Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

~ts too hard to edit quotes for me to pretend the second part of kaylas post is here~

dw too much about the first bit, it was more of an observational joke than anything. tho apparently u felt the need to defend urself against it sooo
also u didnt reply to the bit about trundle, why would he try and be buddy buddy with dolby if hes on the same team as him? wouldnt it be better to do what u said and distance himself from dolby to not arrouse suspicion?

Trundle was trying to be buddy / buddy with Dolby only on Day One correct ? That might have been so he does not have to get called out by Dolby who was deemed leaning Town so he can coast right through without us thinking anything of it. Today is Day Two and he is literally not commenting on anything up to now, which actually can be seen as distancing himself.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Trundle on Day One with Dolby, is not the same as Trundle on Day Two with Dolby. If Dolby flips red I don't think that is a coincidence.

- - - Post Merge - - -

On that note I am actually very curious to see who Trundle will vote for today.
 
iLoveYou said:
Oh by the way, if Dolby flips red then i believe Trundle is red too due to what I have been saying ( Trundle hiding behind Dolby & clearing him as confirmed Town on day One for some reason ).
Sorry if this was addressed already but do you really think Trundle would be that obvious about a teammate? He was literally like 'I'm surprised Dolby isn't townreading me yet." I don't really get why he would say that if they were teammates

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh yup that was addressed already

- - - Post Merge - - -

Now I'm gonna be accused of "copying" rune aren't I
 
Trundle was trying to be buddy / buddy with Dolby only on Day One correct ? That might have been so he does not have to get called out by Dolby who was deemed leaning Town so he can coast right through without us thinking anything of it. Today is Day Two and he is literally not commenting on anything up to now, which actually can be seen as distancing himself.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Trundle on Day One with Dolby, is not the same as Trundle on Day Two with Dolby. If Dolby flips red I don't think that is a coincidence.

- - - Post Merge - - -

On that note I am actually very curious to see who Trundle will vote for today.

if he really was teamed with dolby i dont kniw if he would be that blatant in trying to buddy up with him. i feel like theyed just tr each other and leave it at that, idk if he would post smth like the 'i cant believe dolby hasnt tr me yet' thing.

but i could definitely see him being maf just by himself tho, hes been coasting a lot this game

- - - Post Merge - - -

Sorry if this was addressed already but do you really think Trundle would be that obvious about a teammate? He was literally like 'I'm surprised Dolby isn't townreading me yet." I don't really get why he would say that if they were teammates

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh yup that was addressed already

- - - Post Merge - - -

Now I'm gonna be accused of "copying" rune aren't I[/QUOTE

stop copying me >: (]
 
Sorry if this was addressed already but do you really think Trundle would be that obvious about a teammate? He was literally like 'I'm surprised Dolby isn't townreading me yet." I don't really get why he would say that if they were teammates

Ya I do think he would consider being that obvious given how Dolby was being portrayed as leaning Town by a large number of players. I don't think he would have expected a Dolby lynch Day Two and is panicking now. Should they both be red.

- - - Post Merge - - -

but i could definitely see him being maf just by himself tho, hes been coasting a lot this game

I agree with you there. He is amongst the players I consider as suspicious.
 
i feel like if there really were 5 to 6 scum members i would have a lot more scum reads than just 2 or 3, there must be smth weird going on in the setup, tho its pretty hard to speculate on it

The issue is you guys are assuming all the mafia exist in the top 5-6 active players. Of course you're not going to have more than 2-3 reads. Half the scum team is inactive which is the whole point Kayla went on and on D1 about people who go under the radar. Jeez Louise.

- - - Post Merge - - -

If people wanted to lynch me I really wouldn't mind, just throwing that out there.

I still think Dolby is town. I'm gonna post full reads list shortly but I need to shower real quick.
 
The issue is you guys are assuming all the mafia exist in the top 5-6 active players. Of course you're not going to have more than 2-3 reads. Half the scum team is inactive which is the whole point Kayla went on and on D1 about people who go under the radar. Jeez Louise.

ik that and i even said that its hard to speculate on what the setuo could be without much info to go on. im just saying the setup could be anything based on its experimental nature
 
Going to bed cos it’s pretty late, I’m totally knocked out but hopefully I wake up in time for EoD. I’d rather stick a Tom lynch rn and I don’t think anything will change it unless he’s a possible blue.

Also remember to vote if you didn’t yesterday or you’ll be modkilled.
On that note, Tina if it’s possible can we replace Giglabish pls cos I don’t think they’ll emerge any time soon, and even if they did their play is very disappointing.

Ok gnight.
 
Barebones Reads based on how each person has posted so far this game. Grey means not enough content for me to read properly.

Vanessa
PunchyDaHufflepuff
Trundle
Runeraider
Kammm
Tom
Dolby
N e s s
Ghostkid
Heyden
amazonevan19
Ryumia
Antonio
iLoveYou
mogyay
PandaDarling
Gigalabesh
Jacob
Dad
FireNinja1
glow

Please just ask questions based on my reads rather than making me type out my every thought. Also, fun fact, this is one of my least confident reads lists ever. I think a lot of the mafia are coasting.
 
Barebones Reads based on how each person has posted so far this game. Grey means not enough content for me to read properly.

Vanessa
PunchyDaHufflepuff
Trundle
Runeraider
Kammm
Tom
Dolby
N e s s
Ghostkid
Heyden
amazonevan19
Ryumia
Antonio
iLoveYou
mogyay
PandaDarling
Gigalabesh
Jacob
Dad
FireNinja1
glow

Please just ask questions based on my reads rather than making me type out my every thought. Also, fun fact, this is one of my least confident reads lists ever. I think a lot of the mafia are coasting.

why dont u have a strong opinion on antonio? do u not think his 'scumslip' about blue roles was ai?
 
Barebones Reads based on how each person has posted so far this game. Grey means not enough content for me to read properly.

Vanessa
PunchyDaHufflepuff
Trundle
Runeraider
Kammm
Tom
Dolby
N e s s
Ghostkid
Heyden
amazonevan19
Ryumia
Antonio
iLoveYou
mogyay
PandaDarling
Gigalabesh
Jacob
Dad
FireNinja1
glow

Please just ask questions based on my reads rather than making me type out my every thought. Also, fun fact, this is one of my least confident reads lists ever. I think a lot of the mafia are coasting.

Wait what does orange mean ?
 
I thought you said the mafia team is full of inactives ? Wouldn't you be putting Antonio, mogyay, PandaDarling and that Gigablesh person as orange ?
 
Coloring the player list and then asking us to ask you for your reads is not activity, but I'll go ahead and entertain that, why an orange on me?
 
Back
Top