If you could date one islander, who would it be - and why?

[Romaki]

You know, the issue really isn't the humanized animals (look at BoJack Horseman), it's the fact that they're all so childlike and aromantic. I do love certain villagers more than others, but in a way that you'd love your kid.

That being said, ignoring the question, I'd like to see more mature-acting villagers. I always thought Apollo is pretty cool, but that's mostly due to the anime.

 

[namiieco]

fuschia is hot, fauna is adorable (no im not into deers....)
cherry, lolly and kid cat too

 

[Steampunk Mage]

Chief. I love femboys. <3

 

[itscharles]

Chief. I love femboys. <3

how is he a femboy steampunk mage are you ok

 

[Sanaki]

fuschia is hot, fauna is adorable (no im not into deers....)
cherry, lolly and kid cat too

excuse me, hot?

 

[Maiana]

these replies got me crying -

anywho, not saying i'd date this villager, but i'd love to be besties with tammy <3

 

[marea]

I would take Blair and Marshal in a shopping spree. They sent me lots of cute stuff in NL and i trust their sense of fashion.
I hope that is what you meant by taking them on a date.

excuse me, hot?

meant to say she is hot pink, maybe? XD

 

[John Wick]

Teddy. He's tall, muscular and furry. I'd bounce up and down on his knees and call him Daddy for sure.

Getting into Sons of Anarchy territory here.

 

[Larimar]

OP specifically mentions the personality types of the villagers so I think the dating aspect is less on the animal side lmao
I kinda imagine this question more as like "if an animal with a certain personality was personified/humanized who would you date"

Regardless though this is an entertaining thread, I'm also aromantic anyway so I wouldn't date any of the villagers, but I'd choose Vesta to go antique and thrift shopping with

 

[BlueFlameAngel]

how is he a femboy steampunk mage are you ok

LOL i am DYING

 

[M_Rat]

You know, the issue really isn't the humanized animals (look at BoJack Horseman), it's the fact that they're all so childlike and aromantic. I do love certain villagers more than others, but in a way that you'd love your kid.

That being said, ignoring the question, I'd like to see more mature-acting villagers. I always thought Apollo is pretty cool, but that's mostly due to the anime.

I totally understand that. I feel that way about Celeste. She's adorable!

 

[Steampunk Mage]

how is he a femboy steampunk mage are you ok

He looks like a chick; isn't the definition of femboy supposed to be a dude who looks like a lady?

 

[Pink Issyboo]

Isabelle, Sable, or Reese.

 

[Corrie]

I'm no furry but maybe Marshal.

 

[a sprout]

none broski
the islanders act more like children than anything
I want to take them all out for ice cream bc they deserve it

 

[Bcat]

...I used to have a crush on Moose in city folk.

 

[Fruitcup]

Tom Nook cause he'd be my sugar daddy and he has all the weeds.

 

[capnport]

When I was younger and first got ACNL, I thought that I was a cishet girl, and decided that Rodeo was my new boyfriend. I've since learned that I'm not actually attracted to boys, but maybe I'd go out with Rodeo for the nostalgia.

 

[Raayzx]

Beau :flushed:

 

[capnport]

Also @ the people who are saying "this is weird they're animals"- they're anthropomorphic and sentient. Harkness test, man.