If you had an Island of only one personality, what would it be?

[. Rarity .]

So which single personality could you have an entire island of? it would probably be Smug or Lazy for me.

 

[local korok]

That’s a hard one, a lot of my favorite villagers are peppy but I can only hear about being a pop star so many times before I want to never talk to them again. So maybe smug as well? Or normal…or uchi?

This is a hard question

 

[angelcat621]

Normal types for sure. They're my favorite type and I could pretend to have a big group of nerdy normals in an island wide book club, led by Mitzi of course.

 

[themysterybidder]

Jocks! I would sacrifice all other personalities for King Buck!

 

[oliv]

Normal or lazy! They are nice and funny

 

[Argo]

Personality-wise uchi villagers are by far my favorite. However they usually have my least favorite designs.

 

[ellienoise]

I would go for their designs, and by far peppy villagers are my favorite. There is always an imbalance in my towns, because I can't help myself and get way too many peppys. Right now I have Dotty, Ruby and Bianca in the town I'm working on. I do love color coordinated villager lineups, and pink is my favorite color. So I present you with my dream pink peppy town lineup:

 

[Muna]

Lazy. There are so many cute lazy villagers and I love this personality type.

 

[QueenCobra]

Sisterly/Uchi. They may be snarky, with a tough outer shell, but deep down, they're sweethearts. Some of my favorite villagers (like Shari) are sisterly, so it works out perfectly.

 

[. Rarity .]

I would go for their designs, and by far peppy villagers are my favorite. There is always an imbalance in my towns, because I can't help myself and get way too many peppys. Right now I have Dotty, Ruby and Bianca in the town I'm working on. I do love color coordinated villager lineups, and pink is my favorite color. So I present you with my dream pink peppy town lineup:
View attachment 606630

What a unique group, of pretty pop star girls. I love the flow of pink you have going on ♡

 

[azurill]

I would go with either all jocks or all cranky villagers.

 

[michealsmells]

Normal, because Normal villagers never manage to annoy me. Everyone else does something that ends up messin' me up, whether that be the Smugs sending me fake paintings or the Snooty acting like they better than me. Jocks aren't my vibe even if I love them and, while I love Lazy villagers and have bug-based island lore... they do be saying the same exact things over and over and over again!

So yeah, probably Normal. It might end up being a pretty boring island but its my pretty boring island.

 

[S.J.]

I imagine it would be normal villagers, because I'm boring like that! I tend to have more normal and peppy villagers on my island than other personality types, so I wouldn't be surprised if I accidentally ended up with a town full of normal types!

I'd love to see a town of just cranky villagers, though.

 

[Xara]

Normal! Normal is my favourite personality; a good chunk of my favourite villagers are normal, and I think the majority of the normal villagers' designs are so adorable!! There've been times where I've had 5+ normal villagers because I love and want to have so many of them, so I've actually gotten fairly close to having an all-normal town/island at times LOL

I know some people find the normal villagers boring, but I love how kind, caring, and sometimes sassy they are! They live kind and simple lives, and I love that for them.

 

[Clock]

Cranky, normal or smug.

 

[VernalLapin]

Lazy, they’re so sweet, pure and chill.

 

[Tsukuri_Yukimura]

It’s hard to choose between lazy and smug for me but I like more lazy villagers than smug so I’d go lazy

 

[Briar]

It would most likely be normal for me, and I think smug would be my second choice. There are just so many cute normal villagers that I love. And the villagers I'd pick for the island would probably be:

Lily- She's one of my favorite villagers, and I already have her on my island, so she's a given. I love her color scheme, and I feel like she just looks so cute and happy.
Chevre- I used to have her on my island, and I adore her. I'd be happy to have her again. She has a really sweet and gentle vibe to her.
Eunice- Eunice is an old favorite. I had her in my town in the original Animal Crossing Game, and I'll always have a soft spot for her. Not a big fan of her laundromat house in ACNH though. I preferred her older interior style, which gave me the feeling of a grandma's house.
Marina- Like Lily, I have her on my island currently. She's my favorite octopus villager, and I love her pink color.
Ione- She's one of my favorites of the newer villagers. Her starry tail is really cool, and her color scheme in general is pretty.
Savannah- I just like the fact that she's a zebra. She's one of my favorite horse villagers for sure.
Kiki- I loved the movie Kiki's Delivery Service as a child, so it's no surprise that I'd like a black cat villager named Kiki.
Caroline- Her bold coloring is fun. I've had her in previous games, so I'd be happy to have her again.
Margie- I don't usually give the elephant villagers much attention, but I do like Margie a lot.
Gladys- I was between Gladys, Gayle, and Gala for the last spot, but I've always liked Gladys, and I think it would be nice to have her on my island.

 

[Croconaw]

This is a hard one, but I’d have to say jock. Though, if you asked me about having an island with one species, I could easily answer that.

 

[ABlueRose]

I'm going with cranky. I love the cranky villagers so much, especially when they start to warm up to you! Smug or normal villagers would be nice too