Marshal or Raymond? Who do you like more?

[That Marshal Fangirl]

If only my exam questions were as easy as this.

 

[Evadere]

I was lucky enough to find Marshal on a NMT island. He's so cute!

 

[Mikaiah]

I think Marshal's super cute but he needs to seriously stop getting offended by half the things Chevre or Marina say to him! They're my darlings >_>

 

[Rosie Moon]

Aww I can't decide but I feel like O'Hare should have been on the same level of popularity as them

View attachment 245992

He's just as cute as them both! He's my preferred smug. But maybe I'm just biased.

I had O’Hare in New Leaf and he was definitely one of my favourite villagers! By the time I actually got Marshal (this was at the height of his popularity) I found that I didn’t actually want him anymore because I was so attached to O’Hare

That being said, I love both Marshal and Raymond, they’re so cute together! I have Raymond and I only wish I had an extra space in my town for Marshal too! Raymond is my favourite though, I love cats and I love guys in suits and glasses sooo yeah

 

[elimaycry]

they're both cute but i prefer Raymond solely bc a friend of mine says i remind them of marshal as I'm a short dude with a grumpy face....

 

[fallenchaoskitten]

I have never liked Marshal. He reminds me Justin Beiber.

I liked Raymond the second I saw his image release prior to launch. I love cat villagers (kabuki and lolly especially but sorry lolly, coco is bae so she is my normal...) and a business cat is just too perfect. So serious and grumpy looking. Like my cat irl... who is black so the colors are similar. =3

 

[Dustbird]

Both are overrated, but Marshal is extremely overrated while Raymond is just overrated.

 

[Mayor Mae]

Marshal.

Raymond reminds me too much of post-season-5 Ryan from The Office. I can’t help but feel like he has the same pretentious personality even though I love smug villagers

 

[Moon Cake]

I like them both but I do prefer Raymond because I really like his design!

 

[Aubrey895]

I would love both lol. But Marshal out of the two. However, Julian is the smug of my choice lol.

 

[Toot]

I feel like they are on equal grounds tbh. One is just new. Raymond will fall into place after a while. Give it time.

 

[meo]

Marshal is the only one I've really had any in-game interaction with. So, I can't really say honestly.
I'm not overly hyped on either. I do like their designs (love albino squirrels and grey cats). I'm not generally into smugs (from NL at least) so that's probably what detracted me away from Marshal in NL. I'm going to give smug another chance to see if I feel different in NH and I'll probably wait for either Marshal/Raymond (since again like the animals/colors) to pop up in my camp/island to give the personality another go.
If I'm still apathetic to it then I'll just have a popular character to make someones day with (hopefully if villager moves are patched by then).

 

[Pixiebelle]

Not super hyped about either but would have to say Raymond, because cat ♡

 

[LaFra]

Marshal

Raymond has a overwhelming design, i prefer a simple idea well implemented imho

"Complicare è facile, semplificare è difficile" Bruno Munari
It's easy to complicate, it's difficult to simplify

 

[Angelwatch]

I’m a cat person. I found Raymond on a random island and now he’s a forever friend.

 

[Paperboy012305]

Raymond easily. I try to like Marshal, but every time I do, I can't do it.

I'm so lucky to have Raymond as my first camper, you had to forcibly move in. (Yes, everyone get jealous that I got that luck on me that day)

 

[thedragmeme]

I personally like Raymond because A, cats are my favorite animal b, Business and formal styles are my aesthetics and C, I find heterochromia fascinating

 

[Kuroh]

Raymond, but they're both awesome!

 

[FireNinja1]

I don't really have a strong preference.

 

[mintellect]

marshal's the original smug, sideswept-hair king and he's always gonna have a special place in my heart. that, and the squirrel villagers are always my favorite. raymond isn't bad!! but he just doesn't do it for me.