Mafia PokéMafia : a small game of mafia - Town Wins

[Dolby]

Well I've seen a post from Antonio and from Hyrule and Dad and you so it might not be contributing but I see some posts. Maybe its because there are lots of newbies but I see posts from Hyrule and I think that was good. I haven't seen post from rhino i think that is longer than a line and so are the others.

But you guys know what i mean when you clash before.it was bordering on fighting but this is tame compared to what I've seen from you guys..

I do have a feeling that one of the scum has to be a veteran. I like to believe that toads is randomizing so I can accept the idea of both newbies as scum. But until then, I am sus of all the older players (Dad, Dolby and Antonio)..

You know I actually like this even though it's pretty weak and I can't really explain why, except that I like the first paragraph specifically because it shows what she's reading off of

- - - Post Merge - - -

Well I've seen a post from Antonio and from Hyrule and Dad and you so it might not be contributing but I see some posts. Maybe its because there are lots of newbies but I see posts from Hyrule and I think that was good. I haven't seen post from rhino i think that is longer than a line and so are the others.

But you guys know what i mean when you clash before.it was bordering on fighting but this is tame compared to what I've seen from you guys..

I do have a feeling that one of the scum has to be a veteran. I like to believe that toads is randomizing so I can accept the idea of both newbies as scum. But until then, I am sus of all the older players (Dad, Dolby and Antonio)..

You know I actually like this even though it's pretty weak and I can't really explain why, except that I like the first paragraph specifically because it shows what she's reading off of

 

[Hyrule_Crossing]

Hyrule, votes are already locked.

This was a towny post in that it lacked attention to a voting deadline in a genuine manner.

Oh right, lol

 

[toadsworthy]

cop and watcher will be added to the game tomorrow when i feel better...

in case you didn't realize, its day 1. Vote for who to lynch, voting ends tomorrow at 7pm EST

 

[Biancasbotique]

hyrule, what do you think about the other players? i know you don't have a lot to go on since you're new but what are your impressions of us so far

- - - Post Merge - - -

cop and watcher will be added to the game tomorrow when i feel better...

in case you didn't realize, its day 1. Vote for who to lynch, voting ends tomorrow at 7pm EST

day 1 is supposed to be 48 right

 

[Hyrule_Crossing]

hyrule, what do you think about the other players? i know you don't have a lot to go on since you're new but what are your impressions of us so far

So far I think everyone’s really nice lol

 

[Geoni]

I was saying that you were floundering in the same way I feel I am. We both want to produce accurate reads and no one is putting forward the content to do so (except Hyrule, kinda, but I'm comfortable TLing that). I've said before that I feel you struggle and are weaker as mafia, and really, I feel this is a situation where you struggle to put forward stuff as town due to the sheer lack of anything from other people. This wasn't intended to be a burn or diss or cause for suspicion, but a comment that I felt that it was impossible for us to play the game outside the PR discussion at that point



Eh, it's not so much that I think they're paired, but that they both could be mafia trying to blend in with the noobs



First of all, that effort into digging up Bianca's posts screams so town to me. (Though if you are scum you are definitetely sadistically enjoying seeing me sink into madness considering I'd be the only thread contributor)
Second of all, I don't really think that Bianca progresses outside of the PR roles debate, all she does is piggy back of me at one point and I don't like that



I'd take that +17% chance of catching scum everyday of the weak

I really want to think that Dad is town here, one on a kinda emotional because that means I'm not alone here, but the amount of work he's doing to dig things up really feels like town him

Kinda sounds like you want to tr me for the floundering because it's a mindmeld in that I'm trying to spin straw into gold with what little content there was upon entry that didn't purely have to do with the prs. I say mindmeld but it's only partial since I started digging into the players of the game before you did, you were mostly complaining until recently when you got specific about Antonio and Bianca. I know I'm nitpicking at this NAI thing but I genuinely would expect you to read it as a towntell. You seem to regard it as that at this point, at least.

Something about Bianca worries me in that she could be low hanging fruit, especially considering her progression on figuring out what the difference is between tracker and watcher seeming authentic but posts following this one are doing something different that I will respond to in a moment.

Btw you say Bianca piggybacked you when she was openly considering the other options. If you want a true piggyback it's Zelda voting cop/watcher with the justification I had to get out of her. I want your thoughts on that Zelda post.

 

[Dolby]

Btw you say Bianca piggybacked you when she was openly considering the other options. If you want a true piggyback it's Zelda voting cop/watcher with the justification I had to get out of her. I want your thoughts on that Zelda post.

It's definetely bad, but I could see a noob of either alignment making that post

 

[Biancasbotique]

I am thinking about the game and of course we know that cop and watcher will be added. The question I have is will we know what scum chose?

 

[Geoni]

I never really played meticulously looking at tracker or watcher (as I said, those roles are confusing to me) and I never really payed attention before on who had this trait before so I don't know the mechanics. But I have a feeling that toads might not allow both newbies to be scum (that would be painful) but then again, i dont know if toads is randomizing because I do randomize.

I don't think I have seen posts from other players. The one that participates of course is Dolby, Dad, Hyrule, Antonio. That would be something if this is a Dad/Dolby team up. This is the first time that i have not seen them clash in the beginning so I am sus of that. This is not typical of their interaction.

God this post is so oddly worded, it's jarring. Maybe it's how you word that first sentence and the sudden jump from discussing tracker+watcher and talking about human balancing which then leads up to you airing a concern about me and Dolby being the mafia. Which...lol that is a balance issue on the other end of the scale if you are going to argue Toads human balances.

I do kinda dislike that Dolby doesn't want to outright argue with me for the sake of reading others and not tunnel because he can critically read me while reading everyone else but this also fits your argument and says I am not fighting with him which is only half true. I've not been fighting but heavy disagreements have happened.

 

[Biancasbotique]

I am medicated my thoughts are all over the place

 

[Geoni]

First line is just weird

Bold, I think that I've demonstrated in the past that I can "clash" with a stronger teammate while similitaniously turning it into a referendum on our respective towniness through a proxy town v town lynch

And we honestly kinda have clashed tbh, he tried to lead a counter to my cop/watcher proposal

"The one that participates is Antonio"-Dad do you doubt me now lol

If you haven't seen posts from other players you should look for them

How are Antonio and Hyrule participating because I think both me and Dad have word counts this game greater than everyone else (exempting each other) combined?

Why has Antonio, who only recently put forward a substantial post, been contributing

For reference I hadn't read this until I made my own response a moment ago and us feeling the same way about the first line and that us not fighting is wrong is kinda...yikes.

Not entirely sold on that partnership and I pushing it isn't going to excuse you from reading the new folks. Sure that's a bit unfair of me to say already but I'm wanting plenty of thoughts on them.

 

[Hyrule_Crossing]

I’m exited for Day 1. It’s my first mafia game so don’t expect me to be professional lol

- - - Post Merge - - -

Also still thinking of my thoughts on who to lynch

 

[Geoni]

Well I've seen a post from Antonio and from Hyrule and Dad and you so it might not be contributing but I see some posts. Maybe its because there are lots of newbies but I see posts from Hyrule and I think that was good. I haven't seen post from rhino i think that is longer than a line and so are the others.

But you guys know what i mean when you clash before.it was bordering on fighting but this is tame compared to what I've seen from you guys..

I do have a feeling that one of the scum has to be a veteran. I like to believe that toads is randomizing so I can accept the idea of both newbies as scum. But until then, I am sus of all the older players (Dad, Dolby and Antonio)..

Yeah that seems like a tonally pure explanation of the four active people she has listed but 'has to be' one of the older players and yet you are buckling to the idea that it could be two newbs seems like hedging so if you're honest about that consideration I want thoughts on newbies moving forward.

- - - Post Merge - - -

It's definetely bad, but I could see a noob of either alignment making that post

Wishy-washy stance here. This doesn't help unravel my tinfoil, only tightens it really.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I am thinking about the game and of course we know that cop and watcher will be added. The question I have is will we know what scum chose?

Asking in green helps!

 

[Biancasbotique]

in this game, i like to believe that toads randomizes, but just a gut feeling that because of the sea of newbies, that toads has to include a veteran to make it balanced?

idk how toads does his games so if we are to modkill or lynch newbies, i will be much more confident in that approach if toads randomizes

 

[Hyrule_Crossing]

Oh just a question.
Lets say someone got lynched. After saying goodbye, could they check the game (without posting obviously) and see how stuff is going?

 

[Geoni]

in this game, i like to believe that toads randomizes, but just a gut feeling that because of the sea of newbies, that toads has to include a veteran to make it balanced?

idk how toads does his games so if we are to modkill or lynch newbies, i will be much more confident in that approach if toads randomizes

I feel like I have to deal with this every game and it gets tiresome after a while. Human balancing is bad hosting in the long run. Is there any history of Toads doing it that makes you want to keep bringing it up?

- - - Post Merge - - -

Oh just a question.
Lets say someone got lynched. After saying goodbye, could they check the game (without posting obviously) and see how stuff is going?

Not host but traditionally you get put in an observers quicktopic when you die. You're not banned from reading and that apies in every place I've ever played don't like posts that have game content as an added courtesy even though that isn't a rule yet.

- - - Post Merge - - -

Applies in*

 

[Hyrule_Crossing]

Oh ok, thanks!

 

[toadsworthy]

I'll let it be 48 hrs since I was late, day 1 ends tomorrow at 7pm est

 

[Geoni]

Toads have you prodded Dragonboy?

Also I was hoping people would be around and posting by this hour but I've got to go to bed so I'll park my vote on ZeldaJune and see what fun unravels while I sleep.

 

[dragonboy]

Hi I live in England so ill be texting at night only cos I have a club at night