Mafia Call the Ships to Port: Game Thread - END GAME - TOWN VICTORY!

[PunchyTheCat]

Ok I had this thing planned for a while now, been waiting for Tina to confirm that this wouldn't break a rule
Wait... ok. My flavor text mentions a lover. She was apparently sent away on the ship. After I die, the lighthouse closes, and ghosts will haunt the island. That's why I'm a "Time Bomb" (thanks for that wording Tina :/). The Veteran part of my role is caused by my paranoia. My theory is that someone is a Lyncher, my lover trying to lynch me, so I can be with her in the afterlife or smthn. On to the rainbow of reads.

 

[Ghostkid]

Ok I had this thing planned for a while now, been waiting for Tina to confirm that this wouldn't break a rule
Wait... ok. My flavor text mentions a lover. She was apparently sent away on the ship. After I die, the lighthouse closes, and ghosts will haunt the island. That's why I'm a "Time Bomb" (thanks for that wording Tina :/). The Veteran part of my role is caused by my paranoia. My theory is that someone is a Lyncher, my lover trying to lynch me, so I can be with her in the afterlife or smthn. On to the rainbow of reads.

This still explains nothing punchy

 

[Kamzitty]

Ok I had this thing planned for a while now, been waiting for Tina to confirm that this wouldn't break a rule
Wait... ok. My flavor text mentions a lover. She was apparently sent away on the ship. After I die, the lighthouse closes, and ghosts will haunt the island. That's why I'm a "Time Bomb" (thanks for that wording Tina :/). The Veteran part of my role is caused by my paranoia. My theory is that someone is a Lyncher, my lover trying to lynch me, so I can be with her in the afterlife or smthn. On to the rainbow of reads.

If any of that is true, I don't see how you would be a blue role? That sounds more like a yellow role to me?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Or is it an orange role idk but either way that doesn't sound like town

 

[N e s s]

Ok I had this thing planned for a while now, been waiting for Tina to confirm that this wouldn't break a rule
Wait... ok. My flavor text mentions a lover. She was apparently sent away on the ship. After I die, the lighthouse closes, and ghosts will haunt the island. That's why I'm a "Time Bomb" (thanks for that wording Tina :/). The Veteran part of my role is caused by my paranoia. My theory is that someone is a Lyncher, my lover trying to lynch me, so I can be with her in the afterlife or smthn. On to the rainbow of reads.

Can you possibly tell me how you got that theory of the Messenger being something like a JoaT? No pressure buddy I just want to know

 

[PunchyTheCat]

Can you possibly tell me how you got that theory of the Messenger being something like a JoaT? No pressure buddy I just want to know

I thought that the messenger was one of the JoaT options, like framing and Rbing.

 

[N e s s]

I thought that the messenger was one of the JoaT options, like framing and Rbing.

But how did you get that idea in the first place?

- - - Post Merge - - -

and especially, why think that the basis for the Messenger is that it would be a scum JoaT and not jut a regular joat

 

[iLoveYou]

Omg these new roles are giving me such a headache. Remember back when times were simpler ? We only had Vigilantes, Veterans, Doctors & Detectives. Then we had mafia goons, a framer and a roleblocker.

What would be the purpose of finding a "lover" and joining them in the afterlife ? Are you attached to another player in this game that will automatically die with you or something ? Seriously I don't understand any of this at all.

 

[Jacob]

Just read everything. Red flags:

Can the det invest- oh right Toads is dead

Laughable attempt at trying to sound confident in "someone investigate my role then you'll see." There isn't really another explanation to this post beyond that, it wasn't really funny

How many times have I scumslipped as town?!

This is another scum-slip and more like a claim if you ask me. You don't call your actions "scum slipping" if you aren't scum, as town he probably would've said like "how many times have I messed up?" or also not posted this at all because again, it wasn't really funny.

can u stop with the personal insults pls ty

what im trying to say is that punchys role sounds plausible if u think about it from the perspective of a host. its doesnt seem to be just cobbled together from nothing, it actually has a purpose for town, while the bomb doesnt make sense for a scum player to have. the only way i could see the role being scum is if the bomb did smth that could only benefit scum, like kill a random blue role, and punchy withheld that information. i can see where ur coming from when u add in his actions over the past couple of days, but sussing him over his role is honestly a bad idea.

I think someone brought this point up before but in case I misread something, I doubt tina would give mafia safe-claims without them having some sort of foreseeable possibility of existing. Otherwise mafia wouldn't be safe trying to claim them. That's why we rely on his slips more than the mechanics of his claim.

I CAN NOT DENY THESE FACTS
##Surrender

The surrender part was shady

---

Something else I found kinda weird

However, I will confirm that players who do not vote today will be modkilled.

REEEE I DIDN'T VOTE I THOUGHT THERE WAS ANOTHER DAY.

Why would Tina let Dad live? It's a little eerie as Tina might've thought modkilling scum would be OP for town, but I could just be paranoid

Did anyone else not vote?

 

[Geoni]

i was saying that there's a reason both dad and i are alive, and i'm quite sure that it's because they know that dad is the only ones really trying to lead a lynch on me

That's the reason we're alive? Not the bluesniping?

- - - Post Merge - - -

FYI if Vanessa is mafia her read on Runeraider is probably just a means to throw a townie under the bus once she dies. ^^

A very specific point to swoop in and air. I stg if you are Rune are mafia good job lmao.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

But how did you get that idea in the first place?

- - - Post Merge - - -

and especially, why think that the basis for the Messenger is that it would be a scum JoaT and not jut a regular joat

I DIDNT SAY THAT GO READ THE POST :angry:

 

[Jacob]

It's a little eerie as Tina might've thought modkilling scum would be OP for town

I forgot to back this up with this:

I take other factors into account that players in the game may not be aware of.

*Referring to Modkilling*

 

[Geoni]

@Jacob I hit her up on discord and pleaded and she said my activity balances the lack of voting out. But just this once.

 

[EpicGamer12]

That's the reason we're alive? Not the bluesniping?

- - - Post Merge - - -



A very specific point to swoop in and air. I stg if you are Rune are mafia good job lmao.

lol i'm not that good at being mafia

 

[Jacob]

@Jacob I hit her up on discord and pleaded and she said my activity balances the lack of voting out. But just this once.

Oh gotcha

 

[N e s s]

I DIDNT SAY THAT GO READ THE POST :angry:

No, that is exactly what you said

2. Messenger could have forgot to send in actions, if the messenger is scum, a theory I have is kind of like a JoaT, with the messenger being able to RB or frame or smth

You said here that "If the messenger is scum I have theory they're like a joat". I'm going to ask you again: what gave you that theory and why would you think that it would be scum and not just a regular JoaT? Don't dodge the question this time Scumlord.

 

[PunchyTheCat]

You said here that "If the messenger is scum I have theory they're like a joat". I'm going to ask you again: what gave you that theory and why would you think that it would be scum and not just a regular JoaT? Don't dodge the question this time Scumlord.

Normal JoaTs would probably have the normal things, like killing, investigating, RBing and saving.

 

[Dolby]

Ok I had this thing planned for a while now, been waiting for Tina to confirm that this wouldn't break a rule
Wait... ok. My flavor text mentions a lover. She was apparently sent away on the ship. After I die, the lighthouse closes, and ghosts will haunt the island. That's why I'm a "Time Bomb" (thanks for that wording Tina :/). The Veteran part of my role is caused by my paranoia. My theory is that someone is a Lyncher, my lover trying to lynch me, so I can be with her in the afterlife or smthn. On to the rainbow of reads.

I?m sorry but why would you ?misread? being a veteran, when it should RIGHT IN YOUR ROLE. Moreover, why would Tina create a role for pretty much the sole purpose of flavor. What even happens when the lighthouse closes

The fact that I even have to explain this is people is soul-crushing

 

[cornimer]

Normal JoaTs would probably have the normal things, like killing, investigating, RBing and saving.

But you listed your "hypothetical scumJoAT" to have RBing and framing which are pretty normal things

 

[PunchyTheCat]

I’m sorry but why would you “misread” being a veteran, when it should RIGHT IN YOUR ROLE. Moreover, why would Tina create a role for pretty much the sole purpose of flavor. What even happens when the lighthouse closes

The fact that I even have to explain this is people is soul-crushing

the "ghosts" come in to haunt the town. How did I MISREAD being a Veteran lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

But you listed your "hypothetical scumJoAT" to have RBing and framing which are pretty normal things

for the noobs who quite possibly didn't even think about a scum JoaT

 

[cornimer]

for the noobs who quite possibly didn't even think about a scum JoaT

The question here is why did YOU think of scum JoaT? It's not a very common thing