Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[Geoni]

Because I still haven't read the thread since end of D1 lol (other than the last like 10 pages)

Oh that explains a lot. Some of us learned to use a coloring book before we learned to read.

- - - Post Merge - - -

So the issue that I'm having with Dolby rn as I read and wait for the sleeping pills to kick in is that he has been jumping around in focus a lot but then again so have I, and it's a quality of uncertainty. But there's another thing I'm about to be a hypocrite about: he stuck to voting on a person who nobody was on board with, but so did I, but the difference here is that he didn't really lead when he could have. Personally I would have tried harder with glow had I been on the same schedule as everyone else, but unfortunately I had to sleep and work, but Dolby seemed like he was at least around enough to switch votes. In past games, he's done that when he's town, and it's not uncommon to see him compromise his focus to voting on the scummiest of the popular candidates.

Also he seems to love to list off his townreads more than his scumreads in this game and explain them away rather than drive focus towards his reads, but he also works by process of elimination from what I have noticed, and it's how he bluesnipes as well alongside looking out for other indicators.

Goddamnit he's hard to read. I'm torn between glow/Dolby/Tom because they're the most sus for me atm but a lot of people need to step up when it comes to providing reads. TOM, Panda, Mog, FireNinja, Punchy, Giga. I think Tom is plenty scummy but won't give as much information as the first two would. Clock my joke about policy lynching him and Tom earlier and now a lot of people want to effectively policy lynch Tom.

 

[illunie]

ok im gonna go to bed, voting dolby for now in case i dont wake up before eod, hopefully ill be able to check the tread before then

 

[Kamzitty]

Just woke up and am skimming through the pages from last night.
I'm retracting my vote on ryumia because she finally posted something that could contribute towards town(her reads). I asked her for reads earlier as a test to see if she'd refuse (since she was refusing to do p much everything we asked of her) and if she wouldn't do that either, I felt like that would be a dead scum giveaway.
Now I think I'm leaning more towards a Tom or Antonio lynch,but I need to look into the whole Dolby thing. I find it slightly odd he's being sussed all of a sudden but I'll see what you guys have said.

 

[cornimer]

PunchyDaHufflepuff - I'm only a little concern only because he was telling me that there was a "messenger role". He brought up something like: "Did the messenger post a message yet?".

Oh I forgot to say that this is actually a decent point. Idk when I first saw Punchy say this I immediately wondered if it could be a scum slip and there's a scum messenger that hasn't been using their powers. However I don't think it's very likely and I wouldn't legit sus him over it, but just a thought I had. I still think Punchy is most likely town (although he has started to become a little more quiet)

- - - Post Merge - - -

Barebones Reads based on how each person has posted so far this game. Grey means not enough content for me to read properly.

Vanessa
PunchyDaHufflepuff
Trundle
Runeraider
Kammm
Tom
Dolby
N e s s
Ghostkid
Heyden
amazonevan19
Ryumia
Antonio
iLoveYou
mogyay
PandaDarling
Gigalabesh
Jacob
Dad
FireNinja1
glow

Please just ask questions based on my reads rather than making me type out my every thought. Also, fun fact, this is one of my least confident reads lists ever. I think a lot of the mafia are coasting.

If anything I'd like to know your reasoning for Ness and Dad susses

 

[EpicGamer12]

I thought you said the mafia team is full of inactives ? Wouldn't you be putting Antonio, mogyay, PandaDarling and that Gigablesh person as orange ?

I don't wanna scum lean people that could still be town due to their inactivity but neutral would mean I think there are a few scum in there, I just don't have the information available to determine who actually would be scum.

- - - Post Merge - - -

ligjt scum read most likely

- - - Post Merge - - -

oof

- - - Post Merge - - -

also whats ur reasoning behind ur reads on ghostkid?

Ghostkid is either noob town or scum. If you read back to Weeaboo mafia and other games around that where people like Beary509, Blu Rose, and Jawile played, you'll see that I lynched a lot of noob town by mistake and honestly I have a hard time telling the difference. I never push players like Ghostkid for lynch anymore because my reads on them are never reliable but if other people push I am happy to join.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Coloring the player list and then asking us to ask you for your reads is not activity, but I'll go ahead and entertain that, why an orange on me?

I'll get back to this later

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh I forgot to say that this is actually a decent point. Idk when I first saw Punchy say this I immediately wondered if it could be a scum slip and there's a scum messenger that hasn't been using their powers. However I don't think it's very likely and I wouldn't legit sus him over it, but just a thought I had. I still think Punchy is most likely town (although he has started to become a little more quiet)

- - - Post Merge - - -



If anything I'd like to know your reasoning for Ness and Dad susses

Ness I believe, if he was scum, would fearkill toadsworthy based on the argument they had earlier in the game. I honestly have no idea how toadsworthy got bluesniped. I thought he was a super obvious town but didn't see any reason he should be killed.
I don't think Dolby is mafia so who else would kill him and why? Also for whatever reason Ness has a super mixed focus this game. For the first bit of the game he was incredibly focused on his argument with toadsworthy, over-exaggerated a blow-up response and then after that just dropped it. Next time we really properly hear from Ness, toadsworthy is dead. Ever since he had just been re-iterating points on Dolby and Tom that everyone else has made. He, in my opinion, is coasting and doing a better job at it.

 

[FireNinja1]

I'll be reading the thread later today: I will not be on for EoD.

 

[iLoveYou]

Punchy, FireNinja1, Tom, Mog, Panda, Giflabesh, Ryumia, Antonio, Glow .. who are you guys voting for ? Discuss. Am I missing anyone ?

 

[cornimer]

Does anyone else think Dolby's post against me looks like a panicked OMGUS
Like I'll admit, my reads were rushed and not backed up properly. Nor will I ever back them up properly, because if I had time to do that I would've joined as a regular player and not a replacement. But idk it just feels a bit desperate?

- - - Post Merge - - -

And @Trundle thats fair reasoning, in my opinion toadsworthy kill seems more like someone trying to frame Ness tho

 

[Dolby]

Small thing before I go and do some stuff, but I’ve been seeing that my lack of activity at EoD and me “lurking” is being used as a point against me. At about 3 PM (2 hours before EoD1) I was at a track meet and I simply stopped viewing the thread from there. Prob could have compromised on someone tbh, but I think my options were Ryu and Antonio? Regardless, Antonio was clearly in the lead and the biggest counterwagon at the time I remember only had one vote on it

Also, I saw people citing that scum would want Tom to post more
...
Literally look at his profile page, he hasn’t been online in about a day. That’s why he’s inactive at this moment, he just isn’t here

 

[glow]

Punchy, FireNinja1, Tom, Mog, Panda, Giflabesh, Ryumia, Antonio, Glow .. who are you guys voting for ? Discuss. Am I missing anyone ?

i think if you want the best chance at lowering KP we should lynch mog

- - - Post Merge - - -

Small thing before I go and do some stuff, but I’ve been seeing that my lack of activity at EoD and me “lurking” is being used as a point against me. At about 3 PM (2 hours before EoD1) I was at a track meet and I simply stopped viewing the thread from there. Prob could have compromised on someone tbh, but I think my options were Ryu and Antonio? Regardless, Antonio was clearly in the lead and the biggest counterwagon at the time I remember only had one vote on it

Also, I saw people citing that scum would want Tom to post more
...
Literally look at his profile page, he hasn’t been online in about a day. That’s why he’s inactive at this moment, he just isn’t here

given that you dad and i are all town, who's mafia?

 

[iLoveYou]

i think if you want the best chance at lowering KP we should lynch mog

I agree that she is very suspicious. Why isn't she posting ? Why is she only active near the end of Day One when she has to make a vote ?

 

[Dolby]

i think if you want the best chance at lowering KP we should lynch mog

- - - Post Merge - - -



given that you dad and i are all town, who's mafia?

I’m just gonna for the purposes of the question assume that this could be true, but I am very far sold on you being town.

Still feel that Vampessa/Tom is more than possible. I’m kinda tempted to add Trundle to this list for a simple lack of effort, and he’s a known busser as well. Mog, Gig, and Jacob would fit best for the last slots I guess

Of course, this is all ****ed up if I’ve choose the wrong person in Tom/Antonio to be scum

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Tbh I think I'mma vote mog, she's been coasty af the whole game

 

[Dolby]

Does anyone else think Dolby's post against me looks like a panicked OMGUS
Like I'll admit, my reads were rushed and not backed up properly. Nor will I ever back them up properly, because if I had time to do that I would've joined as a regular player and not a replacement. But idk it just feels a bit desperate?

- - - Post Merge - - -

And @Trundle thats fair reasoning, in my opinion toadsworthy kill seems more like someone trying to frame Ness tho

OMGUS? Sure, call it that. But why would I be panicked by that reads list of all things as scum

 

[cornimer]

OMGUS? Sure, call it that. But why would I be panicked by that reads list of all things as scum

- - - Post Merge - - -

I mean > : (

 

[EpicGamer12]

Does anyone else think Dolby's post against me looks like a panicked OMGUS
Like I'll admit, my reads were rushed and not backed up properly. Nor will I ever back them up properly, because if I had time to do that I would've joined as a regular player and not a replacement. But idk it just feels a bit desperate?

- - - Post Merge - - -

And @Trundle thats fair reasoning, in my opinion toadsworthy kill seems more like someone trying to frame Ness tho

Yeah I was going to include that in my post to leverage my POV but I forgot to mention it.

 

[Dolby]

...
Toadsworthy literally townlocked Ness for that interaction. Why would Ness kill him for that reason as scum

 

[cornimer]

And tbh I'm not opposed to a mog lynch. She seems to be playing the exact same way as in RHOM where she was TP.

- - - Post Merge - - -

...
Toadsworthy literally townlocked Ness for that interaction. Why would Ness kill him for that reason as scum

Yeah that's why I think its more likely an attempt to frame Ness than Ness himself doing it

 

[Dolby]

And tbh I'm not opposed to a mog lynch. She seems to be playing the exact same way as in RHOM where she was TP.

- - - Post Merge - - -



Yeah that's why I think its more likely an attempt to frame Ness than Ness himself doing it

Oops, misread

 

[Ghostkid]

Im coasting because im still confused about they game...im saving myself from embarrassment.