you forgot to vote, but immediately back it up as a reason to say "i'm not scummy for that". Anyone can forget to vote and say that it was purely an accident, forgetting to vote isn't usually AI anyway but you used it as a plug to say "i wouldn't do that as mafia".

I re-read both the sign-ups thread and the current OP and I didn't see anything that related to Voting rules, so I may or may not be missing something here, would like to see a direct quote from you because I really don't see it. I've read the rules atleast 5 times now so if you're telling the truth here I must be blind.

You can't tell me you thought "ugh can we lynch dedenne now" when you had been saying for a day you thought dedenne was suspicious and yet you provided at most like, 1 paragraph and 2 one liners as to why she was scummy? You had been saying that you thought oath and dad were suspicious as well, whats the point in saying you're suspicious of only like 3 people when you're not going to make an active push on any of the 3? You could have even pushed people to lynch Dad, yet you decided not to by saying "aw sad ppl don't want to lynch scummy dad ;,("

 

[Dolby]

Ftr, I have indepedently verified that a "vote every day" rule is in one of the spoilers of the OP (It falls under the activity section I think)

- - - Post Merge - - -

@Ryumia, who do you think is maf? If it's easier for you, then who do you think is town?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Personally, I'm pretty confident that there's multiple scum in Tom/Glow/Locket

- - - Post Merge - - -

Patiently waiting for some sort of response from Ryumia

 

[iLoveYou]

For just Day Two, it is very quiet in here.

 

[Ryumia]

@Ryumia, who do you think is maf? If it's easier for you, then who do you think is town?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Personally, I'm pretty confident that there's multiple scum in Tom/Glow/Locket

Who I think is town at the moment would be: Ness and Runeraider.

 

[illunie]

dont want to take any heat away from glow but @dolby: firstly can u explain why u think kayla (ily) is town without using her policy lynch on inactives on d1? i feel like i mustve missed smth (i probably did) but all ive seen u say is that she wouldve backed down if she was maf.

secondly whats the distinction between trundle and tom in ur mind? i feel like theyre acting very similarly in their posts

- - - Post Merge - - -

that formatting was awful but we

- - - Post Merge - - -

Who I think is town at the moment would be: Ness and Runeraider.

any reasoning behind them?

 

[Ryumia]

any reasoning behind them?

There is. But... It's not complete.

 

[Dolby]

dont want to take any heat away from glow but @dolby: firstly can u explain why u think kayla (ily) is town without using her policy lynch on inactives on d1? i feel like i mustve missed smth (i probably did) but all ive seen u say is that she wouldve backed down if she was maf.

secondly whats the distinction between trundle and tom in ur mind? i feel like theyre acting very similarly in their posts

- - - Post Merge - - -

that formatting was awful but we

- - - Post Merge - - -



any reasoning behind them?

1. Reacted the right way to the bw on Antonio I feel (though it is kinda confirmation bias and I am doubting his alignment now), and she has provided good content. Basically, I feel that she's done all the right things to be deserving of a townlean. The only thing that I actively dislike about her is putting her vote behind a lynch that I feel obviously wasn't going to happen

2. Tom's far past the point where he should have provided general reads and content in any form. Trundle at least has provided some stuff and his content so far has been borderline unacceptable

- - - Post Merge - - -

*been only

 

[illunie]

1. Reacted the right way to the bw on Antonio I feel (though it is kinda confirmation bias and I am doubting his alignment now), and she has provided good content. Basically, I feel that she's done all the right things to be deserving of a townlean. The only thing that I actively dislike about her is putting her vote behind a lynch that I feel obviously wasn't going to happen

2. Tom's far past the point where he should have provided general reads and content in any form. Trundle at least has provided some stuff and his content so far has been borderline unacceptable

- - - Post Merge - - -

*been only

ok, thanks for the clarification. im just kinda terrified of a you/kayla/dad/glow or we scum team rn, no matter how unlucky that would be

 

[N e s s]

Going to bed now, I'll look into other people tomorrow, I feel conflicted about glow and I want to see more content from her because I think there really is something that coulda be looked into with her.

 

[glow]

ok, thanks for the clarification. im just kinda terrified of a you/kayla/dad/glow or we scum team rn, no matter how unlucky that would be

that read doesn't even make sense if you have read any of the interactions between me/dad or me/dolby

- - - Post Merge - - -

dolby/dad don't interact at all tho

 

[Dolby]

that read doesn't even make sense if you have read any of the interactions between me/dad or me/dolby

- - - Post Merge - - -

dolby/dad don't interact at all tho

I’m pretty sure that he meant that he’s paranoid of us being scum, not that we’re all of the same team

 

[Chris]

if you're scumreading her then why are you just "okay" with her lynch? I don't understand what prompted you to suddenly be scumreading her when I don't think I've seen you mention her much at all

i'm not saying that I'm suspicious of you, either, i just genuinely don't understand where this mog scumread came from

- - - Post Merge - - -

Tina could you possibly update the OP to show which players are dead, it's weird to be looking at it and have to sort out who is dead and alive.

Smh Tina add post links please that would make my life 100x easier

As stated in the Day Two post, these things won't been added until later today. I've a 5pm deadline for a lab report.

 

[Geoni]

Kinda think that #787 was a townslip from Evan honestly
/QUOTE]

Haven't caught up yet but I hope you have explained this.

- - - Post Merge - - -

soz if i accidentally made u obv blue oath

I don't see how you can take credit for this but okay.

- - - Post Merge - - -

anyone that knew that oath wasn't scum would know that oath was pr

No. Oath is just like how he was in general. Quiet on day one and sometimes even day two. Out of him and Tom I scumead Tom, but I didn't townread him so surely yet either. His quietness = / = pr.

- - - Post Merge - - -

bruh if i was scum why would i risk getting modkilled

Explain why you didn't vote. iirc you haven't yet.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If Glow were mafia, then why would she target her own suspicions to reveal them as Town ? Wouldn't she then be exposing herself ? I'm sorry but Tom needs to get lynched. He conveniently came around yesterday to post and place a vote on himself. Now ALREADY he has stopped posting again. He dropped by the thread for the night post and now he's gone again.

So. Oath is an interesting kill in that I think it was for one of these two reasons:

1) Dolby the bluesniper

2) Mafia wants to bring attention to me vs glow and glow vs Oath. My concern with Oath's kill over somebody like Dolby/myself/glow/Ness is that one of us will lead wrongly based on the choice. This could be mafia glow making herself seem less scummy because why would she kill somebody she scumread to flip them as important? This could be another crafty player on the mafia team in a game where both myself and glow aren't mafia leaving me alive to rail against glow, especially given another leading type like Dolby also has aired that he finds glow sus.

The thing I don't like about how Dolby has aired some sus of glow is that he hasn't really talked about it much. He just continues to say 'I side with Dad more on this situation and that is why I also townread Dad'. For one, this can be buddying. And two, this is him stepping back to let me do the work on a mislynch without actually rationalizing why he agrees with my reads. I have gone over a lot of different points regarding glow and there is a lot to agree and disagree with when it comes to that and I just don't see Dolby as the type to agree with all of it.

Also Dolby can fit into either of these scenarios.

Buuut if glow is mafia and Kayla is playing a crafty return to mafia, this could be some soft defending but idk. Because if glow is scum I kinda see Tom as a potential partner but this also doesn't seem like a Kayla and Tom team so the alignments here are wonky.

Anyways I still haven't caught up in the last two pages but I wanted to immediately respond to this.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Yeah you need to explain that quote of yours I messed up Dolby because I don't see how Evan townslipped there and you haven't explained it.

Speaking of which I need to read Evan's wall of what will probably be defense but I have a headache. I admittedly skipped it because it seemed like a task but I can already say...that's a long post for defending. Granted, he had a long post thrown at him.

But yeah if it isn't obvious, Dolby is no longer a townlock for me like his D1 play could have potentially fooled me into.

 

[PandaDarling]

im here, its late im gonna try to read up, its been a long 2 days.

 

[Antonio]

I need to catch up aswell, what do people with blue roles mean?

 

[illunie]

I need to catch up aswell, what do people with blue roles mean?

a blue role is basically just a town member with a special ability. both toad and oath were blue roles, but kate wasnt bc she didnt have any abilities which differed from an average townie

 

[N e s s]

I need to catch up aswell, what do people with blue roles mean?

Lol nice one

 

[Antonio]

a blue role is basically just a town member with a special ability. both toad and oath were blue roles, but kate wasnt bc she didnt have any abilities which differed from an average townie

Thanks c:

- - - Post Merge - - -

Lol nice one

??