Audie has to be my favorite new villager, and one of my favorites overall. Her name being associated with the Youtube grandma is cute, and I really like the vibrancy of the colors in her design and how she looks overall.
I didn't like Raymond too much at first given his dull colors, but after having him move in from my campsite, I enjoy him a lot, as it's hard to dislike villagers when I spend time around them and get ~attached~.
My third favorite has to be Reneigh, and I'm a little surprised at how low she's scoring in this poll. It's the small things in her design that make me like her so much, like her earrings, undercut, and tiny dots under her eyes.
Judy is just gorgeous. I love pastel, cutesy villagers, so she's just my cup of tea. Being the only villager (that I know of) with an ombre sort of body color, she stands out so much from other villagers, not to mention her huge anime eyes.
Now for my thoughts on the other new villagers- Sherb is cute, and I think he'd be nice on a winter themed town, with Fang, Whitney, Sprinkles, etc cetera. Dom is really endearing, given his super cute design and contrasting jock personality; Nintendo has DESTROYED gender roles with that sheep. I really like Megan's face, as she looks like the newer care bear designs, and definitely seems like the most huggable new villager, besides Dom. Cyd's design is the only one that doesn't appeal to me too much, given that I don't care for elephants a lot and he lacks a lot of very distinct features the other new villagers have. I like his purple mohawk, though. I feel like I would like him a lot more if some small tweaks to his design were added, like a golden piercing to really top off his punk look, also, piercings seem to be exclusive to female villagers.
Overall, every single one of the new villagers has a memorable design and each one has their own appeal- Audie with her attention-grabbing colors and wardrobe, Raymond looking like the biggest nerd on the island, Sherb being simple, yet adorable, and Cyd looking like he'd shove you in a locker, but only if you asked nicely.