I've posted 3-4 relevant posts into the game so far and it's only Day 2. I literally contributed as much as possible during Day 1 putting out my opinion based on player's behavior. Lynching me for "trying to hide in the shadows" seems incredibly ******** to me. Tom is pushing me like he used to when he was scum and wanted me out before I caught on to him. I can't really remember how Minties plays, but I would say that Tom and Minties are scum trying to control the game from a "all hail the experienced player" POV. I made one joke post that was hardly even a joke right when the game started, all the ones before that were completely pre game. Tom even ADMITTED he didn't know which of my posts were pre or post game start. What does that show? He didn't do the research. He's either scum and trying to get me out early or he is a poor town player. From the amount of effort he has put into his posts onto me, obviously pushing with a cause, we can likely cross out the latter. I know my early game Tom picks. I'll try to post more after I sleep and get to university tomorrow.
...But Minties is 50/50 scum/town because of her douse and save claim? And Tom was pushing you because of your sus behavior though... okay...
(part 1)
I'm not sure quite what you expected from me in Day 1. You guys are playing as if the amount I post plus or minus 5 determines whether or not I'm scum. What did you want me to do? I didn't find scum and guess who didn't either? YOU. What the heck did you do other than accuse me? What did I do other than accuse m30w_ as an attempt to get the game to steer from lynching an inactive.
I find it funny that you hop on me being "fishy" even though you haven't even commented on anything I've said yet. What makes me fishy? You saw me as scum last game I played and you know how I play.
RUSSIAN RED MAFIA YOU SCUMMY PIECE OF TRASH (AND COUNTLESS OTHERS)
And yes, I did forget that because I HAVE SO MUCH SCHOOL WORK TO DO but I'm actually trying my best. I haven't avoided pointing suspicions at anyone. That's how you know I'm not scum. My scum play is terrible and it just avoids pointing fingers for as long as possible because I know when I die those people are cleared as town. I'm aggressive and accusatory as town, and you know that. You're just pushing me like this because a) you lied about being doused (btw if there is a doctor that can confirm they DIDN'T protect Minties, that's a confirmed scum kill) or b) you're just salty Monroe. I'm not being quiet.
- - - Post Merge - - -
(part 2)
Lists like that are exactly what mafia players do to try to prove they are helping town. You suck at mafia and I'm going to get you lynched.
- - - Post Merge - - -
(part 3)
Yes, sorry I don't post crap once every 5 minutes but actually take the effort to put together a drawn out post
Massive post... time for some dissection.
Part one, you basically say no one is scumhunting and use that as an excuse for not helping. You didn't seem to help anyone with reads or give opinions, you just defend yourself and randomly accuse people for them accusing you. (if that makes sense)
Part two sounds like you're going to revenge lynch. Who does a revenge lynch? Shtty town, or shtty mafia. So whatever you are, you're shtty at it.
Part three is either an excuse for not posting, or unrelated and shtposting.
responses to your ******** post in bold
'your ******** post' lmao
There's not much to go by here, other than you're attacking meow now.
Sorry, Monroe's salt is rubbing off on me
Shtpost
I'm not sure what you mean hang up to be perfectly honest. But if you want my thoughts on Monroe here they are:
- Very salty towards me and pushing me super hard, very common of her in games where she is scum and wants me dead before I properly call her out.
- Claimed that she was protected from being doused by "someone who knows I die a lot night 1". The only people that would know that are me, Tom, and oath2order, and I'm not the doctor. I believe it to be a fake claim at the moment, although we will see in time.
- Very blindly supportive of Tom even though she usually hates Tom's mafia posts.
Trundle basically called out a valuable blue role.... not gonna go any further
I believe he is scum. I already made 4 billion posts on why I believe him to be scum. If I think he is scum, then I vote for him. That is how MAFIA is SUPPOSED TO BE PLAYED. If everyone brought up their own points and stopped bandwagoning, we would find scum a lot faster in games.
This post is hard to get anything out of. And 4 bil posts? Barely even 4 posts before this.
1) I suspect Tom because of his behaviour. It is the only thing I can go off of right now because only Starry has been lynched so far and no one else has died. As I've said before, I've played so many games with Tom. Most older players try super hard to get me out early when they are mafia because they know I'm going to call them out and stop their team from winning, which is exactly what they are trying to do right now. His basis for thinking I'm scum is a) only posting 4 times during Day 1 (which is actually quite common for me to lay back Day 1 as I know it's not worth putting that much effort into, I can cite countless games I do this as townie if you want), b) Not somehow magically lynching scum right away. Both of these points are literally nothing and he is instantly ASSUMING I am scum for little to no reason. It would be perfectly reasonable for him to be suspicious of me, but outright believing me to be scum and pushing me is completely baseless and scummy. That's why I think he is scum.
2) I don't know if you're scum or just a dumb town, but I made a post on you day 1 because I thought your posts were scummy and I didn't want to follow a bandwagon on an inactive. This created more option for town to vote even though I didn't execute my post very well at all and people brushed it aside.
3) I did make a case for someone else to be lynched. It was not a joke accusation. You passing it off as a joke accusation is, again, pretty suspicious. Anything anyone says in these games can be used for or against them.
Not much to make off this post, other than Trundle pushing Tom. And you haven't really stated why Tom is scum. I mean, yes Tom accusing you with little info is sus, but since that was D1 (I think, correct me if I'm wrong) that was a sht-accusation. Literally everything D1 is shtty.
(part 1)
Never said I'm the strongest town player, I just said you and Tom both enjoy targeting my early. I honestly don't know about you Minties, I think you're coming off as scum, although you just made a post that I mostly agree with. Although I still think it's very possible you're scum, especially with how you and Tom are interacting.
- - - Post Merge - - -
(part 2)
Also, if you have any questions for me, ask away. I don't feel like I should have any reason to defend myself as there has been nothing of substance put on me so far yet. I just want more people to actually post, holy crap.
Part 1, convincing everyone you're town and Tom is sus.
Part 2 seems like townie behavior. With the previous posts I'm undecided; you could be faking it though.
Well, in order to disprove it, a doctor needs to out themselves. There's also a good chance the doctor is too shy or afraid of dying to step up, etc. I've claimed protection N1 as mafia in older games before. It generally worked a bit better when the games were bigger.
Hard for me to extract info from this post
Me being suspicious of someone is not equal to them being scum. I aggressively push people because people tend to slip up and reveal information that proves them mafia more than a very mild passive aggressive suspicion would. We have pretty much nothing to go off of this game so far so I'm making the best of what I have.
Um... when someone's considered sus by a vet player, and the vet seems semi-trustable that game, they're often lynched and usually turn out scum. So, in a way, the first sentence is sorta false. Second sentence.... he's scumhunting. Third sentence makes me believe the scum-hunting tactic is fake. What about Tom/Danny and Panda/Ayayayayay; or are you just ignoring the tennis match between them? Right there is a ton of info to go by. I can see definite sides forming: Pandy/Ayayayay/Trundle and Tom/Danny/Minties. In my honest opinion, lynching Trundle will show who's 'team' seems to be the least trustworthy; and even if he is town and lynched, he hasn't helped town much other than defending himself, and trying to prove Tom is scum.
.
